Appeals court declines to lift order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois

[C_Clayton_Jones]

‘A federal appeals court panel has denied a request from the Trump administration to lift a lower court's order blocking the president from deploying National Guard troops in Illinois.

The three-judge panel on the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals said the Trump administration's decision to deploy National Guard troops was a "likely violation" of the Tenth Amendment, which reserves certain powers to the states.

It also found that the Trump administration was "unlikely to succeed" in proving that there is a "rebellion" against the authority of the U.S. government or that the president is unable to execute the law with regular forces.

"Political opposition is not rebellion," the judges wrote in their decision.’

Appeals court declines to lift order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois, finding scant evidence of 'rebellion'

Appeals court keeps order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois.

abcnews.go.com

Of course Trump is in violation of the Tenth Amendment.

This is authoritarian excess and overreach.

Trump’s desire to silence political opposition with threats of military force is clearly unlawful.

 

[Care4all]

It's plain as day, there is no justification for his actions and it breaks the 10th.

Is Trump going to appeal to his favorite accessory....?

 

[sealybobo]

‘A federal appeals court panel has denied a request from the Trump administration to lift a lower court's order blocking the president from deploying National Guard troops in Illinois.

The three-judge panel on the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals said the Trump administration's decision to deploy National Guard troops was a "likely violation" of the Tenth Amendment, which reserves certain powers to the states.

It also found that the Trump administration was "unlikely to succeed" in proving that there is a "rebellion" against the authority of the U.S. government or that the president is unable to execute the law with regular forces.

"Political opposition is not rebellion," the judges wrote in their decision.’

Appeals court declines to lift order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois, finding scant evidence of 'rebellion'

Appeals court keeps order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois.

abcnews.go.com

Of course Trump is in violation of the Tenth Amendment.

This is authoritarian excess and overreach.

Trump’s desire to silence political opposition with threats of military force is clearly unlawful.

Yes Trump is doing test runs with the troops. Getting us used to him using the troops. He's going to need them if he's going to steal 2028.

In most cases, active-duty soldiers are prohibited from performing law enforcement functions in Baltimore or elsewhere in the United States. This is due to the Posse Comitatus Act, a federal law that restricts the use of the U.S. military for domestic law enforcement. There are, however, limited exceptions, particularly for the National Guard, who may be called upon by a state's governor during emergencies.

 

[elektra]

A rebellion, The State, The Media, The Courts built a strawman argument.

democrats are pretty stupid funny dangerous all at the same time

 

[sealybobo]

A rebellion, The State, The Media, The Courts built a strawman argument.

democrats are pretty stupid funny dangerous all at the same time

You know most of the Republicans wish Trump would have lost to Hillary? Even Kamala? They secretly wished he'd lose/go away.

I think Mitch might have convicted Trump in the Senate for Jan 6 if he knew Trump would run and win again in 4 years. He thought Trump was done but Trump is the gift that keeps on giving.

I'm pretty confident the USA will fix itself eventually. And I feel what makes us great is we are a pendulum. We swing left for awhile, eventually we swing back to the right and back and forth.

The one thing I hate is the Supremes will be conservative for the rest of my life. I'm 55. Even if I live to 85, the court will still be conservative right? Those justices aren't going anywhere.

Maybe not

The ages of the current Supreme Court justices range from 53 to 75, with Clarence Thomas being the oldest at 75 and Ketanji Brown Jackson the youngest at 53. The justices are: Samuel Alito (75), Sonia Sotomayor (71), John Roberts (69), Elena Kagan (63), Brett Kavanaugh (58), Neil Gorsuch (56), and Amy Coney Barrett (53).

I thought Alito was going to retire after that recording of him and his wife. Vergogna. She said something caught on tape that led me to believe he was going to retire if Trump won. So Trump could replace him with a conservative.

How old are you? Why are you a Republican/Conservative/MAGA?

 

[merrill]

‘A federal appeals court panel has denied a request from the Trump administration to lift a lower court's order blocking the president from deploying National Guard troops in Illinois.

The three-judge panel on the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals said the Trump administration's decision to deploy National Guard troops was a "likely violation" of the Tenth Amendment, which reserves certain powers to the states.

It also found that the Trump administration was "unlikely to succeed" in proving that there is a "rebellion" against the authority of the U.S. government or that the president is unable to execute the law with regular forces.

