Hiryuu
Gold Member
- Jul 27, 2016
- 1,769
- 208
- 130
Thanks for the nice read.
I think you have reminded us all enough already, don't you think?
I read this article today. . . your thoughts?
It's a long read.
I'm not sure you are up for it.
The Fantasy of Black Nationalism
Whatever the 1960's may go down in history for, the resurgence of "black nationalism" will surely be high on, ifā¦
Theodore Draper / Sept. 1, 1969
The Fantasy of Black Nationalism - Commentary Magazine
". . .This is not the place to try to settle this issue, even if it were within my capabilities. What strikes me most of all, however, is the many-sided specificity of the American Negro problem. It breaks out of one conceptual compartment after another and yet defies a synthesis of all of them. The Negro group is a āminorityāābut it is unlike all other minority groups. It is a āclassā for the vast majority of its membersābut it extends beyond the class line. It has some likeness to a ācasteāābut the basis of this casteācolorāstrikingly differentiates it from the classical Indian caste system. The only thing to do with such a phenomenon is to see it for itself and not to make it something else. American history, especially the appallingly incompatible heritage of slavery and democracy, the distribution of population, the ever more interdependent and interlocking economy, are among the circumstances which have molded the American Negro problem in ways that are both like and unlike any other. The colonial or national metaphor may be mistaken, but it evokes enough of the reality to be persuasive to those who are desperately looking for a quick answer. If fantasy is a substitute for reality, then the fantasy of black nationalism should help us to understand better the reality for which it is a substitute.
The cost of misunderstanding has become catastrophic. That black nationalism may not be the answer does not mean the present system can continue in the same old way. It must adapt itself to the new conditions brought about by the failure to wipe out the old ghettos which, instead, have spawned more and greater ghettos. The black rural enclaves and urban ghettos cannot create a new nation, but they can attempt to form a new type of ālocal political community,ā as Professor Kennan has suggested. What it is going to be can only be dimly perceived at present. But of one thing we may be sure. As long as America permits black enclaves and ghettos, it cannot deny them representation of their own choosingāand remain true to itself or even avoid a conflagration. The democratic process itself must bring about far-reaching change in the relations of blacks and whites. Only political double bookkeeping and the most outrageous inequities prevented such change earlier. The critical problem at this stage is whether the new political communities, whatever they may be, will relate more or less realistically to the rest of the country or whether they will be infected with the nationalist fantasy and encourage a destructiveāand self-destructiveāseparatism from the rest of the country. Once the fantasy sets in, no arrangement, however well-meaning, is workable. Whatever the road ahead, it can scarcely fail to be a hard one, full of bumps and sharp turns, threatening to many existing vested interests. But if the democratic road is blocked, the nationalist fantasy will loom larger and larger, even if it can destroy far more than it can create. There has been a white fantasy to get rid of blacks, and a black fantasy to get rid of whites. After more than two centuries, it is high time for both whites and blacks to get rid of their fantasies instead of each other."
Thanks for finding something that expresses intent to find a new idea and acknowledges the fact it may not work.
The second paragraph was more interesting to me, because it describes a common dilemma. You can take all the people (regardless of race or political affiliation) from a middle class suburban neighborhood, and put them in a ghetto. You could take all the people (regardless of race or political affiliation) from the ghetto, and put them in the middle class suburban neighborhood. You could have each neighborhood elect their own governing body. You could come back in 15 years and the what was the ghetto will be a middle class neighborhood, and what was the middle class neighborhood will be a ghetto.
Fixing the buildings isn't going to work, fixing the politics won't make a difference either. You have to fix the people for it to ever make a difference.