what did pvt manning really do or reveal?

[Sunni Man]

You, Ringel and Mudwhistle all think these leaks were not due to Bradley Manning...Why???

Franklin D. Roosevelt:

"In politics, nothing happens by accident. If it happens you can bet it was planned that way."

 

[Sallow]

It doesn't seem as if very real harm was done by this information dump. But it was terribly wrong. Manning should do some jail time and never be allowed around sensitive information again.

define "harm".

I'd say setting up a secret fund to help guys that rape nuns..is pretty harmful..

You?

 

[Trajan]

It doesn't seem as if very real harm was done by this information dump. But it was terribly wrong. Manning should do some jail time and never be allowed around sensitive information again.

define "harm".

I'd say setting up a secret fund to help guys that rape nuns..is pretty harmful..

You?

when you answer with a serious response......

 

[asterism]

Valerie, heres an idea if you are willing to listen to ideas.

The young man reveled these documents to show to the world how easy it was for him to obtain them.

You see he was outing the country for its extrememly POOR security of what it labeled secret documents.

It was a whistler blower act.

He knew if he could optain them soooo easily that these docs were completely insecure and had already no doubt been veiwed by someone on the outside.


electronic comunications and storage are HORRIBLY unprotected by our country AND the corporations.

Computors are NOT secure enough to do the business that system (both gov and private) are increasingly forcing us to use for information that should be completely secure.


Its a whistle blower case, the young man thought he was helping the US protect itsself.

GET IT NOW??????

There are very effective ways to do that without risking the lives, sources, or methods of intelligence collection. He did not need to make the whole dataset public if all he wanted to do was expose flaws in the security systems.

You are absolutely wrong.

 

[007]

Valerie, heres an idea if you are willing to listen to ideas.

The young man reveled these documents to show to the world how easy it was for him to obtain them.

You see he was outing the country for its extrememly POOR security of what it labeled secret documents.

It was a whistler blower act.

He knew if he could optain them soooo easily that these docs were completely insecure and had already no doubt been veiwed by someone on the outside.


electronic comunications and storage are HORRIBLY unprotected by our country AND the corporations.

Computors are NOT secure enough to do the business that system (both gov and private) are increasingly forcing us to use for information that should be completely secure.


Its a whistle blower case, the young man thought he was helping the US protect itsself.

GET IT NOW??????

There are very effective ways to do that without risking the lives, sources, or methods of intelligence collection. He did not need to make the whole dataset public if all he wanted to do was expose flaws in the security systems.

You are absolutely wrong.

99.9% of the time she is.

 

[Sallow]

define "harm".

I'd say setting up a secret fund to help guys that rape nuns..is pretty harmful..

You?

when you answer with a serious response......

That was serious.

We had a defacto shadow government going on in the first part of the Reagan administration. No one was "executed" or served life sentences. Their crimes were far worse.

 

[strollingbones]

at this point i am with holding judgement until more facts are in...i think this story will have a lot of turns and twists before the whole truth is known

 

[hortysir]

Valerie, heres an idea if you are willing to listen to ideas.

The young man reveled these documents to show to the world how easy it was for him to obtain them.

You see he was outing the country for its extrememly POOR security of what it labeled secret documents.

It was a whistler blower act.

He knew if he could optain them soooo easily that these docs were completely insecure and had already no doubt been veiwed by someone on the outside.


electronic comunications and storage are HORRIBLY unprotected by our country AND the corporations.

Computors are NOT secure enough to do the business that system (both gov and private) are increasingly forcing us to use for information that should be completely secure.


Its a whistle blower case, the young man thought he was helping the US protect itsself.

GET IT NOW??????

Yep. I get that you are complete and total fucking moron.

He should have taken it up his chain of command rather than turning it over to the world.