spectrumc01
I give you....the TRUTH
What to look for in determining the best quarterback of all time. There are all kinds of things to look at, but I believe these to be the most important.
1) Wins. How many do you have? I figure 100 or better. There are only 11 QB's with 100+ wins, and one QB with less than 100 wins but 3-0 in the Superbowl, i.e. Aikman.
2) Super Bowl appearances / wins. How many times have you gotten your team to the big one, and when you got there did you win? There are only several QB's with 4 and 5 Super bowl appearnces. Montana and Bradshaw are 4-0, Elway 2-3, Tarkenton 0-4, Kelly 0-4.
3) Stats. How good were you mechanically?
Looking at this I would have to list them like this.
1) Montana (4-0 SB) (100+ wins) (more wins) (better stats)
2) Bradshaw (4-0 SB) (100+ wins)
3) Elway (2-3 SB) (100+wins)
4) Brady (3-1 SB) (100+ wins)
5) Kelly (0-4 SB) (100+ wins) (more wins) (better stats)
6) Tarkenton (0-4 SB) (100+ wins)
7) Aikman (3-0 SB) (less than 100 wins)
8) Griese (2-1 SB) (less than 100 wins)
1) Wins. How many do you have? I figure 100 or better. There are only 11 QB's with 100+ wins, and one QB with less than 100 wins but 3-0 in the Superbowl, i.e. Aikman.
2) Super Bowl appearances / wins. How many times have you gotten your team to the big one, and when you got there did you win? There are only several QB's with 4 and 5 Super bowl appearnces. Montana and Bradshaw are 4-0, Elway 2-3, Tarkenton 0-4, Kelly 0-4.
3) Stats. How good were you mechanically?
Looking at this I would have to list them like this.
1) Montana (4-0 SB) (100+ wins) (more wins) (better stats)
2) Bradshaw (4-0 SB) (100+ wins)
3) Elway (2-3 SB) (100+wins)
4) Brady (3-1 SB) (100+ wins)
5) Kelly (0-4 SB) (100+ wins) (more wins) (better stats)
6) Tarkenton (0-4 SB) (100+ wins)
7) Aikman (3-0 SB) (less than 100 wins)
8) Griese (2-1 SB) (less than 100 wins)