All UN Members Walk Out on Netanyahu Speech

[Sherlock Holmes]

Lol the point is Israel isn't commiting genocide. Stop bleating BS

If Jews had accused the Third Reich of engaging in Genocide in 1936 would they have been right?

But answer the question how can you prove that what's taking place in Gaza is not genocide?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Why? what is the ratio and who defined it?

Your criteria is from a Kafka novel - only if the Israelis admit genocide will you believe there's genocide, that's it really, that's the bottom line for the dumb amongst us, a vacuous position, driven by racist ideology not facts.

How many bombs? How many dead Arabs?

 

[SassyIrishLass]

If Jews had accused the Third Reich of engaging in Genocide in 1936 would they have been right?

But answer the question how can you prove that what's taking place in Gaza is not genocide?

Well Gaza would be obliterated and Israel could certainly do it

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

How many bombs? How many dead Arabs?

In 1939 Jews had already been exiting Germany for some years, they feared genocide as the record shows.

In 1939 100 Jews had been killed during Kristallnacht and about 30,000 sent to camps.

The Third Reich had repeatedly referred to Jews as vermin and implied wiping them out as a solution to a problem.

So at the start of WW2 genocide had already started yet only a few thousands Jews had yet been killed.

 

[BackAgain]

What reasoning leads you to believe they are not engaged in genocide? what is the criteria? what would need to happen for you to agree that genocide was underway?

I’ve covered this topic innumerable times.

I use an actual dictionary definition of “genocide,” for starters.

Also, there’s the fact that for almost all of its attacks on Hamas (the shitbags who are perfectly content to use Palestinian people and hospitals and food distribution locations to “hide behind”) the IDF has a habit of giving prior warning to the local population.

And I realize that nevertheless some Palestinian civilians (likely including actual Hamas vermin) have been killed. But the non intentional outcome of civilian deaths in war has never been “genocide” in the past and it still isn’t.

The better question is; how can you clam — using any valid definition of the term “genocide” — that Israel is engaged in any effort at genocide?

You can’t.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

I’ve covered this topic innumerable times.

I use an actual dictionary definition of “genocide,” for starters.

Also, there’s the fact that for almost all of its attacks on Hamas (the shitbags who are perfectly content to use Palestinian people and hospitals and food distribution locations to “hide behind”) the IDF has a habit of giving prior warning to the local population.

And I realize that nevertheless some Palestinian civilians (likely including actual Hamas vermin) have been killed. But the non intentional outcome of civilian deaths in war has never been “genocide” in the past and it still isn’t.

The better question is; how can you clam — using any valid definition of the term “genocide” — that Israel is engaged in any effort at genocide?

You can’t.

Yes, this is now beyond any doubt.

The UN recently found that there is a man made famine underway in Gaza, a "manmade disaster", "Famine is not about food; it is the deliberate collapse of the systems needed for human survival.”.

Genocide's definition includes point 3:

Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;

Israel has and is creating famine conditions intentionally and doing so meets condition 3 of the UN's definition of genocide.

That should wrap it it up for you, it does for all decent human beings, but you're the same as the Holocaust denier, twisting and squirming words out of desperation to somehow prove that black is white that evil is good, **** off.

 

[M14 Shooter]

Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. Pure and simple.

This is an outright lie.
All you do is lie.
Pure and simple.

 

[BackAgain]

Yes, this is now beyond any doubt.

The UN recently found that there is a man made famine underway in Gaza, a "manmade disaster", "Famine is not about food; it is the deliberate collapse of the systems needed for human survival.”.

Genocide's definition includes point 3:


Israel have and are creating famine conditions intentionally and doing so meets condition 3 of the UN's definition of genocide.

That should wrap it it up for you, it does for all decent human beings, but you're the same as the Holocaust denier, twisting and squirming words out of desperation to somehow prove that black is white that evil is good, **** off.

No. It’s far beyond just having doubt. It’s bullshit. The same Marion as shoes like you falsely accuse of genocide are striving mightily to send Gazans food. But Hamas steals it. And they even theme re-sell it to help fund their atrocities.

What the UN “reports” is primarily propaganda for useful idiots like you.

And as I said earlier, I use the ACTUAL definition of “genocide.” You rely on the fictional alterations to any true definition.

It isn’t black or white. I never said it was. But, even so, you’re full of shit. So here your own advice Hemlock: **** off.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

No. It’s far beyond just having doubt. It’s bullshit. The same Marion as shoes like you falsely accuse of genocide are striving mightily to send Gazans food. But Hamas steals it. And they even theme re-sell it to help fund their atrocities.

You're in a very tiny minority, you need to think about that, why would 96% of the world's people see genocide and a fraction of he others 4% (The US population) jump up and down and play holocaust denial?

What the UN “reports” is primarily propaganda for useful idiots like you.

Not really, the UN is a democratic (remember that word?) institution, the majority of members have repeatedly declared Israel to be an illegal occupying power among many other unsavory things. I don't see how a tiny percentage of people can credibly accuse the other 96% of peddling propaganda, surely even you can see how ridiculous that is?

