Claims that the press is glossing over questions about Biden's age just don't hold up to scrutiny.
Silverâs argument is that, yes, age is a valid concern for voters to have. I donât think this is a particularly controversial statement in itself. Yeah, Biden and Trump are very old, and will only get older. And as they get older, the likelihood of dying or experiencing physical or mental decline increases.
Silverâs argument is that people clearly do have concerns about Bidenâs age (he cites a recent AP-NORC poll that showed 77% of Americans believe Biden is too old to be effective for a full additional term, and 51% of Americans believe the same about Trump). Biden and Trump are separated by three years, and Silver argues, that is a significant span of time. His point is, essentially, that once you get to the late 70s and early 80s, the difference in each passing year becomes more significant.
The problem with Silverâs story is that his piece calling out âa pretty dangerous tendency to shrug off Bidenâs ageâ doesnât actually show anyone âshrug[ging] off Bidenâs age.â
As Washington Post opinion writer
Paul Waldman wrote in response to Silver, âNate doesn't cite a single person âshrugging offâ Biden's age as a concern. Sure it's a concern. I don't know why we have to pretend Democrats are all in denial about it. They aren't. They talk about it frequently.â
Hop over to Google and do a search for
site:cnn.com âbidenâs ageâ. There are pages and pages of results. Hundreds of stories have used the term, and a good number of them have age as their primary focus. You can do the same thing for
the New York Times,
Washington Post,
NBC News,
MSNBC,
NPR, and virtually any other media site on the planet. There is no shortage of media coverage centered around Bidenâs age.
Over on
Twitter X, Silver had been arguing this point with Tim Miller. Silver would say that the topic wasnât getting enough coverage. Miller would respond with screenshots of coverage. Silver would say that whatever amount of information was included in the screenshots and videos, it still wasnât enough coverage. On and on.
Iâll spare everyone the blow-by-blow. Letâs just look at one particular part of their exchange that caught my eye:
https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch...e2f-3b18-46ab-8160-ac498e413089_1475x1702.png
https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch...e2f-3b18-46ab-8160-ac498e413089_1475x1702.png
More at the link.