BREAKING: The UN concludes that Israel has established an APARTHEID REGIME...

[P F Tinmore]

RE: BREAKING: The UN concludes that Israel has established an APARTHEID REGIME...
※→ P F Tinmore, et al,

Yes, this observation is correct. None of the states were mentioned. It became a function of the Mandate System and the Allied Power under which the Mandate was administered.

I go back to the commentary in Post #116 and 117 of (Palestine Today) wherein you drop back onto the Article 30 argument; and our friend "Shusha" corrects your mistake.

None of the new states were mentioned.
Do you have a point?

(COMMENT)

There is no reason for the Arab Palestinian to suggest that they belong to a particular regional class of people that is superior to the Jewish People, and that greater international community should grant dominate, control, and allow the Arab Palestinian to subjugate the Jewish People. In fact, the Arab Palestinian consistently hold the position that the entire territorial landscape, once under the authority of the Occupied Enemy Territory Administration (OETA) then transferred to the formerly civil administered under the British Mandate, should have been given such control.

The Arab Palestinian, believing that the have the superior right to demand sovereign control over the entire territory (formerly under the administration of the British Mandate). Making this demand four months after the Jewish People declared independence. The Arab Palestinian believe they (as the majority) had the right to subjugate the earlier established Right of Self-Determination exercised by the minority Jewish People in the creation of the Jewish State. And the Arab Palestinian claiming the right to override the authority of the Allied Powers which had agreed to the establishment in Palestine (within such boundaries as may be fixed by them) of a national home for the Jewish people,

(THE POINT)

Just where did the Arab Palestinian people get the notion that they can come-in "after the fact" and (in both 1948 and 1967) and demand sovereignty over territory that was never under Arab Palestinian control?

Most Respectfully,
R

Talk about reading disability.

 

[P F Tinmore]

United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia
Page not found

The requested page "/sites/www.unescwa.org/files/uploads/israeli-practices-palestinian-people-apartheid-occupation-executive-summary-english.pdf" could not be found.

UN ESCWA report on Israeli apartheid | Palestine Liberation Organization | West Bank

 

[Hollie]

United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia
Page not found

The requested page "/sites/www.unescwa.org/files/uploads/israeli-practices-palestinian-people-apartheid-occupation-executive-summary-english.pdf" could not be found.

UN ESCWA report on Israeli apartheid | Palestine Liberation Organization | West Bank

You poor, angry Islamist.

It’s not surprising that a collection of retrograde Islamic backwaters would use the “apartheid” slogan. Both you and your co-religionists are ignorant of the definition.

Let’s take a look at which Islamist Hell-holes make up the collection of Islamist fascists collectively called ESCWA, shall we?

ESCWA comprises 18 Arab countries:Bahrain, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Oman, the State of Palestine, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the Sudan, the Syrian Arab Republic, Tunisia, the United Arab Emirates and Yemen.

 

[P F Tinmore]

There is no reason for the Arab Palestinian to suggest that they belong to a particular regional class of people that is superior to the Jewish People, and that greater international community should grant dominate, control, and allow the Arab Palestinian to subjugate the Jewish People.

The Palestinians were citizens of Palestine. That gave them the same rights as any of the citizens of their countries anyplace.

The native Jews became citizens also without distinction.

 

[Hollie]

There is no reason for the Arab Palestinian to suggest that they belong to a particular regional class of people that is superior to the Jewish People, and that greater international community should grant dominate, control, and allow the Arab Palestinian to subjugate the Jewish People.

The Palestinians were citizens of Palestine. That gave them the same rights as any of the citizens of their countries anyplace.

The native Jews became citizens also without distinction.

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

If the Islamics would simply convert to Judaism, allow right of return, problem solved.

 

[P F Tinmore]

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

They did but Israel upset their apple cart in 1948. The Palestinians had no problem with Jews living in Gaza.

 

[P F Tinmore]

United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia
Page not found

The requested page "/sites/www.unescwa.org/files/uploads/israeli-practices-palestinian-people-apartheid-occupation-executive-summary-english.pdf" could not be found.