"Political opposition is not rebellion," the judges wrote in their decision.’

Appeals court declines to lift order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois, finding scant evidence of 'rebellion'

Appeals court keeps order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois.

abcnews.go.com

Of course Trump is in violation of the Tenth Amendment.

This is authoritarian excess and overreach.

Trump’s desire to silence political opposition with threats of military force is clearly unlawful.

Thumbs Up !!!!!!

 

[22lcidw]

You know most of the Republicans wish Trump would have lost to Hillary? Even Kamala? They secretly wished he'd lose/go away.

I think Mitch might have convicted Trump in the Senate for Jan 6 if he knew Trump would run and win again in 4 years. He thought Trump was done but Trump is the gift that keeps on giving.

I'm pretty confident the USA will fix itself eventually. And I feel what makes us great is we are a pendulum. We swing left for awhile, eventually we swing back to the right and back and forth.

The one thing I hate is the Supremes will be conservative for the rest of my life. I'm 55. Even if I live to 85, the court will still be conservative right? Those justices aren't going anywhere.

Maybe not

The ages of the current Supreme Court justices range from 53 to 75, with Clarence Thomas being the oldest at 75 and Ketanji Brown Jackson the youngest at 53. The justices are: Samuel Alito (75), Sonia Sotomayor (71), John Roberts (69), Elena Kagan (63), Brett Kavanaugh (58), Neil Gorsuch (56), and Amy Coney Barrett (53).

I thought Alito was going to retire after that recording of him and his wife. Vergogna. She said something caught on tape that led me to believe he was going to retire if Trump won. So Trump could replace him with a conservative.

How old are you? Why are you a Republican/Conservative/MAGA?

Progs forced out Breyer at the Supreme Court due to age fearing a Republican would be elected in 2024. The real Kings. Progs put Kamala the Presidential candidate after lying through their teeth for 4 years about Joe. The real Kings.

 

[sealybobo]

Progs forced out Breyer at the Supreme Court due to age fearing a Republican would be elected in 2024. The real Kings. Progs put Kamala the Presidential candidate after lying through their teeth for 4 years about Joe. The real Kings.

I wonder what Trump would do if in his last year Democrats controlled the Senate and didn't let him replace a person who died or retired. That would be great. What would he do?

 

[NewsVine_Mariyam]

‘A federal appeals court panel has denied a request from the Trump administration to lift a lower court's order blocking the president from deploying National Guard troops in Illinois.

The three-judge panel on the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals said the Trump administration's decision to deploy National Guard troops was a "likely violation" of the Tenth Amendment, which reserves certain powers to the states.

It also found that the Trump administration was "unlikely to succeed" in proving that there is a "rebellion" against the authority of the U.S. government or that the president is unable to execute the law with regular forces.

"Political opposition is not rebellion," the judges wrote in their decision.’

Appeals court declines to lift order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois, finding scant evidence of 'rebellion'

Appeals court keeps order blocking Trump from deploying National Guard in Illinois.

abcnews.go.com

Of course Trump is in violation of the Tenth Amendment.

This is authoritarian excess and overreach.

Trump’s desire to silence political opposition with threats of military force is clearly unlawful.

I don’t think I’ve ever seen this distinction stated so clearly before:

Political opposition is not rebellion.” A protest doesn’t transform into rebellion simply because demonstrators demand broad legal or policy changes, are highly organized, challenge government structures, engage in civil disobedience, or even carry firearms where the law permits. Nor does it become rebellion because of isolated unlawful acts or violence by rogue participants

This is precisely the difference many have failed to recognize between the Black Lives Matter protests and the January 6th storming of the U.S. Capitol.

 

[22lcidw]

I wonder what Trump would do if in his last year Democrats controlled the Senate and didn't let him replace a person who died or retired. That would be great. What would he do?

Progs replace one of their own because they wanted a younger person in there. They shit on the justice they jettisoned. And that is the truth about your party. And you are so myopic in your beliefs you do not see loyalty as an important trait when not needed. You jettison anyone who does not go 100% party in politics. Musk is an example. You value the court because you use them to make laws.

