Not sure where to put this

[Gdjjr]

So, feel free to move it to an "appropriate" forum, but, it was written recently.

This is an ongoing argument- for the record I think the holacaust is way over played. The comments at the end are interesting. This site has some pretty knowledgeable responders/posters.

What Happened to Jews Sent to the Aktion Reinhardt Camps?

Establishment historians state that all Jews sent to the Aktion Reinhardt camps of Treblinka, Belzec and Sobibor were exterminated. It is claimed that a handful of strong young Jews were temporarily spared to keep the camps running. All other Jews sent to the Aktion Reinhardt camps were immediately gassed upon arrival without registration.[1]

In his book Holocaust, historian Peter Longerich states that 1,274,166 Jews had been killed in the Aktion Reinhardt camps by the end of 1942. Longerich bases his statement on the fact that the Höfle telegram shows that this many Jews had been sent by then to the Aktion Reinhardt camps. Longerich assumes that every Jew sent to the Aktion Reinhardt camps was murdered.[2]

This article will show that the Aktion Reinhardt camps were actually transit camps rather than extermination camps.

Demographic Studies

 

[dannyboys]

So, feel free to move it to an "appropriate" forum, but, it was written recently.

This is an ongoing argument- for the record I think the holacaust is way over played. The comments at the end are interesting. This site has some pretty knowledgeable responders/posters.

What Happened to Jews Sent to the Aktion Reinhardt Camps?

Establishment historians state that all Jews sent to the Aktion Reinhardt camps of Treblinka, Belzec and Sobibor were exterminated. It is claimed that a handful of strong young Jews were temporarily spared to keep the camps running. All other Jews sent to the Aktion Reinhardt camps were immediately gassed upon arrival without registration.[1]

In his book Holocaust, historian Peter Longerich states that 1,274,166 Jews had been killed in the Aktion Reinhardt camps by the end of 1942. Longerich bases his statement on the fact that the Höfle telegram shows that this many Jews had been sent by then to the Aktion Reinhardt camps. Longerich assumes that every Jew sent to the Aktion Reinhardt camps was murdered.[2]

This article will show that the Aktion Reinhardt camps were actually transit camps rather than extermination camps.

Demographic Studies

Oh goodie! Another holocaust denier. Just what this forum needs.
Permanent Ignore asshole!

 

[miketx]

Why do you think it was overplayed?

 

[Oddball]

Why do you think it was overplayed?

Stalin and Mao murdered far more people....But where are the "Holocausts of Communism" museums?....Why aren't we beat over the head on a regular basis about the atrocities of the Holomodor and the Great Leap Forward?

 

[Biff_Poindexter]

Why do you think it was overplayed?

Stalin and Mao murdered far more people....But where are the "Holocausts of Communism" museums?....Why aren't we beat over the head on a regular basis about the atrocities of the Holomodor and the Great Leap Forward?

Maybe China and Russia should put some museums up then......

 

[Oddball]

Why do you think it was overplayed?

Stalin and Mao murdered far more people....But where are the "Holocausts of Communism" museums?....Why aren't we beat over the head on a regular basis about the atrocities of the Holomodor and the Great Leap Forward?

Maybe China and Russia should put some museums up then......

Why is Murican taxpayer money being frittered away on them?....None of that crap happened here.

 

[Biff_Poindexter]

Why do you think it was overplayed?

Stalin and Mao murdered far more people....But where are the "Holocausts of Communism" museums?....Why aren't we beat over the head on a regular basis about the atrocities of the Holomodor and the Great Leap Forward?

Maybe China and Russia should put some museums up then......

Why is Murican taxpayer money being frittered away on them?....None of that crap happened here.

So your complaint isn't about the lack of other holocaust museums in China and Russia -- you are just pissed that there are holocaust museums here...

Maybe you can get Trump and the GOP to campaign on that in 2020....unless you are a coward?

 

[jwoodie]

Oh goodie! Another holocaust denier.

I don't think debating its extent makes one a holocaust "denier." At least as many non-Jews were also killed, but that fact seems to be receding in modern historical accounts. Isn't it enough to describe it as one of several atrocious genocides during the 20th Century?

 

[CarlinAnnArbor]

Why do you think it was overplayed?

Stalin and Mao murdered far more people....But where are the "Holocausts of Communism" museums?....Why aren't we beat over the head on a regular basis about the atrocities of the Holomodor and the Great Leap Forward?

Are you being "beaten over the head"? I'm not seeing that.

 

[Oddball]

Why do you think it was overplayed?

Stalin and Mao murdered far more people....But where are the "Holocausts of Communism" museums?....Why aren't we beat over the head on a regular basis about the atrocities of the Holomodor and the Great Leap Forward?

Maybe China and Russia should put some museums up then......

Why is Murican taxpayer money being frittered away on them?....None of that crap happened here.

So your complaint isn't about the lack of other holocaust museums in China and Russia -- you are just pissed that there are holocaust museums here...

Maybe you can get Trump and the GOP to campaign on that in 2020....unless you are a coward?

Didn't answer my question...Why is taxpayer money being expended to commemorate/exhibit something that neither happened here or was in any way a Murican historical event?

 

[Gdjjr]

Well since the person I wanted to reply to is a coward-

I deny the jews are victims as claimed- they bring a lot of crap on themselves with their behavior- this particular article deals with a specific site- it refutes the claims by evidence- denying evidence is THE why *this* country (USA) is in the mess it's in
That said- how many actually took the trouble to read the article or the comments?
The commenters are actually well read about most of the stuff they comment on- of course there are dunderheads who would rather attack a messenger than actually read evidence (message) like any public forum, but there, like here, you have to read-

 

[Gdjjr]

We've (the world) has been duped.

Today’s American Neocons are just as heavily Jewish as were the Bolsheviks of a hundred years ago, and they have greatly benefited from the political immunity provided by this totally bizarre inversion of historical reality. Partly as a consequence of their media-fabricated victimhood status, they have managed to seize control over much of our political system, especially our foreign policy, and have spent the last few years doing their utmost to foment an absolutely insane war with nuclear-armed Russia. If they do manage to achieve that unfortunate goal, they will surely outdo the very impressive human body-count racked up by their ethnic ancestors, perhaps even by an order-of-magnitude or more.

Excerpt:

We must also recognize that many of the fundamental ideas that dominate our present-day world were founded upon a particular understanding of that wartime history, and if there seems good reason to believe that narrative is substantially false, perhaps we should begin questioning the framework of beliefs erected upon it.

George Orwell fought in the Spanish Civil War during the 1930s and discovered that the true facts in Spain were radically different from what he had been led to believe by the British media of his day.