Would you be willing to live with yourself by letting 10,000 people die even if you knew you had the right dirtbag???
Bob Barr At CPAC: 'How Would You Like To Be Waterboarded?'
- Thread starter Cal
- Start date
Would you be willing to live with yourself by letting 10,000 people die even if you knew you had the right dirtbag???
CMike
Zionist, proud to be
- Oct 25, 2009
- 9,219
- 1,172
- 190
CMike
Zionist, proud to be
- Oct 25, 2009
- 9,219
- 1,172
- 190
Would you be willing to go to prison for allowing thousands of americans to die because you were too much of a pussy to cause discomfort to mass murdering terrorists?
If it saved 10,00 American lives, yes I would.
How about answering mine?? Would you let 10,000 americans die even though you knew you had the right dirtbag with the info you needed to save em???
Last edited:
- Banned
- #446
again...silly hypothetical.. How would anyone KNOW that the information any captive had would save lives until after they had divulged it?
And why not answer the rest of my slippery slope comparisons. Where does torture stop?
It reminds me of a joke. A man sit down next to a stunningly beautiful woman at a bar. He says, "Please excuse me for being so forward, but you'll soon realize that I really don't have a lot of time for small talk. I am a wealthy entrepreneur who just found out that I have pancreatic cancer and have about six months to live. I have always put work ahead of romance and that needs to stop right now. If I gave you ten million dollars, would you come away with me to my private yacht in the Mediterranean and be my lover while I still have life?" She was stunned, but he looked so sincere and was pretty good looking... and ten million dollars was a LOT of money... so she said, "Yes, you poor kind man...YES! I will go with you to your yacht in the Mediterranean". He then said, "Great! Would you slip out into the alley behind the bar right now and give me a blowjob for ten bucks?" She said, "What???? What sort of woman do you take me for????" He said, "We've already established that, now we're just haggling over the price!"
Today you torture one terrorist to save 10K Americans, tomorrow, you'll torture five hundred terrorists to maybe save ten Americans.... next year, you'll torture bank robbers to get them to tell you where they hid the loot. Once you start, you no longer can make ANY moral argument to stop.
CMike
Zionist, proud to be
- Oct 25, 2009
- 9,219
- 1,172
- 190
The better comfort is too what lengths would you not go to in order to save american lives?
Would you interorgate them without a lawyer? That would could be pretty upsetting to the terrorist
Would you threaten them with longer prison sentences? That could cause emotional trauma
Would you put them in solitary confinement? People are social animals and that could be considered torture
Would you not give them high quality food? That could be pretty upseetting
Would you keep them handcuffed during interrogation? That could be considered torture and uncomfortable
Bottom line- The three terrorists were taunting the interrogators.
The waterboarding was midler than done to some of our CIA personnel in their training
All other measures failed
It worked
It stopped two major terrorist attacks, and saved thousands of american lives.
To the CIA people who did it
I still don't believe waterboarding to be torture but to save those American lives I would be willing to go to jail.
Now answer my questioin?? Lets see where you really stand.
bodecea
Diamond Member
- Banned
- #450
The better comfort is too what lengths would you not go to in order to save american lives?
Would you interorgate them without a lawyer? That would could be pretty upsetting to the terrorist
Would you threaten them with longer prison sentences? That could cause emotional trauma
Would you put them in solitary confinement? People are social animals and that could be considered torture
Would you not give them high quality food? That could be pretty upseetting
Would you keep them handcuffed during interrogation? That could be considered torture and uncomfortable
Bottom line- The three terrorists were taunting the interrogators.
The waterboarding was midler than done to some of our CIA personnel in their training
All other measures failed
It worked
It stopped two major terrorist attacks, and saved thousands of american lives.
To the CIA people who did it
Prove. It.
Where were these terrorist attacks to take place?
When were these terrorist attacks to take place?
How many people were saved from these so-called terrorist attacks?
The better comfort is too what lengths would you not go to in order to save american lives?
Would you interorgate them without a lawyer? That would could be pretty upsetting to the terrorist
Would you threaten them with longer prison sentences? That could cause emotional trauma
Would you put them in solitary confinement? People are social animals and that could be considered torture
Would you not give them high quality food? That could be pretty upseetting
Would you keep them handcuffed during interrogation? That could be considered torture and uncomfortable
Bottom line- The three terrorists were taunting the interrogators.
The waterboarding was midler than done to some of our CIA personnel in their training
All other measures failed
It worked
It stopped two major terrorist attacks, and saved thousands of american lives.
To the CIA people who did it
Prove. It.
Where were these terrorist attacks to take place?
When were these terrorist attacks to take place?
How many people were saved from these so-called terrorist attacks?
You still haven't answered my very simple question?? Lets see what stand you would take. Save the lives or not???
bodecea
Diamond Member
- Banned
- #452
The better comfort is too what lengths would you not go to in order to save american lives?
