Presidential Immunity

[schmidlap]

What none of our libs seem to comprehend is the force of the arguments carefully articulated and well argued in the President’s brief.

There are many things said there which the Court seems to have picked up on.

https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/23/23-939/307578/20240415133854183_USSC%2023-939%20-%20Reply%20Brief%20of%20Petitioner.pdf

Some very interesting and refined points.

For example:

Sadly, many (if not most) of our liberals will not be able to contemplate what it might mean if this SCOTUS makes any decision which is at odds with that holding in Marbury.

President Biden should not be allowed to stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot Trump in the interests of the nation, and then claim presidential immunity, despite your argument.

​

 

[Kilroy2]

The Court is hearing a case today questioning whether Presidential Immunity is absolute. Trump claims that anything done as President is subject to immunity.
Basically, a President is above the law.

Trump says that a President requires immunity so that he can do his job without fearing prosecution for bad decisions.

But if George Bush brought the nation to war based on lies that he was aware were false…..should he be subject to prosecution?
If a President accepts bribes to influence his presidential decisions, should he be prosecuted?
If a President uses his powers to overturn a lawful election, should he be prosecuted?

Trump says that a President requires immunity so that he can do his job without fearing prosecution for bad decisions.

Bad decision just shows intent and motivation but its the action that defines whether it is a crime that can be prosecuted.

This is how Trump gets himself into trouble with statements of absolute immunity. Its all self serving. It makes it hard to in defending him. Difficult for the right wing judges because they know they cannot go with absolute immunity for the president in a criminal trial.

Any person who did what Trump did would be prosecuted and most likely found guilty.

The closest example that can be compared is with Nixon. He resigned. His buddies went to jail

Just because he is president does not give him absolute immunity and it clear that it is talking about civil cases.

Trump was declared the loser, he has no presidential rights to do the things he did

But to make a statement concerning criminal immunity in the same context puts his fellow right wing judges in a bind

So the Nixon case is the hurdle for the current Supreme Court to retain some level of respectability

Nixon would have went to jail but I believe Ford did pardon him which saved him.

Trump dilemma is Biden is not going to pardon him.

So Trump is desperate and will they the Supreme Court save him.
Which really is a bad ideas as it sends the wrong message

 

[BackAgain]

President Biden should not be allowed to stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot Trump in the interests of the nation, and then claim presidential immunity, despite your argument.

​

Stupid you. That’s not the argument, you idiot.

Damn. You libturds are a brainless lot.

 

[schmidlap]

Stupid you. That’s not the argument, you idiot.

Damn. You libturds are a brainless lot.

Trump's bum kissers are devoid of a sense of humor.

One would think that it would be essential.

 

[C_Clayton_Jones]

I just heard Trump make that claim this morning
A President needs immunity to do his job

Stealing classified documents and national security intelligence in violation of the law and refusing to return those documents in violation of court orders isn’t part of a president’s job.

Committing the treasonous crimes of attempting to overturn a presidential election, disenfranchise millions of Americans, and disrupt the peaceful transfer of power aren’t part of a president’s job.

 

[Grumpyolman]

Should FDR have been prosecuted for denying the rights of thousands of Japanese Americans?

 

[Lastamender]

I understand Seal Team Six is poised and ready to assassinate Trump at Biden's order depending on the outcome of this case. Should make for an interesting afternoon.

Biden already killed members of Seal Team Six. You people have goldfish memories.

The White House was forced to delete an Instagram post showing US President Joe Biden meeting with American Special Forces in Israel, which violated national security decorum because the agent's faces were fully visible.


The photo was posted to the White House's official Instagram account Wednesday for hours as it got more than 6,000 likes and about 792 comments. It showed President Biden shaking hands with bearded men sporting camouflage and the American flag. It was a violation of US Department of Defense rules as officially released photos typically have the faces of the agents blurred.



Before it was stricken from the internet, the caption read: “In Israel, President Biden met with first responders to thank them for their bravery and the work they’re doing in response to the Hamas terrorist attacks."

