If you think old existing jobs are new jobs I have some non exist land I own want to buy it?
Ok kid, i understand what your saying. When those people came back to work they were just reoccupying the jobs they left before. Totally get that. So you can stop repeating it over and over.
The problem is that the non-farm payroll numbers arent intended to be a measure of new jobs. It measures something else entirely. It publishes the number of people on business payrolls, which businesses are legally obligated to report.
Understand? The monthly non-farm payrolls arent a report of new jobs created, theyre a report of how many people businesses currently employ on their payrolls.
Again, your angry because you dont understand the stat your looking at.