I will reiterate the question that Care4All posed:
How would voter ID laws stop the election fraud that is to be alleged with these indictments?
So far there are very few details in this case. If there was, indeed, some sort of election fraud, then I hope it is prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. Of course, it helps if we know what law they have violated.
What always bugs me about these discussions is not whether or not voter ID laws would stop this fraud or even any fraud. It is the absolute denial of the left (not saying you personally) that Democrats do this, yet the fervent insistence that Republicans do this all the time. That kind of partisanship pisses me off. Any thinking human being would realize that if one side or the other finds a way to cheat, the other side is going to try to beat them at their own game. It is not like either side in this discussion has a moral bone in its body so to speak.
Also, I simply cannot understand why anyone believes that there are very many American adults who do not have an ID since so much of our lives require one. It amazes me that people like TDM will claim that millions of Americans (when there are only slightly more than 300 million men, women and children in America) don't have some form of legal ID. To me it only makes sense that one would have to prove who he/she is before casting a vote.
It is only common sense that someone would have to prove who they are before they cast a vote.
Immie
You only have to "believe" the facts.
Studies have been done and those studies show that there ARE voters who will be disenfranchised by some of these states more restrictive voter ID laws. Some voters already HAVE, especially the elderly.
I don't, necessarily, have a problem with
some form of voter ID, but the laws that some of these states are passing are so restrictive that things like student IDs are not accepted as valid.
I'd feel a lot better about some of these ID laws if there was a grandfather clause. If you've been voting your whole life, you shouldn't have to suddenly jump through
hoops to get an ID.
The kind of fraud being alleged in this thread will not be stopped by Voter ID laws. The kind of fraud that is ACTUALLY occurring isn't going to be stopped with Voter ID laws. Heck, the Supreme Court could not find ANY cases of fraud that will be stopped with these restrictive Voter ID laws.
If these conservative states really WERE concerned with Election Fraud, they would be doing a lot more than passing
excessively restrictive voter ID laws that DO disenfranchise voters. They would be pushing for more transparency...for example, in Wisconsin where a single registrar stored ALL the votes on her personal computer or in Texas where the State Supreme Court actually ruled that no paper trail is required for electronic voting.
This is where the actual fraud can and DOES occur, but these states that are passing the most restrictive Voter ID laws aren't even LOOKING at these things.
Does that strike you as them wanting to prevent fraud or just prevent
some people from voting?
THE BRENNAN CENTER FOR JUSTICE?
It is quite possible their research is skewed
Besides, even the author of the report, Norden, said
“We’re not claiming that all 3.2 million, in the case of voter ID laws, are actually not going to be able to vote."
Fundamentally, it will fall down to believability to the US public
Very few believe that showing ID for voting would be burden and find it
hard to believe that people who use the system in any way, can not
come up with some ID. Furthermore, the negative impact ,if any, would be
very limited and easily corrected. Indeed, the only people who resist would
be people who have something to hide, be it themselves or some activity they
are engaging in, like voter fraud. Indeed, give us some examples of people who
have no ID of any type and could never get it?
Besides, most of these laws have a “laundry list” of exemptions for people who may
have a hard time obtaining the required identification,
such as living more than 50 miles away from the nearest Division of Motor Vehicles.
Furthermore, it adds integrity to the voting system and cuts down on fraud.
Votes from the dead, multiple votes, etc only cancel out the legitimate votes.
The Left has a hard time selling this one because people fundamentally know, it is the right thing to do.
(albeit for a few leftists who want voter fraud to continue since it tends to favor them)
New laws requiring voters to show photo identification are set to take effect in
Kansas, Rhode Island, Wisconsin, Alabama, South Carolina, Tennessee and Texas.