Israel Launches Operation Protective Edge on Gaza

[Billo_Really]

Nobody is disputing the fact that the hospital suffered some damage.

What IS in dispute is your unsubstantiated claim that the IDF intentionally targeted the hospital and that they committed a war-crime by doing so,to wit...

...This is a war crime and there is no reason for the Israeli's to do this, other than just being mean. It takes a really sick person, to target a hospital...

There is no credible evidence to suggest that the minor damage incurred by the hospital (a roof antenna, some cracks in a few wall-areas, some shattered windows) was attributable to anything more than blast concussion, shrapnel and debris fallout, or even an errant shell here and there.

...An eyewitness inside a hospital getting bombed, is a pretty credible source...

1. how would someone inside a lightly damaged hospital building know that the munitions had been intentionally targeted against that building?

2. what makes you think your female Palestinian doctor-blogger was actually IN the hospital at the time, as you've claimed here?

Go back and read your own highly biased and subjective blogging-source again...

A View from Gaza: We Hug the Children as the Bombs Fall | Common Dreams

Hilariously, not even your own source supports your secondary claim here, about the blogger being inside the hospital as an eyewitness at the time...

Excerpts from your own blogging-source...

---------------------

"...I do not know what is going on and I can hear successive bombing. I am thinking of all the people I know tonight, especially my colleagues at the hospital..."

"...I heard they bombed the area around the European hospital east of Khan Younis in Southern Gaza... Then the hospital was directly targeted..."

"...At 4:15 am, there were explosions very close to my apartment..."

-------------------

Not exactly an eyewitness writing about her experiences INSIDE the hospital at the time of the incident, is it?

Your claim of intentional IDF targeting of a hospital and your related claim of the commission of a war-crime, are dismissed with extreme prejudice, due to...

1. lack of substantiation from an objective and credible source, and...

2. false representation of the supposed eyewitness-mode in which your subjective and incredible source was supposedly functioning...



You can always re-submit or appeal, later, if additional evidence comes to light which reliably substantiates your otherwise wild and highly partisan falsehoods illegitimately posing as legitimate claims.

How about from the people pulling the trigger?

Testimony 10 – Briefings

Formal briefings covered “going off to war (and in war) no consideration of civilians was to be taken. Shoot anyone you see….this pretty much disgusted me. There was a clear feeling, and this was repeated whenever others spoke to us, that no humanitarian consideration played any role in the army at present.”

Testimony 9 – Rules of Engagement & House Demolitions

The entire infrastructure, tracks, fields, roads (were) in total ruin.” D-9 bulldozers demolished everything “in our designated area. It looked awful, like in those World War II films where nothing remained. A totally destroyed city.”


Testimony 24 – Briefings & House Demolitions

Initial briefings by commanders never mentioned “the lives of civilians (or) showing consideration to civilians.” Here it wasn’t mentioned. “Just the brutality, go in there brutally….In case of any doubt, take down houses. You don’t need confirmation for anything….”

That doesn't sound like people who care about international law or the Geneva Conventions.

 

[georgephillip]

Is this going to be another week long cluster **** and then fake peace or something more?

Probably.
One account I've heard this afternoon claims Israel can't inflict too much pain on Gaza without paying some economic "sanctions" with some of their biggest trading partners. Europeans get a much different picture of violence in Palestine than US viewers do.

 

[Billo_Really]

There is no call for this, no reason for this. This is Israeli tyranny at its worst. Israel is showing the entire world that they are the animals, they are the savages. This is just ridiculous.

What Palestinian's have endured for almost 50 years is unimaginable.

And the pro-Israeli crowd at this website is showing everyone they're not much different from the Nazis. Their hate, is Nazi hate. There is absolutely no difference between the two. It's the same hate and it's disgusting.

 

[Ibentoken]

There is no call for this, no reason for this. This is Israeli tyranny at its worst. Israel is showing the entire world that they are the animals, they are the savages. This is just ridiculous.

What Palestinian's have endured for almost 50 years is unimaginable.

