Zone1 Does Egypt Owe Israel Clear Title to Gaza?

Lisa558

Diamond Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2021
Messages
51,793
Reaction score
54,068
Points
3,488
Given Egypt’s history of treatment of the Jews, I’d say Egypt should take back the Egyptians (now called Gazans) into the country, and acknowledge the region belongs to the Land of Isrsel.

1) Egypt’s aggression in the six-day war, in which it attempted to wipe Israel off the map, was a humiliating loss, and Israel won that land. (Some would say won the land back.)

2) Egypt expelled all its Jews about 60 years ago, upon 24 hours notice, and forced the Jews to deed over all their land, houses, and other assets. This land now belongs to the descendants of those who stole it, and Jews were driven to Israel penniless. To be fair, Gaza should be deeded over to a) the descendants of those who had their land stolen, which would be their grandparents, and 2) Israel in general upon which to build a thriving Jewish community.

 
Given Egypt’s history of treatment of the Jews, I’d say Egypt should take back the Egyptians (now called Gazans) into the country, and acknowledge the region belongs to the Land of Isrsel.

1) Egypt’s aggression in the six-day war, in which it attempted to wipe Israel off the map, was a humiliating loss, and Israel won that land. (Some would say won the land back.)

2) Egypt expelled all its Jews about 60 years ago, upon 24 hours notice, and forced the Jews to deed over all their land, houses, and other assets. This land now belongs to the descendants of those who stole it, and Jews were driven to Israel penniless. To be fair, Gaza should be deeded over to a) the descendants of those who had their land stolen, which would be their grandparents, and 2) Israel in general upon which to build a thriving Jewish community.


To be fair they didn’t do that until the Jews forced all the Arabs out of Israel and into the Gaza Strip.

You can’t have it both ways.
 
Egypt wants nothing to do with Gaza. They have their own barrier system on their side of it.
Well, naturally. The point is: since Egypt stole all the Jews’ land and assets, shouldn’t they be held responsible for a solution? As it stands, the anti-Israel contingent puts the onus on the Jews.
ON the flipside, Israel wants nothing to do with Gaza either.
Can you blame them?
 
Egypt wants nothing to do with Gaza. They have their own barrier system on their side of it.

ON the flipside, Israel wants nothing to do with Gaza either.
Well Isreal did ethic cleanse 750,000 them out Isreal(with the support of the Allies)... Would you want to be talking with them either...
Would be very awkward...

1739542612454.webp

They area wasn't majority Jewish until the 5th century... That is 900 years before Columbus landed in America...

The Area has not been a Jewish homeland but a place shared by multiple cultures and religions...
 
To be fair they didn’t do that until the Jews forced all the Arabs out of Israel and into the Gaza Strip.

You can’t have it both ways.
All the Arabs were forced out of Israel into Gaza?

No, they were not.

Israel has a large Arab population outside of Gaza.
 
All the Arabs were forced out of Israel into Gaza?

No, they were not.

Israel has a large Arab population outside of Gaza.
Yup. About 20% of Israel’s citizens are Arabs.

The only ethnicity forced out, and had their land stolen, was the Jews - and by the Arabs - throughout the Middle East.
 
All the Arabs were forced out of Israel into Gaza?

No, they were not.

Israel has a large Arab population outside of Gaza.
Maybe not all but a whole bunch were.

Israel may have a small Muslim population in it, but they are utterly powerless.

Not that it is a bad thing.


The whole thing is a mess. Multiculturalism does not work.
 
Yup. About 20% of Israel’s citizens are Arabs.

The only ethnicity forced out, and had their land stolen, was the Jews - and by the Arabs - throughout the Middle East.
Wrong. Christians were also forced out of their lands all throughout North Africa or just killed off.

Much of Europe was conquered by Muslims as well. Until the Christians fought back in something called the Crusades, which most Jews criticize, because Christians are just supposed to roll over and let Muslims slaughter them I guess. Rules for thee and not for me I guess.
 
Okay, it wasn’t “all”. Just the vast majority out of Israel.
So you started with two mistakes. Now, you can also consider this

 
So you started with two mistakes. Now, you can also consider this

Hey, I’m not saying it was wrong to deport the Muslims.

If you want a Jewish nation then go for it, it requires that Muslims aren’t in power.

Just don’t pretend Israel welcomes Muslims, and don’t act all hurt when other Muslim nations kick out their Jews.
 
Hey, I’m not saying it was wrong to deport the Muslims.

If you want a Jewish nation then go for it, it requires that Muslims aren’t in power.

Just don’t pretend Israel welcomes Muslims, and don’t act all hurt when other Muslim nations kick out their Jews.
Israel doesn't welcome Muslims? Then you know nothing about Israel.
 
Egypt should take back the Egyptians (now called Gazans) into the country, and acknowledge the region belongs to the Land of Isrsel.
I think that would be a bad idea. Rightly or wrongly, taking over Gaza after expelling its inhabitants would place Israel in the same category as Russia taking over parts of Ukraine. No Arab country would dare to have any dealings with Israel after that.

Trump's suggestion that the US take over Gaza would be a better idea. Despite chants of "Death to America" and other rabble rousing performances, Trump is recognized as the only honest broker of international disputes. Since the US has no territorial interest in Gaza, it could play a temporary custodial role in the reconstruction of Gaza.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom