Zone1 Should the Burka be banned?

Should the Burka be banned?

  • Yes

  • No

  • I have no opinion in this case


Results are only viewable after voting.
there is no right to disguise yourself in public
In Germany, disguising yourself is not broadly illegal, but it is prohibited in specific situations, such as during public gatherings or if it involves impersonating an official. The legality depends on the context and purpose of the disguise.

Disguises prohibited during public assemblies
A German law from 1985 prohibits disguising one's identity during public demonstrations, rallies, and meetings.
  • Purpose: The law aims to ensure police can identify individuals to maintain public order and hold people accountable for their actions.
  • Context: While enforced, protesters sometimes use items like scarves, sunglasses, and hats to obscure their faces while arguing they are not in full "disguise".
Impersonation of officials is a crime
It is a criminal offense to impersonate an official, such as a police officer or soldier.
  • Military uniforms: While civilians can wear military-style clothing for fashion, it is illegal to wear a uniform that is identical to a current military uniform to impersonate a soldier.
  • Nazi symbols and uniforms: Germany has strict laws prohibiting the use and display of Nazi symbols, signs, and uniforms.
Face coverings while driving
A 2017 law made it illegal to cover one's face while driving.
  • Purpose: This rule ensures that drivers can be identified by speed cameras and police surveillance.
  • Restrictions: The law applies to items like burqas, niqabs, full-face helmets (when not on a motorcycle), and certain types of scarves.
Context-dependent face coverings
Outside of protests, drivers, and officials, the general wearing of face coverings like burqas is a contested issue.
  • There is no nationwide general ban on full-face veils in public spaces.
  • State-level regulations vary, particularly concerning schools and other institutions.
 
In Germany, disguising yourself is not broadly illegal, but it is prohibited in specific situations, such as during public gatherings or if it involves impersonating an official. The legality depends on the context and purpose of the disguise.

Disguises prohibited during public assemblies
A German law from 1985 prohibits disguising one's identity during public demonstrations, rallies, and meetings.
  • Purpose: The law aims to ensure police can identify individuals to maintain public order and hold people accountable for their actions.
  • Context: While enforced, protesters sometimes use items like scarves, sunglasses, and hats to obscure their faces while arguing they are not in full "disguise".
Impersonation of officials is a crime
It is a criminal offense to impersonate an official, such as a police officer or soldier.
  • Military uniforms: While civilians can wear military-style clothing for fashion, it is illegal to wear a uniform that is identical to a current military uniform to impersonate a soldier.
  • Nazi symbols and uniforms: Germany has strict laws prohibiting the use and display of Nazi symbols, signs, and uniforms.
Face coverings while driving
A 2017 law made it illegal to cover one's face while driving.
  • Purpose: This rule ensures that drivers can be identified by speed cameras and police surveillance.
  • Restrictions: The law applies to items like burqas, niqabs, full-face helmets (when not on a motorcycle), and certain types of scarves.
Context-dependent face coverings
Outside of protests, drivers, and officials, the general wearing of face coverings like burqas is a contested issue.
  • There is no nationwide general ban on full-face veils in public spaces.
  • State-level regulations vary, particularly concerning schools and other institutions.
was that AI speaking?
 
i prefer to speak to real people, not to artificial intelligence
Where do you believe google got that from? It came from people. The AI just regurgitates it.

If you had been able to point to an error that would be one thing. But you couldn’t because there weren’t any. So rather than acknowledge what reality is, you dismiss reality instead. That’s not what God wants from us.
 
there is no right to disguise yourself in public
Do you know what reasons the Danes gave for banning burkas?

I don’t believe no disguise was one of the reasons. Maybe you should look at their reasons and see if you agree with their reasons.

Would you be ok with laws that were written to subordinate religion?
 
Where do you believe google got that from? It came from people. The AI just regurgitates it.

If you had been able to point to an error that would be one thing. But you couldn’t because there weren’t any. So rather than acknowledge what reality is, you dismiss reality instead. That’s not what God wants from us.
you are missing the point.

you are in favour of the Burka, I am not.

so let us agree to disagree. 😎
 
you are missing the point.

you are in favour of the Burka, I am not.

so let us agree to disagree. 😎
No. I am in favor of religious freedom and freedom of expression.

Would you like to disagree with that?
 
Well, 1/2 of them have the right, anyway. I don't think the woman, buried up to her shoulders, whose skull is being crushed by boulders, has any choice. Or the 18-year-old whose nose and ears were cut off for trying to escape a brutal marriage. What happens to the woman that stands up for her rights and wears a red mini skirt to the market?
good question! 👍
 
the burka is not a sign of ex.pression, but of op.pression
That's not for you to say. Would you like it if the crucifix was banned because some people saw it as a sign of op.pression?
 
15th post
Back
Top Bottom