The simple answer is...Without employers there are no jobs to create employees.
Now, what exactly are you not going along with?
Again, we don't have jobs because we have employers.
We have jobs because we have DEMAND, which are filled sometimes by the public sector, and sometimes by the private sector...
or as a wise Republican once put it...
"Labor is prior to, and independent of, capital. Capital is only the fruit of labor, and could never have existed if labor had not first existed. Labor is the superior of capital, and deserves much the higher consideration..." Abraham Lincoln
See. Republicans USED to get this.
Really? Ok.
Say I am a small business person. A landscaper. I have many customers. I prefer to do all of the work myself. I would rather operate this way.
I elect to hire NO ONE...I do not need labor however there is DEMAND for my services. Only when I decide that I no longer wish to do the work myself, will I consider hiring labor.
Example 2...
I own a large factory. Some years ago I had the old factory torn demolished because my foreign competitors had modern factories.
I built a new one. Only this time I built it to be almost fully automated.
Alas, because I now needed only 1/3rd of the people to run this new factory to put out MORE product, I let go 2/3rds of the employees.
I now can operate with less labor and produce more product because my plant is modern.
Not labor for demand of product..I have that covered. Labor for demand of labor.
This is the chicken or the egg argument union supporters have tried in vain to rationalize for years. It still hasn't worked.
Labor does not exist in waiting. Labor is a commodity.
When labor is needed it is obtained. When labor is not needed, it is not labor.
Lincoln's notion applied to the mid 19th century.
Obviously the US is a much different place now.
Once again...IN the absence of employers( pick any small town in the Rust Belt where there used to be factories and mills) there is no need for labor.
Yeah, I saw the guys in the union hall waiting for work, sitting there watching tv, drinking coffee and all pissed off thinking somebody owed them something.
Instead of sitting on their miserable asses waiting for some one to give them something, they should have gone home, and tried to figure out how to get painting jobs in their local community. But NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO...Da Yoon Yun don allow dat.
Another reason why I oppose the concept of the labor collective.