UN ESCWA report on Israeli apartheid | Palestine Liberation Organization | West Bank

You poor, angry Islamist.

It’s not surprising that a collection of retrograde Islamic backwaters would use the “apartheid” slogan. Both you and your co-religionists are ignorant of the definition.

Let’s take a look at which Islamist Hell-holes make up the collection of Islamist fascists collectively called ESCWA, shall we?

ESCWA comprises 18 Arab countries:Bahrain, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Oman, the State of Palestine, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the Sudan, the Syrian Arab Republic, Tunisia, the United Arab Emirates and Yemen.

The ESCWA report merely confirmed what people had been saying for decades. The report was not made by "Arabs." The report was written by a Christian and a Jew. The report found that Israel has created a system of discrimination and domination over the Palestinian people wherever they may live. That is as obvious as the nose on your face.

 

[Hollie]

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

They did but Israel upset their apple cart in 1948. The Palestinians had no problem with Jews living in Gaza.

That was a poor attempt at trying to sidestep Islamist fascism. Arabs-Moslems have always had a problem with Jews. Jews are reviled in your Korans.

I’m guessing you’re just incensed that the Jews threw off the shackles of the dhimmi status that was a fact of life under the Ottoman rule.

 

[Hollie]

I’m afraid your excuses are another fail.

 

[P F Tinmore]

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

They did but Israel upset their apple cart in 1948. The Palestinians had no problem with Jews living in Gaza.

That was a poor attempt at trying to sidestep Islamist fascism. Arabs-Moslems have always had a problem with Jews. Jews are reviled in your Korans.

I’m guessing you’re just incensed that the Jews threw off the shackles of the dhimmi status that was a fact of life under the Ottoman rule.

The dhimmi status has been gone since the middle of the 19th century and no Palestinian has ever mentioned bringing it back. You are the only person ever mentioning it.

 

[Hollie]

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

They did but Israel upset their apple cart in 1948. The Palestinians had no problem with Jews living in Gaza.

That was a poor attempt at trying to sidestep Islamist fascism. Arabs-Moslems have always had a problem with Jews. Jews are reviled in your Korans.

I’m guessing you’re just incensed that the Jews threw off the shackles of the dhimmi status that was a fact of life under the Ottoman rule.

The dhimmi status has been gone since the middle of the 19th century and no Palestinian has ever mentioned bringing it back. You are the only person ever mentioning it.

Yes, the inability of the Islamic fascists to impose the dhimmi status was a result of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. We do, however, continue to see the results of Islamist fascism across the Islamist Middle East (and in the mini-caliphates of Gaza’istan and Fatah’istan) with the expulsion of non- Islamics.

It’s quite the inversion of reality to see you Islamics whine about your phony “apartheid” claims when Islamic fascism is so clearly demonstrated across the Islamist world.

 

[P F Tinmore]

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

They did but Israel upset their apple cart in 1948. The Palestinians had no problem with Jews living in Gaza.

That was a poor attempt at trying to sidestep Islamist fascism. Arabs-Moslems have always had a problem with Jews. Jews are reviled in your Korans.

I’m guessing you’re just incensed that the Jews threw off the shackles of the dhimmi status that was a fact of life under the Ottoman rule.

The dhimmi status has been gone since the middle of the 19th century and no Palestinian has ever mentioned bringing it back. You are the only person ever mentioning it.

Yes, the inability of the Islamic fascists to impose the dhimmi status was a result of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. We do, however, continue to see the results of Islamist fascism across the Islamist Middle East (and in the mini-caliphates of Gaza’istan and Fatah’istan) with the expulsion of non- Islamics.

It’s quite the inversion of reality to see you Islamics whine about your phony “apartheid” claims when Islamic fascism is so clearly demonstrated across the Islamist world.

Yes, the inability of the Islamic fascists to impose the dhimmi status was a result of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.

Again not true. The Ottoman Empire eliminated the dhimmi status 50 years before its demise.

 

[rylah]

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

They did but Israel upset their apple cart in 1948. The Palestinians had no problem with Jews living in Gaza.

