Originally posted by gop_jeff
NewGuy,
I think it is rather ridculous for you to claim that Catholicism is not a Christian denomination. The Catholic Church preaches the Trinity, the Bible, etc. They have vastly different theological beliefs within that context, and a few beliefs that we would both agree are not Biblical, but to say that Catholics are not Christians is not true.
As I have said before.....
Catholicism IS NOT Christianity.
Catholics CAN be Christians.
There NEEDS to be this distinction.
Catholocism was NEVER a division of Christianity. It was formed AFTER Christ walked the Earth and was SEPERATE from His teachings.
It may have started out as REFERENCING the Bible, but as a religious belief system, it has ALWAYS pitched its power in a human position, REQUIRING supplanting either Mary or a pope (man) in place of God for determining salvation.
Since this did not DERIVE from Christs teachings, and WAS NOT Biblical in origin, it was a parallel origin and a CULT.
It may CLAIM BIBLICAL foundation, but so do a million OTHER cults. Christianity is a FAITH. Catholocism is a RITUAL which USES a misplaced faith which CAN subvert people into replacement theology and replace God with MAN.
However, IF God is NOT replaced by man in the mind and internallized FAITH of the catholic, then they would be a Christian. -Ritualistic practices, or not.
I hope that clarifies the issue.
Catholocism is cultic ritual.
Christianity is a faith.
Catholics CAN be Christians, but it is a shaky area in regard to their faith.