- Apr 1, 2011
- 170,023
- 47,212
- 2,180
The private owners did not control industry in Nazi Germany. The government did.
Nazis did allow for private ownership, and private profits... Just with mild micro-management for National Interest.
The allowed the "owners" to have a worthless scrap of paper. Meanwhile the government made all the important decisions for the enterprise. The so-called "owners" were reduced to little more than factory managers.
The term "mild micro management" is an oxymoron.
Actually the factory owners were enriched fheavily and the workers were often times slave laborers.
How do you know if they were "enriched?" What they recieved isn't propaerly labeled a "profit" in the economic sense of the term. It was simply a payment from the government. A profit is the result of trading your goods in the market. Factory "owners" didn't trade anything. Their prices were determined by the government. So where their customers and their suppliers.
Companies such as Mercedes made a lot of money due to the use of slave labor provided by the government and then of course that same government provided these companies with a lot of business. Deutsche Bank made out like bandits seizing Jewish assets. When you have a government that reduces it's citizens rights such as religious freedoms, democratic institutions such as the right to vote and banning trade unions while supplying the rich with free labor you're called a right wing fascist government.
The Soviet Union also reduced the right of citizens to vote, banned trade unions and curtailed religious freedom, and it had a class of wealthy party apparatchiks who had an endless supply of labor at their disposal. Slave elabor was used to build damns, mine for gold, cut wood, and manufacter numerous items. Opressive governments are all on the left. All you're doing is applying different labels to the exact same behavior.
The compensation Mercedes recieved is not properly described as a profit, according to the economic definition of the term. A profit is a surplus produced by the difference in price of the company's inputs compared to the proceeds from the sale of its products on the market. When government controls the price of the inputs, the price of the product and the quanitity produced and "sold," any excess is purely a decision made by government bureacrats, not the market. There is no market under fascism.