And as I said earlier, I use the ACTUAL definition of “genocide.” You rely on the fictional alterations to any true definition.

The "definition" arose in a book by a Polish lawyer in 1944. So far as law goes, the term became formally defined during he genocide convention held in 1948 here it is.

Israel formally signed the declaration on 17 Aug 1949, so as you can see the "Point 3" I referred to above is copied verbatim from the very definition to which Israel assented (and the US in Dec 1948) to my mind this is the "actual definition", the one formally signed by the Israeli government - do you not agree?

It isn’t black or white. I never said it was. But, even so, you’re full of shit. So here your own advice Hemlock: **** off.

You're a neo-Holocaust denier and your sickening attempts to twist and distort facts in order to sanitize the mass slaughter being carried out by the Israelis is disgusting, one of the most disgusting things I see in the world today.

 

[BackAgain]

You're in a very tiny minority, you need to think about that, why would 96% of the world's people see genocide and a fraction of he others 4% (The US population) jump up and down and play holocaust denial?

Not really, the UN is a democratic (remember that word?) institution, the majority of members have repeatedly declared Israel to be an illegal occupying power among many other unsavory things. I don't see how a tiny percentage of people can credibly accuse the other 96% of peddling propaganda, surely even you can see how ridiculous that is?

The "definition" arose in a book by a Polish lawyer in 1944. So far as law goes, the term became formally defined during he genocide convention held in 1948 here it is.

Israel formally signed the declaration on 17 Aug 1949, so as you can see the "Point 3" I referred to above is copied verbatim from the very definition to which Israel assented (and the US in Dec 1948) to my mind this is the "actual definition", the one formally signed by the Israeli government - do you not agree?

You're a neo-Holocaust denier and your sickening attempts to twist and distort facts in order to sanitize the mass slaughter being carried out by the Israelis is disgusting, one of the most disgusting things I see in the world today.

I hereby note that I didn’t read your post beyond your first paragraph.

Your numbers are fictional. But even if they were true, that would mean only that under things far too clearly than to be deceived by the MSM propaganda efforts.

You’re truly a gullible useful idiot. What you’re useful for is not determined.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

I hereby note that I didn’t read your post beyond your first paragraph.

I hereby don't give a shit, I just showed you the official definition of Genocide that Israel signed in 1949 and it includes the point 3 I mentioned earlier, why didn't you know about this anyway?

Your numbers are fictional. But even if they were true, that would mean only that under things far too clearly than to be deceived by the MSM propaganda efforts.

The US represents 4.2% of the world's population. Only three nations to my knowledge have issued emphatic denials that a genocide is underway in Gaza - Israel and the USA and Germany.

You’re truly a gullible useful idiot. What you’re useful for is not determined.

I'm useful for putting nasty bastards like you under a microscope for all to see the disease that you are.

You are the same as the holocaust deniers, you think yourself so much better but you are the same, filth.

 

[theHawk]

Why would they walk out like spoiled children?

Jew fatigue.

 

[Lisa558]

You'd think they'd have a much, much higher dead Arab per bomb ratio.

If Israel wanted to commit a genocide, every last Palestinian would have been dead by October 14, 2023.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

If Israel wanted to commit a genocide, every last Palestinian would have been dead by October 14, 2023.

Let me paraphrase by way of showing you how absurd you are:

"If Germany had wanted to commit genocide, every last Jew would have been dead by 1934."

See? see how stupid you are woman?

 

[SassyIrishLass]

Let me paraphrase by way of showing you how absurd you are:

"If Germany had wanted to commit genocide, every last Jew would have been dead by 1934."

See? see how stupid you are woman?

Hitler's goal was too large but about 6 million was a gallant effort

 

[Mac-7]

Jew fatigue.

Not Palestinian fatigue?

 

[Lisa558]

Let me paraphrase by way of showing you how absurd you are:

"If Germany had wanted to commit genocide, every last Jew would have been dead by 1934."

See? see how stupid you are woman?

Are you the antisemite who just lied and said that 96% of people think Israel is committing genocide? What a nasty lie to spread in order to advance Jew-hate.

And your analogy is idiotic. Did the Nazis warn Jews to allow them to escape? Did they take steps to REDUCE the number of Jews that they killed?

The comparison of Israel to Nazi Germany is one of the most disgusting antisemitic lie there is.

 

[theHawk]

Not Palestinian fatigue?

I sure am tired of them, but that isn’t why they walked out.

 

[Lisa558]

Yes, this is now beyond any doubt.

The UN recently found that there is a man made famine underway in Gaza, a "manmade disaster", "Famine is not about food; it is the deliberate collapse of the systems needed for human survival.”.

Genocide's definition includes point 3:


Israel has and is creating famine conditions intentionally and doing so meets condition 3 of the UN's definition of genocide.

That should wrap it it up for you, it does for all decent human beings, but you're the same as the Holocaust denier, twisting and squirming words out of desperation to somehow prove that black is white that evil is good, **** off.

Oh….the anti-Jew, anti-Israel UB found that did they?

 

[Mac-7]

I sure am tired of them, but that isn’t why they walked out.

I guess so

The current UN is totally on the wrong side of history AND the future