Much as with elections WARS HAVE CONSEQUENCES.
Was there a place called Palestine?
Of course there was. Look at any old map of the region.
Is there a place now called Palestine?
No.
I know that both the Isreali and Palestinian partisans here are both attempting to find MORAL justification for the existence (or destruction) of the state we now call Isreal, but honestly boys, that is a dead end.
No nation is moral. Seeking to pin such a label on ANY nation is absurd
Nation states are amoral contrivences of the winners of wars.
We can pretend (if it amuses us) that GOD was on the side of the winners.
And that will be very comforting only as long as the side you're on is the winner.
But surely SOME of you must have, at one time or the other, gotten your asses kicked unfairly.
Do you tell yourselves that GOD wasn't on your side?
Of course not (Jesus I hope not for your sakes, at least!)
It's time for those of you who are not actually completely insane to get the whole GODand morality issue out of the issue of geopolitics.
Agreed.
"Nation states are amoral contrivances of the winners of wars."
Don't we still have to morally account for the degree of racism, discrimination and xenophobia in a state like Nazi Germany or White South Africa or Jim Crow USA?
And take whatever actions are required to reveal and eliminate such states?
If "actual politics is an interaction between realistic considerations (whether valid or mistaken, moral or immoral in my view) and ideological influences (and) (t)he latter tend to be more influential the less they are discussed and 'dragged into the light', (then) any form of racism, discrimination and xenophobia becomes more potent and politically influential if it is taken for granted by the society which indulges in it."
Personally, I believe racism, discrimination and xenophobia run rampant in the Jewish State of Israel and deserve the same extinction the Nazis, South Africans, and segregationists received.