MSN

 

[citygator]

I think they are willing to gum up the works to further delay the trial

Seemingly.

Biden already killed members of Seal Team Six. You people have goldfish memories.

The White House was forced to delete an Instagram post showing US President Joe Biden meeting with American Special Forces in Israel, which violated national security decorum because the agent's faces were fully visible.


The photo was posted to the White House's official Instagram account Wednesday for hours as it got more than 6,000 likes and about 792 comments. It showed President Biden shaking hands with bearded men sporting camouflage and the American flag. It was a violation of US Department of Defense rules as officially released photos typically have the faces of the agents blurred.



Before it was stricken from the internet, the caption read: “In Israel, President Biden met with first responders to thank them for their bravery and the work they’re doing in response to the Hamas terrorist attacks."

MSN

I’ll take “things that didnt happen” for $100 Chuck.

 

[BackAgain]

Trump's bum kissers are devoid of a sense of humor.

One would think that it would be essential.

Oh. So now you’re backpeddling like a bitch because you’re caught.

So unsurprising.

Also, leave your anal fixation with yourself — where it has always resided.

 

[Clipper]

I think they are willing to gum up the works to further delay the trial

The fix is in. The court could have taken this case back in December but refused. Now, they may kick it back down for further arguement ensuring Trump won't go to trial before the election.

Thomas should have recused himself considering his overfed fat ass old lady was in on the plot to overturn the election. Thomas is just as corrupt as Trump is & Alito isn't much better.

 

[C_Clayton_Jones]

For an act he supposedly did while in office, for which he was impeached but not removed from office.

Impeachment is a political – not judicial – process.

It’s ignorant nonsense to argue that a president must first be removed from office via the impeachment process as a ‘prerequisite’ to being subject to criminal prosecution for crimes committed in or out of office.

 

[schmidlap]

Oh. So now you’re backpeddling like a bitch because you’re caught.

So unsurprising.

Also, leave your anal fixation with yourself — where it has always resided.

You lash out hysterically because your worship of the sexual abuser compels you to fantasize that he is above the law.

Most Americans disagree, of course.

Poll Reveals: Majority of Americans Reject Trump’s Claims of Presidential Immunity​

​

 

[BackAgain]

You lash out hysterical

You do tend to do this an awful lot.

because your worship of the sexual abuser

I don’t worship any man. Now get back down on your Potato God.

compels you to fantasize that he is above the law.

Wrong as always. “Above the law” has not a thing in the world to do with the question of Presidential immunity. Damn. You’re woefully ignorant.

Most Americans disagree, of course.

With you? Of course. You’re an idiot.

Poll Reveals: Majority of Americans Reject Trump’s Claims of Presidential Immunity​

​

This isn’t a democratic question, you trite twat.

 

[MarathonMike]

Trump's bum kissers are devoid of a sense of humor.

One would think that it would be essential.

Oh yeah, Schmidlap and his gang of Democrat Stalinists are just a laugh a minute. Y'all the most humorless, angry bunch of mofos I've ever seen.

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Oh yeah, Schmidlap and his gang of Democrat Stalinists are just a laugh a minute. Y'all the most humorless, angry bunch of mofos I've ever seen.

"Stalinist"

You guys sound so stupid, when you talk this way. Like little manbabies.

 

[dudmuck]

More of that opinion parading as fact from the left.

 

[MarathonMike]

"Stalinist"

You guys sound so stupid, when you talk this way. Like little manbabies.

Speaking of angry Stalinists, look who's here!

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Speaking of angry Stalinists, look who's here!

So stupid. I'm embarrassed for you.

 

[BackAgain]

"Stalinist"

You guys sound so stupid, when you talk this way. Like little manbabies.

You are remarkably lacking in self perception, Farty.

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

You are remarkably lacking in self perception, Farty.

Oh look, another manbaby begging for attention.

Sorry, that's all you get.