I said 1/3 don't work, therefore, don't pay income taxes. That's not wrong. I said nothing about the total number of people paying no federal taxes. Who do you expect to pay income taxes if not those earning money?
The conversation is about the 49% of all American
earners who pay no federal personal income tax (as opposed to the top 25% who carry 86% of that tax load).
I believe you to be bright enough to know that figure does not include non-filers - the
2/3 of Americans who don't work, so I'm forced to conclude you are trying to fudge the facts and derail the discussion.
I said 1/3 of Americans don't work, and therefore, pay no taxes. What part of that do you imagine is fudged?
Actually over 2/3 of all Americans don't work but again you attempt to fudge the topic.
The discussion, as you well know, was about just those who work, file tax returns, and pay no federal personal income tax. As Ray correctly noted, nearly half of all filers pay no fed income tax.
None ... Zilch ... Nada ... while "the rich" - the top 25% of filers - carry 86% of the load.
So what would satisfy you?
96%?
106%?