And the pro-Israeli crowd at this website is showing everyone they're not much different from the Nazis. Their hate, is Nazi hate. There is absolutely no difference between the two. It's the same hate and it's disgusting.

The Muslims were allies of nazis, not Jews. If you don't like what's happening then work for peace and tell the muslims to stop firing rockets into israel. Start by being honest.

 

[georgephillip]

There is no call for this, no reason for this. This is Israeli tyranny at its worst. Israel is showing the entire world that they are the animals, they are the savages. This is just ridiculous.

What Palestinian's have endured for almost 50 years is unimaginable.

And the pro-Israeli crowd at this website is showing everyone they're not much different from the Nazis. Their hate, is Nazi hate. There is absolutely no difference between the two. It's the same hate and it's disgusting.

We're not hearing much about Israeli snipers executing two teens on CNN cameras on 15 May or almost one month before two apparent rogue Hamas operatives kidnapped three Jewish teens. The Jews knew the ID of those suspects within 24 hours, yet withheld the information in order to rearrest hundreds of innocent Hamas members exchanged for Gilad Shalit, thus setting up the current kosher killing spree in Gaza.

Jews being Jews.

 

[georgephillip]

There is no call for this, no reason for this. This is Israeli tyranny at its worst. Israel is showing the entire world that they are the animals, they are the savages. This is just ridiculous.

What Palestinian's have endured for almost 50 years is unimaginable.

And the pro-Israeli crowd at this website is showing everyone they're not much different from the Nazis. Their hate, is Nazi hate. There is absolutely no difference between the two. It's the same hate and it's disgusting.

The Muslims were allies of nazis, not Jews. If you don't like what's happening then work for peace and tell the muslims to stop firing rockets into israel. Start by being honest.

Some Jews like Avraham Stern also offered to ally with the Nazis in exchange for help with driving the British from Palestine. Maybe you should expand your summer reading list?

 

[Kondor3]

...How about from the people pulling the trigger?...

Is any of that testimony directly related to the July 2014 Gaza hospital incident?

 

[Ibentoken]

There is no call for this, no reason for this. This is Israeli tyranny at its worst. Israel is showing the entire world that they are the animals, they are the savages. This is just ridiculous.

What Palestinian's have endured for almost 50 years is unimaginable.

And the pro-Israeli crowd at this website is showing everyone they're not much different from the Nazis. Their hate, is Nazi hate. There is absolutely no difference between the two. It's the same hate and it's disgusting.

We're not hearing much about Israeli snipers executing two teens on CNN cameras on 15 May or almost one month before two apparent rogue Hamas operatives kidnapped three Jewish teens. The Jews knew the ID of those suspects within 24 hours, yet withheld the information in order to rearrest hundreds of innocent Hamas members exchanged for Gilad Shalit, thus setting up the current kosher killing spree in Gaza.

Jews being Jews.

"innocent hamas members." That's sick.

 

[Billo_Really]

We're not hearing much about Israeli snipers executing two teens on CNN cameras on 15 May or almost one month before two apparent rogue Hamas operatives kidnapped three Jewish teens. The Jews knew the ID of those suspects within 24 hours, yet withheld the information in order to rearrest hundreds of innocent Hamas members exchanged for Gilad Shalit, thus setting up the current kosher killing spree in Gaza.

Jews being Jews.

I'm not going to blame Jews, because this has nothing to do with Judaism. It's Israeli's. Right wing Israeli's, to be more specific. Asshole Zionists and their bloodlust.

 

[Billo_Really]

Is any of that testimony directly related to the July 2014 Gaza hospital incident?

No.

 

[Billo_Really]

The Muslims were allies of nazis, not Jews. If you don't like what's happening then work for peace and tell the muslims to stop firing rockets into israel. Start by being honest.

That was in response to Israel locking up over 500 innocent Palestinian's who committed no crime and the following air strikes into Gaza, which had nothing to do with the kidnapping.

 

[Indeependent]

The Muslims were allies of nazis, not Jews. If you don't like what's happening then work for peace and tell the muslims to stop firing rockets into israel. Start by being honest.

