Hey Billo. I would take Puig for the simple reason that his upside is so full of superstar potential. Trout is a proven commodity and swings a good bat, but how can I pick against a ballplayer with so much energy and raw talent?
Puig can outrun Trout, has a lot better arm, and once he learns to harness all his talents...his future (barring a bad injury) is limitless.
Now you know what you sound like when you're talking about the Lakers, Billo.
Trout > Puig. And it's really not that close.