Would you interorgate them without a lawyer? That would could be pretty upsetting to the terrorist
Would you threaten them with longer prison sentences? That could cause emotional trauma
Would you put them in solitary confinement? People are social animals and that could be considered torture
Would you not give them high quality food? That could be pretty upseetting
Would you keep them handcuffed during interrogation? That could be considered torture and uncomfortable
Bottom line- The three terrorists were taunting the interrogators.
The waterboarding was midler than done to some of our CIA personnel in their training
All other measures failed
It worked
It stopped two major terrorist attacks, and saved thousands of american lives.
To the CIA people who did it
Prove. It.
Where were these terrorist attacks to take place?
When were these terrorist attacks to take place?
How many people were saved from these so-called terrorist attacks?
You still haven't answered my very simple question?? Lets see what stand you would take. Save the lives or not???
I most certainly DID answer your question.
http://www.usmessageboard.com/2052895-post436.html
My apologies.
You did answer and your answer is basically the same as mine. You would do what it took to save those lives.
CMike
Zionist, proud to be
- Oct 25, 2009
- 9,219
- 1,172
- 190
The better comfort is too what lengths would you not go to in order to save american lives?
Would you interorgate them without a lawyer? That would could be pretty upsetting to the terrorist
Would you threaten them with longer prison sentences? That could cause emotional trauma
Would you put them in solitary confinement? People are social animals and that could be considered torture
Would you not give them high quality food? That could be pretty upseetting
Would you keep them handcuffed during interrogation? That could be considered torture and uncomfortable
Bottom line- The three terrorists were taunting the interrogators.
The waterboarding was midler than done to some of our CIA personnel in their training
All other measures failed
It worked
It stopped two major terrorist attacks, and saved thousands of american lives.
To the CIA people who did it
Prove. It.
Where were these terrorist attacks to take place?
When were these terrorist attacks to take place?
How many people were saved from these so-called terrorist attacks?
I did numerous times
Once again pages 8-11
http://luxmedia.vo.llnwd.net/o10/clients/aclu/olc_05302005_bradbury.pdf
- Banned
- #455
The better comfort is too what lengths would you not go to in order to save american lives?
Would you interorgate them without a lawyer? That would could be pretty upsetting to the terrorist
Would you threaten them with longer prison sentences? That could cause emotional trauma
Would you put them in solitary confinement? People are social animals and that could be considered torture
Would you not give them high quality food? That could be pretty upseetting
Would you keep them handcuffed during interrogation? That could be considered torture and uncomfortable
Bottom line- The three terrorists were taunting the interrogators.
The waterboarding was midler than done to some of our CIA personnel in their training
All other measures failed
It worked
It stopped two major terrorist attacks, and saved thousands of american lives.
To the CIA people who did it
the point is: waterboarding has been considered torture since the days of the spanish inquisition... if THAT hadn't worked, clearly you would have been all for whatever OTHER even MORE painful method of torture that could be found that DID work... cutting off digits? electric leads to the genitals? who would care? right?
slippery slope.
bodecea
Diamond Member
- Banned
- #456
The better comfort is too what lengths would you not go to in order to save american lives?
Would you interorgate them without a lawyer? That would could be pretty upsetting to the terrorist
Would you threaten them with longer prison sentences? That could cause emotional trauma
Would you put them in solitary confinement? People are social animals and that could be considered torture
Would you not give them high quality food? That could be pretty upseetting
Would you keep them handcuffed during interrogation? That could be considered torture and uncomfortable
Bottom line- The three terrorists were taunting the interrogators.
The waterboarding was midler than done to some of our CIA personnel in their training
All other measures failed
It worked
It stopped two major terrorist attacks, and saved thousands of american lives.
To the CIA people who did it
Prove. It.
Where were these terrorist attacks to take place?
When were these terrorist attacks to take place?
How many people were saved from these so-called terrorist attacks?
I did numerous times
Once again pages 8-11
http://luxmedia.vo.llnwd.net/o10/clients/aclu/olc_05302005_bradbury.pdf
40 pages of half blacked out stuff? LOL....either you are a fool, or you take me for one.
I'll ask again.
Prove it.
Old Rocks
Diamond Member
Vanquish
Vanquisher of shills
- Aug 14, 2009
- 2,663
- 358
- 98
WTF is this "would you save lives" bullshit? Again? Seriously?
You Claudette lives in some dreamworld where bad guys have big blinking lights over their heads and it's easy to save people.
She's also decided that it's ok to screw with the rules our Founding fathers had (cruel and unusual punishment) to TRY to save lives.
Talk about a fantasy world.
You Claudette lives in some dreamworld where bad guys have big blinking lights over their heads and it's easy to save people.
She's also decided that it's ok to screw with the rules our Founding fathers had (cruel and unusual punishment) to TRY to save lives.
Talk about a fantasy world.
SFC Ollie
Still Marching
I'm pretty certain that the CIA knew who they had and they chose those 3 very carefully for enhanced interrogations.
Similar threads
New Topics
-
Anti-ICE protesters try to break into ICE facility, ICE Agents bum rush them- Started by theHawk
- Replies: 9
-
-
-
-
