WorldWatcher
Platinum Member
WOW, thanks for such a detailed summary. I don't know if Meese's opinion explains the Law or not.
5. Can the appeals courts say that Jack Smith doesn't have "standing" to appeal, if Cannon is right?
Yes. Which could then trigger an appeal to the SCOTUS.
4. If you are right, the appeals court will rule for Smith, but then it goes to the USSC, where its 50/50 which way it goes. No matter, if Trump wins in November can he or his AG dismiss the case? I would think so.
As President Trump can't directly dismiss the case. Now he can order his AG to dismiss the case. If the AG agrees the AG will withdraw the case. If the AG doesn't agree, then Trump can fire the AG, rinse repeat until he finds a lacky that will.
But it's very likely that such an action will lead to Trump's 3rd impeachment for abuse of power in dismissing a case he is the defendant in.
3. As Turley said in his video, both sides have good arguments. He did not subscribe to the Meese opinion that Taylor Swift has more legal authority because Smith was not approved by the Senate.
I'm sorry, I don't turn to others for what to think. Turley prime amongst them.
If memory serves, after a new president takes office all the US Attorneys resign and get replaced by the new president.
The President asks them to resign, and most do out of curtesy and so that the President doesn't have to fire them.
But not always all, for example President Biden retained US Attorney Hur and I think Weiss from the previous administration so they could continue their work.
2. Cannon may be replaced if the appeals court think she is being blatantly partisan. No matter, she got the case past the election. Similar to Biden getting a pass on mishandling classified documents because he's too old and senile to stand trial.
"No matter, she got that case past the election", I rest my case as to her actions being not based on the law, but based on ensuring Trump's trial didn't occur before the election.
1. Cannon stood strong. I give her credit. The partisan democrat judges, Merchan & Engeron, will also get overturned even though they arguably did their jobs of hanging felonies and massive fines on Trump before the election.
When you conduct criminal activities, expect to be held accountable for criminal activities.
We'll see how Chutkin handles the J6 case now that Smith's authority has been challenged. Any prediction?
If a motion is filed with Judge Chutkin to dismiss based on SC Smith's appointment, I would expect her to provide a well detailed response with history and precedent from the slew of challenges over the last 50 years and multiple administrations showing that the AG has the power delegated by Congress to hire special attorney's.
WW