 

[Rogue AI]

What silly nonsense. Since Trump has not invoked the Insurrection Act any talk of 'rebellion' is moot. Nor is this a 10th Amendment issue. Once federalized there is only one Commander in Chief, state's rights have no bearing on that. The loony tunes judiciary has become a threat to the republic and that loser Roberts does nothing. Pathetic.

 

[elektra]

You know most of the Republicans wish Trump would have lost to Hillary? Even Kamala? They secretly wished he'd lose/go away.

I think Mitch might have convicted Trump in the Senate for Jan 6 if he knew Trump would run and win again in 4 years. He thought Trump was done but Trump is the gift that keeps on giving.

I'm pretty confident the USA will fix itself eventually. And I feel what makes us great is we are a pendulum. We swing left for awhile, eventually we swing back to the right and back and forth.

The one thing I hate is the Supremes will be conservative for the rest of my life. I'm 55. Even if I live to 85, the court will still be conservative right? Those justices aren't going anywhere.

Maybe not

The ages of the current Supreme Court justices range from 53 to 75, with Clarence Thomas being the oldest at 75 and Ketanji Brown Jackson the youngest at 53. The justices are: Samuel Alito (75), Sonia Sotomayor (71), John Roberts (69), Elena Kagan (63), Brett Kavanaugh (58), Neil Gorsuch (56), and Amy Coney Barrett (53).

I thought Alito was going to retire after that recording of him and his wife. Vergogna. She said something caught on tape that led me to believe he was going to retire if Trump won. So Trump could replace him with a conservative.

How old are you? Why are you a Republican/Conservative/MAGA?

I am 62, a man born in detroit. Lived there, moved north to rural armada. Apple orchards, and corn fields.

Life was tough, I made it, fist fighting, petty fake gang shit that was real. **** I seen much.

We had race riots in 67, I was too young to remember but I remember we never went downtown. Murder capitol of the world.

I seen detroit alive and thriving 2 cars built every second. I saw how the environmentalists and taxes ran the car companies out of detroit.

 

[NewsVine_Mariyam]

Yes Trump is doing test runs with the troops. Getting us used to him using the troops. He's going to need them if he's going to steal 2028.

In most cases, active-duty soldiers are prohibited from performing law enforcement functions in Baltimore or elsewhere in the United States. This is due to the Posse Comitatus Act, a federal law that restricts the use of the U.S. military for domestic law enforcement. There are, however, limited exceptions, particularly for the National Guard, who may be called upon by a state's governor during emergencies.

I asked my AI assistant how Trump was able to do this, and it turns out it’s because Washington, D.C. isn’t a state. Since it has no governor, the president acts as the de facto commander-in-chief of the District — giving him more direct authority over deploying the National Guard there than he would in a state like Maryland or Virginia.

 

[Blaster]

It's plain as day, there is no justification for his actions and it breaks the 10th.

Is Trump going to appeal to his favorite accessory....?

I'm sure Trump will appeal this unfair ruling.

 

[EvilCat Breath]

Republicans should be working behind the scenes to encourage enemies like Pritzker and Newsom to take up arms against federal agents. Push them until there is no doubt that the national guard is necessary.

What's going on with federal Marshalls? Can't they be used?

 

[sealybobo]

I am 62, a man born in detroit. Lived there, moved north to rural armada. Apple orchards, and corn fields.

Life was tough, I made it, fist fighting, petty fake gang shit that was real. **** I seen much.

We had race riots in 67, I was too young to remember but I remember we never went downtown. Murder capitol of the world.

I seen detroit alive and thriving 2 cars built every second. I saw how the environmentalists and taxes ran the car companies out of detroit.

I thought it was the good for nothing uneducated overpaid blue collar union workers?

Let’s be honest. They went with cheaper Mexican labor.

And yes environmental regulations. You act like that’s a bad thing. Are you stupid?

 

[sealybobo]

I asked my AI assistant how Trump was able to do this, and it turns out it’s because Washington, D.C. isn’t a state. Since it has no governor, the president acts as the de facto commander-in-chief of the District — giving him more direct authority over deploying the National Guard there than he would in a state like Maryland or Virginia.

So how is he doing it in other cities? He’s making up shit. Says those cities are on fire. What news is he watching? Ah yes, fox and newsmax. They’re controlling trump with fake news

 

[WEATHER53]

“Likely and maybe” as a ruling is bogus and troops are there anyway