Dutch Lawmakers Approve a 36% Tax on Unrealized Crypto, Stock, and Bond Gains

1srelluc

Diamond Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2021
Messages
73,674
Reaction score
108,939
Points
3,488
Location
Shenandoah Valley of Virginia
What people don't realize is with unrealized gains taxes, it structurally requires selling off some of the taxed asset to pay the tax in most economic conditions.

So what happens when their farmers have to sell off a field every year to pay the tax man?

Less food happens and that's a big deal to the Dutch who are the second largest food exporter in the world.

So, you want to be more like the EU huh.....Maybe the Obamas will move to the land of wooden shoes since they like the EU so much.



Starting January 2028, the Netherlands is set to require that residents pay tax on paper profits they have not yet cashed in, pending Senate approval.

The Dutch House of Representatives on Thursday voted to pass the Actual Return in Box 3 Act (Wet werkelijk rendement box 3), a reform that will tax residents at a flat rate of 36% on the actual returns they earn from savings and investments, effective January 1, 2028.

The bill replaces a system that taxed investment income based on assumed returns, a framework the Dutch Supreme Court ruled unconstitutional in a series of decisions beginning in December 2021.

Under the new regime, the tax applies not only to income that has actually been received, such as interest, dividends, and rent, but also to the annual increase in value of assets like stocks, bonds, and cryptocurrencies, even when those assets have not been sold.

If a Dutch resident holds a portfolio of shares that rises by €10,000 over the course of a year, the tax authority will treat that paper gain as taxable income, regardless of whether the investor has sold anything.

 
I don't get it, the Dutch Supreme Court shot this down, right? So, what's different this time? Different people on the Court that will rule differently?

Interesting to see how this works out, assuming it gets implemented. It ain't gonna help investors in that country, some of the rich guys are gonna pack up and leave IMHO, or find ways to make or hide investments that doesn't get taxed.
 
Their domestic stock portfolios are going to decrease significantly.

One potential trade off might be more venture capitalism and seed money available directly to junior companies via some of the former heavy stock investors. Time will tell I suppose. Buy and hold is now gone in that country;
 
I don't get it, the Dutch Supreme Court shot this down, right? So, what's different this time? Different people on the Court that will rule differently?

Interesting to see how this works out, assuming it gets implemented. It ain't gonna help investors in that country, some of the rich guys are gonna pack up and leave IMHO, or find ways to make or hide investments that doesn't get taxed.
Looks like they need to break out the manure spreaders again.

 
What people don't realize is with unrealized gains taxes, it structurally requires selling off some of the taxed asset to pay the tax in most economic conditions.

So what happens when their farmers have to sell off a field every year to pay the tax man?

Less food happens and that's a big deal to the Dutch who are the second largest food exporter in the world.

So, you want to be more like the EU huh.....Maybe the Obamas will move to the land of wooden shoes since they like the EU so much.



Starting January 2028, the Netherlands is set to require that residents pay tax on paper profits they have not yet cashed in, pending Senate approval.

The Dutch House of Representatives on Thursday voted to pass the Actual Return in Box 3 Act (Wet werkelijk rendement box 3), a reform that will tax residents at a flat rate of 36% on the actual returns they earn from savings and investments, effective January 1, 2028.

The bill replaces a system that taxed investment income based on assumed returns, a framework the Dutch Supreme Court ruled unconstitutional in a series of decisions beginning in December 2021.

Under the new regime, the tax applies not only to income that has actually been received, such as interest, dividends, and rent, but also to the annual increase in value of assets like stocks, bonds, and cryptocurrencies, even when those assets have not been sold.

If a Dutch resident holds a portfolio of shares that rises by €10,000 over the course of a year, the tax authority will treat that paper gain as taxable income, regardless of whether the investor has sold anything.

Damn, 36%!!! I have no idea how the Dutch income taxes work, but if unrealized gains are taxed, wouldn't that result in a huge tax deduction also?
 
What people don't realize is with unrealized gains taxes, it structurally requires selling off some of the taxed asset to pay the tax in most economic conditions.

So what happens when their farmers have to sell off a field every year to pay the tax man?

Less food happens and that's a big deal to the Dutch who are the second largest food exporter in the world.

So, you want to be more like the EU huh.....Maybe the Obamas will move to the land of wooden shoes since they like the EU so much.



Starting January 2028, the Netherlands is set to require that residents pay tax on paper profits they have not yet cashed in, pending Senate approval.

The Dutch House of Representatives on Thursday voted to pass the Actual Return in Box 3 Act (Wet werkelijk rendement box 3), a reform that will tax residents at a flat rate of 36% on the actual returns they earn from savings and investments, effective January 1, 2028.

The bill replaces a system that taxed investment income based on assumed returns, a framework the Dutch Supreme Court ruled unconstitutional in a series of decisions beginning in December 2021.

Under the new regime, the tax applies not only to income that has actually been received, such as interest, dividends, and rent, but also to the annual increase in value of assets like stocks, bonds, and cryptocurrencies, even when those assets have not been sold.

If a Dutch resident holds a portfolio of shares that rises by €10,000 over the course of a year, the tax authority will treat that paper gain as taxable income, regardless of whether the investor has sold anything.

So, the Dutch supreme court shot it down last time, and it'll get shot down again, and you're point of arguement is from the standpoint it's implemented law. Yup, typical Yank.
 
What people don't realize is with unrealized gains taxes, it structurally requires selling off some of the taxed asset to pay the tax in most economic conditions.

So what happens when their farmers have to sell off a field every year to pay the tax man?

Less food happens and that's a big deal to the Dutch who are the second largest food exporter in the world.

So, you want to be more like the EU huh.....Maybe the Obamas will move to the land of wooden shoes since they like the EU so much.



Starting January 2028, the Netherlands is set to require that residents pay tax on paper profits they have not yet cashed in, pending Senate approval.

The Dutch House of Representatives on Thursday voted to pass the Actual Return in Box 3 Act (Wet werkelijk rendement box 3), a reform that will tax residents at a flat rate of 36% on the actual returns they earn from savings and investments, effective January 1, 2028.

The bill replaces a system that taxed investment income based on assumed returns, a framework the Dutch Supreme Court ruled unconstitutional in a series of decisions beginning in December 2021.

Under the new regime, the tax applies not only to income that has actually been received, such as interest, dividends, and rent, but also to the annual increase in value of assets like stocks, bonds, and cryptocurrencies, even when those assets have not been sold.

If a Dutch resident holds a portfolio of shares that rises by €10,000 over the course of a year, the tax authority will treat that paper gain as taxable income, regardless of whether the investor has sold anything.

Their economy will now crash as massive selling occurs, people will flee, and no one will invest.
 
Back
Top Bottom