President Trump reveals his administration is working on NATIONAL RIGHT TO CARRY

[DonGlock26]

Correct, as far as being codified.

I already got that part. We both agree on that.

I'm talking about the right itself and how much our right to keep and bear predates the Constitution and even the DOI, for that matter.

The only reason I raise this point is that too many people on BOTH sides keep trying to promote the idea that our right to keep and bear arms comes from the 2nd Amendment, when it doesn't.

The 2nd Amendment could be repealed tomorrow, and we would still have the right to keep and bear arms that our founders had, even before the Revolutionary War!

It's seen as natural law coming from the Creator. Thomas Hobbes and John Locke wrote about it.

 

[DonGlock26]

You said it wasn't necessary. You have yet to prove that hypothesis.

YOU brought up congress. Are you sundowning?

 

[DonGlock26]

You're nothing but a garden variety imbecile.

Yes, you are.


The Comity Clause, formally known as the Privileges and Immunities Clause (U.S. Constitution, Article IV, Section 2).

What about it, goofy?

 

[Chuz Life]

It's seen as natural law coming from the Creator. Thomas Hobbes and John Locke wrote about it.

Precisely.

So, you see why I wanted to steer away from the idea that our right to keep and bear arms comes from the 2A.

Right?

 

[DonGlock26]

Precisely.

So, you see why I wanted to steer away from the idea that our right to keep and bear arms comes from the 2A.

Right?

I never said that.

 

[80zephyr]

Yes please. When the Dems retake the Senate they can have a merry old time.

The Dems will do it anyway,

 

[Chuz Life]

I never said that.

Great!

I don't think you intended to say the right to keep and bear arms "comes from" the Second Amendment.

However, when you post things like;

Thread 'President Trump reveals his administration is working on NATIONAL RIGHT TO CARRY'

Wednesday at 5:11 PM

The carry permit for law abiding Americans is called the 2nd amendment.
It is time for this to happen.

• DonGlock26
• Replies: 57
• Forum: 2nd Amendment

• 
• 
• 

Post in thread 'President Trump reveals his administration is working on NATIONAL RIGHT TO CARRY'

Wednesday at 9:11 PM

Authorize carry that is already in the Constitution but courts allow states to restrict it.

The 2nd authorizes carry.

• DonGlock26

It does lead some to the idea that the 2A is where the RTKBA comes from.

So, I felt the need to clarify.

 

[DonGlock26]

Great!

I don't think you intended to say the right to keep and bear arms "comes from" the Second Amendment.

However, when you post things like;

Thread 'President Trump reveals his administration is working on NATIONAL RIGHT TO CARRY'

Wednesday at 5:11 PM

The carry permit for law abiding Americans is called the 2nd amendment.
It is time for this to happen.

• DonGlock26
• Replies: 57
• Forum: 2nd Amendment

• 
• 
• 

Post in thread 'President Trump reveals his administration is working on NATIONAL RIGHT TO CARRY'

Wednesday at 9:11 PM

Authorize carry that is already in the Constitution but courts allow states to restrict it.

The 2nd authorizes carry.

• DonGlock26

It does lead some to the idea that the 2A is where the RTKBA comes from.

So, I felt the need to clarify.

Okay. I’m not responsible for the poorly educated.

 

[Chuz Life]

Okay. I’m not responsible for the poorly educated.

It's ok.

I have your six.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

YOU brought up congress. Are you sundowning?

Why can't you answer a simple question? I made that statement about Congress so long ago, I forgot it, since you keep wandering off and not telling me how you propose to solve this dilemma.

 

[Dante]

What about it, goofy?

Try arguing the actual legal issues argued and settled in the court, and not some made up looniness in your warped mind.

 

[DonGlock26]

Why can't you answer a simple question? I made that statement about Congress so long ago, I forgot it, since you keep wandering off and not telling me how you propose to solve this dilemma.

Yes, we've all watched you go from congress to the courts. What are you struggling to say?

Pay attention to what Chuz and I have discussed.

 

[DonGlock26]

Try arguing the actual legal issues argued and settled in the court, and not some made up looniness in your warped mind.

You just post insults like a pre teen girl.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Yes, we've all watched you go from congress to the courts. What are you struggling to say?

Pay attention to what Chuz and I have discussed.

When are you filing your court case so that the Supremes can rule on your contention? Why do you think no one has done it so far?

 

[Chuz Life]

When are you filing your court case so that the Supremes can rule on your contention? Why do you think no one has done it so far?

Let's do a poll to see how many trust the SCOTUS to get it right.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Let's do a poll to see how many trust the SCOTUS to get it right.

Sure! Let's do something completely irrelevant! Knock yourself out!

 

[Chuz Life]

Sure! Let's do something completely irrelevant! Knock yourself out!

Let me make the point against your appeal to authority a little easier for you to grasp.

When the founders and framers took up arms against King George in the Revolutionary War, did they get that right from the Constitution? (Didn't have one yet), from a favorable ruling from the SCOTUS? (Didn't have a SCOTUS), Or from some other source?

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Let me make the point against your appeal to authority a little easier for you to grasp.

When the founders and framers took up arms against King George in the Revolutionary War, did they get that right from the Constitution? (Didn't have one yet), from a favorable ruling from the SCOTUS? (Didn't have a SCOTUS), Or from some other source?

You said:
"Let's do a poll to see how many trust the SCOTUS to get it right."

A poll is about as irrelevant as you can get.