Murtha........ needs an ass whipping.
You? I dunno, likely not.
Resign? Enlisted guys don't resign. They reenlist, retire, accept discharge, or get kicked out.
Being liberal doesn't mean you are bad. It just means that you are wrong most times

(that was a joke. An all conservative or realist board would be stale)
Letter from me to Congressman Murtha sent 6-1-06. I got a form letter back.
Congressman Murtha,
One of the tenets of retiring is that we are allowed to relax, grow our hair, and speak our mind. Obviously we both have mastered those three skills.
Regarding your comments on the alleged incident at Haditha. Sir, your comments were completely over the top. When on active duty, I would bet you lunch at the SNCO club that you would not have tolerated such inflammatory commentary towards any of your Marines without benefit of a guilty verdict at a General Court Martial. So I have to remind you of those leadership traits and principles that you obviously didn’t apply when talking about your fellow Marines. I need to remind you that you are also failing to set an example for your fellow members of Congress. I need to remind you that in your capacity as an elected representative you have poisoned the investigation. If by some chance they are exonerated, are you going to apologize publicly to the young Marines? And if you were to apologize, is there any hope that your staff will ensure the apology gets the same press as your “in cold blood” declaration?
To put a point to it Colonel, you mayÂ’ve been speaking as a congressman but the public took your words as a Marine. Semper Fidelis doesnÂ’t mean we are faithful to atrocities. If these Marines are found guilty then I will applaud the fact that Marines take care of their own, for good or ill. Semper Fidelis means you should be faithful to the concept of innocent until definitively proven guilty.
Perhaps a visit to the field, eating MREÂ’s, and sleeping in a GP or CP tent might remind you of those core values that you mayÂ’ve let slip. ItÂ’s the only reason I can imaging you would say what you did, considering your background and record.
MSgt Phillip E. Gwinn USMC (ret)
Lubbock, TX