That was in response to Israel locking up over 500 innocent Palestinian's who committed no crime and the following air strikes into Gaza, which had nothing to do with the kidnapping.

Serious question...
Is any "Palestinian" ever NOT an innocent?

 

[Billo_Really]

The Muslims were allies of nazis, not Jews.

Well, we've come full circle, because the Israeli's are treating the Palestinian's, like the Nazis treated the Jews.

 

[Billo_Really]

Serious question...
Is any "Palestinian" ever NOT an innocent?

Of coarse. Every society has its share of criminals.

Israel's problem is that this is "state sanctioned terrorism".

 

[Kondor3]

Is any of that testimony directly related to the July 2014 Gaza hospital incident?

No.

Your Honor, Plaintiff rests.

We pray that the original judgment of 'pwned' earlier today be allowed to stand.

 

[Indeependent]

Serious question...
Is any "Palestinian" ever NOT an innocent?

Of coarse. Every society has its share of criminals.

Israel's problem is that this is "state sanctioned terrorism".

I guess you've been brushing up on your revisionist history of the 1990s when your pals were bombing children on a daily basis.
Ever since the gates closed and the electronic border eye went up in 2000, your Pals must have become truly frustrated in their inability to carry out their blood lust.
Too bad many good Arabs who needed jobs in Israel have to suffer financially up to today.

 

[georgephillip]

There is no call for this, no reason for this. This is Israeli tyranny at its worst. Israel is showing the entire world that they are the animals, they are the savages. This is just ridiculous.

What Palestinian's have endured for almost 50 years is unimaginable.

And the pro-Israeli crowd at this website is showing everyone they're not much different from the Nazis. Their hate, is Nazi hate. There is absolutely no difference between the two. It's the same hate and it's disgusting.

We're not hearing much about Israeli snipers executing two teens on CNN cameras on 15 May or almost one month before two apparent rogue Hamas operatives kidnapped three Jewish teens. The Jews knew the ID of those suspects within 24 hours, yet withheld the information in order to rearrest hundreds of innocent Hamas members exchanged for Gilad Shalit, thus setting up the current kosher killing spree in Gaza.

Jews being Jews.

"innocent hamas members." That's sick.

Innocent of the kidnapping of the three murdered Israeli teens.
Would you support the same type of collective punishment in this country?

 

[Billo_Really]

Your Honor, Plaintiff rests.

We pray that the original judgment of 'pwned' earlier today be allowed to stand.

You live in a fantasy land. I provided evidence that before the IDF goes into Gaza, they're told not to give any consideration to civilian lives. And they're to go in with the intent of "total destruction". They have shown this behavior time and time again.

Now you're trying to argue that, all of a sudden, they're going to switch gears and be concerned about civilians and civilian infrastructure? That's like arguing Charles Manson is pro-life.

But that's your dumbass argument. In spite of all their priors, you claim they're going to act the opposite of what they've done in the past.

 

[Indeependent]

We're not hearing much about Israeli snipers executing two teens on CNN cameras on 15 May or almost one month before two apparent rogue Hamas operatives kidnapped three Jewish teens. The Jews knew the ID of those suspects within 24 hours, yet withheld the information in order to rearrest hundreds of innocent Hamas members exchanged for Gilad Shalit, thus setting up the current kosher killing spree in Gaza.

Jews being Jews.

"innocent hamas members." That's sick.

Innocent of the kidnapping of the three murdered Israeli teens.
Would you support the same type of collective punishment in this country?

Have you met a non-Muslim who would use an entire city as a human shield?
There must be a language, perhaps Klingon, where Muslim means "*****".

 

[Billo_Really]

I guess you've been brushing up on your revisionist history of the 1990s when your pals were bombing children on a daily basis.
Ever since the gates closed and the electronic border eye went up in 2000, your Pals must have become truly frustrated in their inability to carry out their blood lust.
Too bad many good Arabs who needed jobs in Israel have to suffer financially up to today.

The Pals have been imprisoned under Israeli oppression for almost 50 years now.

They have a right to be free.