Jesus might have EXISTED, but that certainly does not mean that the hearsay about his magic/divinity has any truth to it, nor that their is a magic invisible Hindu-free place up in the sky that you'll magically go if you simply "believe" in a 2000 year-old dead guy, one can argue.
Besides, their is no more evidence for this divinity than the divinity of any other of the 5000+ claimed gods throughout history. Paul just expanded on a myth - so try to ease people's thanatophobia.
I try to explain to people that mastering Philosophy is the first step in understanding ourselves and the world and Earth around us.
Once you reach the limits of Philosophy then you are logically forced to explore Science.
Once you reach the limits of both Philosophy and Science then you must choose from the following:
1 - to pick a religion and become a Theist.
2 - to avoid organized religion and become a Deist.
3 - to refrain from making a choice and become an Agnostic.
4 - to fight against God and become an Atheist.
I have chosen #2 after many years in the Catholic Church.
However I still go to Mass twice at Easter and once at Christmas.