Are you serious? The problem here is the banks didn't do the correct things to proof ownership in an effort to write as many bad loans or sell as many bad loans as possible. Then they required payouts.
Bottomline: If they can't provide the proper documentation then they shouldn't be able to foreclose on the home!
There is no borrower, not one, who is getting foreclosed on when really he shouldn't. The sale of mortgages is complex. Punishing banks because some document or other wasn't retained while letting the deadbeat owner live rent free is no way to revitalize the housing market. Nor will it make people eager to lend money in the future.
yes and part of the blame lies on the finiancial instutions messing up the proof of ownership records.
Blame Game is Simple:
(1) Community Reinvestment Ac ("CRA")t: This was Jimmy Carter's brain child that basically state that for banks to keep their tax benefits, incentives and other monetary advantages (hence stay competitive), then they had to lend a certain percentage of their portfolio to lower income people. Lower income, meaning minorities, because that is what they touted it would do. What it did was force the banks to do risky loans.
The War on CRA: Opportunity in Next Wave of Mergers, by Gale Cincotta
Repeal the Community Reinvestment Act - March 8, 1995
(2) Jimmy Carter: For being the brain child of the CRA. Kudos for Reagan for not letting it get going.
(3) Bill Clinton: For pushing the CRA, getting trollish Congressman like Dobbs and Frank on board and then signing it into law. Also giving Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac the power to create and artificial secondary mortgage market.
(4) ****** Frank, Dodds and the Other Democrats that pushed it through Congress
(5) Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac: These quasi government companies (created in the 30s) which were given the power by the Clinton administration to create a secondary mortgage market. This market allowed banks to write bad loans and sell them off quickly making a killing and not taking the risk.
(6) The Banks: The Banks wrote the loan. Although they had to get tricky to comply with the CRA. In the end they tossed the the matrix and wrote the loans.
(7) Wall Street: For package toxic loans together, slapping on a A+++ rating and selling them off.
(8) GWB: For ignoring the growing bubble and storm ahead. Economist were screaming the bubble was going to burst. Foreclosures were at all time highs as far back as '02. True any attempt he made to do anything, the Democrats and many Republicans alike stopped him. While Clinton, Dodds and Franks started the snowball down the hill (a snowball that was extremely hard to stop), Bush needs to take blame, because the build up happened on his watch.
(9) Mortgage Brokers: They originated the loans. It was a first job out of college. I though to myself no way these people can afford these loans, but I did them anyways. Many brokers did other shady things, like bend appraisals, forge docs etc. They had no skin in the game, so they sold as many mortgages as possible without worrying about the risk.
(10) Appraisers: Its wasn't uncommon for appraiser to stretch values. Look if an appraiser came up with a conservative value and lost me a loan, I wouldn't send him another deal, nor would anyone in my office. If the appraiser gave me a liberal value and stretch the value, then he would get business. They did alot of things, many unethical and illegal, to get values higher.
(11) Borrowers: If you make $3000K a month after taxes and tax on a mortgage for $2500 (or in many cases $3K) a month, then shame on you for doing it. Who cares if the lender approved it. I remember when my wife and I were looking for a home. A mortgage guy without morals tried to get us to take a mortgage that would have left us $600 after we paid our mortgage. My wife said they wouldn't approve us if we couldn't afford it. I said sure and we got a different home that left us $2500+ after our mortgage (now its closer to $3,500).
(12) Real Estate Agents: For getting people into homes they couldn't afford.
Their is no shortage of culprits in the mortgage meltdown.