What the hell gives you the idea anyone is being gifted with a free house with this refinancing proposal?
It is extremely ironic you people sit in judgement of others for supposedly being financially irresponsible when you then make statements that demonstrate extreme financial ignorance.
All this proposal is trying to do is LOWER THE INTEREST PAYMENT on a mortgage!
It is not lowering the principal, which was the price they paid for the house. Do you people get that?
The only effect lower interest payments will have is that the banks will make less profit on the loans they made or bought in the secondary market.
Which means that the bank, its depositors, and stockholders are being shafted! DUH!
And why should the borrowers be the only ones to bear the burden?
Imagine you are a banker. You eat, sleep, drink, and shit money. You talk in terms of "LIBOR" and "Inverse floaters", the first thing you do when you wake up every day is check the TED spread.
That's who is on one side of the table.
On the other side of the table is the borrower, middle class white nose picker, who hasn't a clue about any of those things. He doesn't know an ARM from a hole in the wall, but when one is slid across the table, he happily goes for it based on the soothing dulcet tones of the banker's assurances.
Which one bears the most responsibility for making sure the borrower has the ability to pay?
I know you want to say "they both share equal responsibility" just to be a jerk, but the banker knows far, far, far better than the borrower does. Especially in the heat of the global property bubble.
So why should the banker feel NO PAIN when the shit starts blowing up?
Why does the banker get TARP money and the borrower gets no help at all? Why should the investors who incited all this shit be protected from any losses incurred by their own stupidity?
This is some bullshit reasoning you are demonstrating. It certainly isn't Republican reasoning which demands people pay the price of their foolishness. What you are demonstrating is that you only want the most vulnerable side of the table to pay the price for stupidity while you protect the side that had the most inside knowledge of the situation.
And that is bullshit.
Not only that, I can show you undeniable evidence that the banks deliberately put these people into these types of loans precisely to revitalize the lagging re-fi industry. They believed interest rates would go up and so would their profits. They were dead wrong.
A re-fi today means lower interest rates and lower profits. But it still means profits.