Zone1 Is it anti semitic to say there is jewish DNA

[Mortimer]

Yes its a common german and austrian approach saying jews are germans with slightly different religion but in USA its different they are a ethnicity like ashkenazi sephardi etc i dont think eithe is really a discrimination i accept how jews see it

I was at court examination for the crime of Wiederbetätigung i was asked how its possible that i claim someone has jewish genes i said maybe that sounds racist but its not it really exists like 23andme ancestry can detect jewish DNA

 

[rightwinger]

I was at court examination for the crime of Wiederbetätigung i was asked how its possible that i claim someone has jewish genes i said maybe that sounds racist but its not it really exists like 23andme ancestry can detect jewish DNA

You really need to learn how to shut up

They are trying to prove you are a Nazi. Just say you like to play dress up and don’t know anything about DNA
Some of your best friends are Jewish
You enjoyed Fiddler on the Roof

 

[rosends]

Yes its a common german and austrian approach saying jews are germans with slightly different religion but in USA its different they are a ethnicity like ashkenazi sephardi etc i dont think eithe is really a discrimination i accept how jews see it

I was at court examination for the crime of Wiederbetätigung i was asked how its possible that i claim someone has jewish genes i said maybe that sounds racist but its not it really exists like 23andme ancestry can detect jewish DNA

Not anti Semitic, just really, really wrong.

 

[luiza]

You really need to learn how to shut up

They are trying to prove you are a Nazi. Just say you like to play dress up and don’t know anything about DNA
Some of your best friends are Jewish
You enjoyed Fiddler on the Roof

Fiddler in his own bed more likely . Alone .

We all know that Morticia loves the fine Nazi way of life .
I remember him once saying how much he wished that he looked more like dear Granpdpa Adolf .

I will happily testify if it helps .
Them .

 

[DGS49]

The term, "anti-Semite" presumes that Jews have Semitic genes - meaning that they originated in the Middle-East, just like the Arabs. But they were tossed out of their ancestral homeland, a phenomenon which is sometimes called the Jewish Diaspora.

Jews generally do not proselytize, but occasionally snag a convert. This does not explain the large numbers of Jews from northern and eastern Europe or from Africa. The late Joe Smith, founder of LDS, claimed that Native Americans were descended from the "lost tribes" of Israel. There is no evidence to back this up.

I wonder what the ancestry sites would say about Jewish ethnicity. Does "Jewish DNA" even exist any more?

 

[1srelluc]

Jews have the same cluster of genes as non-jews with the same gene clusters.

Are Jews a Race? | My Jewish Learning

The short answer is no — Jews are not a race. People who identify as Jewish include individuals of enormously diverse ...

www.myjewishlearning.com

 

[Mortimer]

Not anti Semitic, just really, really wrong.

Ok but 23andme has a ashkenazi jewish category it says im 1.2percent it even says which community like ukranian jews do you think thats fake or unreliable?

Im not saying jews are a seperate race but you can detect whether someone is jewish like you could detect someone is british and irish eventhough it might be both caucasians

 

[Mortimer]

Jews have the same cluster of genes as non-jews with the same gene clusters.

Are Jews a Race? | My Jewish Learning

The short answer is no — Jews are not a race. People who identify as Jewish include individuals of enormously diverse ...

www.myjewishlearning.com

Im not saying jews are a race but you can detect jewish ancestry

That jews have the same genes probably means they have same ancient DNA components like hunter gatherer anatolian neolithic farmer etc but you can detect recent ancestry as well even if someone is from a community in the americas

 

[Winston]

The term, "anti-Semite" presumes that Jews have Semitic genes - meaning that they originated in the Middle-East, just like the Arabs. But they were tossed out of their ancestral homeland, a phenomenon which is sometimes called the Jewish Diaspora.

Jews generally do not proselytize, but occasionally snag a convert. This does not explain the large numbers of Jews from northern and eastern Europe or from Africa. The late Joe Smith, founder of LDS, claimed that Native Americans were descended from the "lost tribes" of Israel. There is no evidence to back this up.

I wonder what the ancestry sites would say about Jewish ethnicity. Does "Jewish DNA" even exist any more?

Are the North Carolina Cherokee Indians Separdic Jews?

Many people have expressed the fact that the Cherokees resembled the Jewish population. Indeed, my own visits into Cherokee, North Carolina seem to confirm this.

www.linkedin.com

 

[rosends]

Ok but 23andme has a ashkenazi jewish category it says im 1.2percent it even says which community like ukranian jews do you think thats fake or unreliable?

Im not saying jews are a seperate race but you can detect whether someone is jewish like you could detect someone is british and irish eventhough it might be both caucasians

Simply put, they should not have that category. There is no such thing as "Ashkenazi Jewish" DNA. I don't trust most if the other categories, but this one doesn't even exist.

 

[The Irish Ram]

Not only can DNA tell what group your ancestors probably belonged to, but gain of function can target specific groups.