pinqy
Gold Member
I like the debate tactic....you don't like or don't understand my point so you ignore it to just restate your own point. Nice dodge...I'm sure not many people noticed.And all he's really saying is that "something" must have made all this. That it seems irrational that this all happened by chance.
Not that it "seems" irrational... it IS irrational. .
If I took you out to a golf course and showed you my golf ball sitting on the one blade of grass dyed pink on the whole course (fairway of the 4th hole) and told you that I hit exactly that blade when I teed off from the 4th hole, would you say it was irrational to say it happened by chance?
First of all, I totally don't understand your analogy. The odds of a randomly created universe with the fine tuning in evidence is enormous. Much greater than the odds in your analogy, or any analogy your mind can imagine.
But try my analogy again. I promise I'll explain. Forget about the differences in scale, it's not important at this stage. It's pretty straight forward......Is the probability of a golf ball landing on one particular blade of grass so low that it couldn't happen by chance, or could it happen by chance?