Hypothetically speaking, if we had an opening topic of:
”A poster here has died. I supported him for saying he wants to molest children, for leading those Klan rallies, and for clubbing baby seals.”
Would it be wrong to comment negatively on his molesting children, participation in Klan rallies, and clubbing baby seals? Would that be out-of-line?
You don't need to create any hypothetic scenarios because we already have at least two real cases here.
For more than 10 years, Clayton Jones and Unkotare have been openly promoting the genocide of the american people using code words like "diversity" to hide the depravity of what they're saying (
"Diversity is the future of America"); a monstrosity even more disgusting, vile than molesting children, leading Klan rallies and clubbing baby seals and receive a standing ovation from at least 70% of the Board.