For the atmosphere, we have two measures, satellites and balloons, and both showed no warming in the atmosphere in highly correlated fashion despite rising Co2, until 2005 when both were fudged with pathetic excuses.
Orbit wobble was the excuse to fudge the flat line from the satellites into an upward slope, pathetic that IR sensors would change with a few feet of orbit change, because that wouldn't change the data at all.
Shade issues that were constant the whole time were used to fudge the flat line from the balloons into an upward slope, which again is fraud. A constant issue might add or subtract from the entire series, but it would not change a flat line into an upward slope...
ATMOSPHERE NOT WARMING DESPITE RISING Co2
DATA not FUDGE