That was a poor attempt at trying to sidestep Islamist fascism. Arabs-Moslems have always had a problem with Jews. Jews are reviled in your Korans.

I’m guessing you’re just incensed that the Jews threw off the shackles of the dhimmi status that was a fact of life under the Ottoman rule.

The dhimmi status has been gone since the middle of the 19th century and no Palestinian has ever mentioned bringing it back. You are the only person ever mentioning it.

Yes, the inability of the Islamic fascists to impose the dhimmi status was a result of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. We do, however, continue to see the results of Islamist fascism across the Islamist Middle East (and in the mini-caliphates of Gaza’istan and Fatah’istan) with the expulsion of non- Islamics.

It’s quite the inversion of reality to see you Islamics whine about your phony “apartheid” claims when Islamic fascism is so clearly demonstrated across the Islamist world.

Yes, the inability of the Islamic fascists to impose the dhimmi status was a result of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.

Again not true. The Ottoman Empire eliminated the dhimmi status 50 years before its demise.

As far as I know djhimma was only one of the special Jews taxes in the empire.
One of the causes for the Arab rebellion against Egyptians was that they were made to pay the same taxes as Christians and Jews.

Ereikat family main business at that time was "giving protection" to Christian pilgrims on the road..and You know how it goes for those who don't pay "protection".

 

[eagle1462010]

The comparison between the Israeli Forces and the Jihadist, the Fedayeen, Hostile Insurgents, Radicalized Islamic Followers, and Asymmetric fighters of Arab Palestinians is no contest.

Indeed, Israel is trying to steal all of Palestine and get rid of the Palestinians while the Palestinians are trying to defend themselves. There is no contest.

Palestinians are not trying to defend themselves -- as they are not under attack.

What they are trying to do is gain sovereign control of territory over which they have no sovereignty and have never had any sovereignty, based on the idea that the territory is "theirs" and they have sole rights to self-determination there.

The Palestinians are under attack every day.

Not so. Those living peaceful lives are living peaceful lives.

Palestinians have been attacked in their own villages since before 1948 and those attacks continue today. Who are they attacking while sitting at home?

Area was a battleground of wwi................both sides evacuated the area of concern...............it was the end of the Ottoman Empire.........Turkey LOST........

None of these countries EVEN EXISTED UNTIL AFTER WWI.

 

[Hollie]

So, all of those native Jews living in Gaza’istan became citizens of your invented Magical Kingdom of Disney Pally’land?

They did but Israel upset their apple cart in 1948. The Palestinians had no problem with Jews living in Gaza.

That was a poor attempt at trying to sidestep Islamist fascism. Arabs-Moslems have always had a problem with Jews. Jews are reviled in your Korans.

I’m guessing you’re just incensed that the Jews threw off the shackles of the dhimmi status that was a fact of life under the Ottoman rule.

The dhimmi status has been gone since the middle of the 19th century and no Palestinian has ever mentioned bringing it back. You are the only person ever mentioning it.

Yes, the inability of the Islamic fascists to impose the dhimmi status was a result of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. We do, however, continue to see the results of Islamist fascism across the Islamist Middle East (and in the mini-caliphates of Gaza’istan and Fatah’istan) with the expulsion of non- Islamics.

It’s quite the inversion of reality to see you Islamics whine about your phony “apartheid” claims when Islamic fascism is so clearly demonstrated across the Islamist world.

Yes, the inability of the Islamic fascists to impose the dhimmi status was a result of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.

Again not true. The Ottoman Empire eliminated the dhimmi status 50 years before its demise.

Again, the Ottoman Empire collapsed long before it’s dissolution in 1922. There was simply no method whereby Islamics could enforce their fascist policy of dhimmitude.

Islamic fascists in places such as your Islamist paradise of Gaza’istan resolve that issue by simply expelling the non-Islamics.

 

[eagle1462010]

Armenian Genocide of 1915: An Overview - New York Times

Armenian Genocide of 1915: An Overview
By JOHN KIFNER
On the eve of World War I, there were two million Armenians in the declining Ottoman Empire. By 1922, there were fewer than 400,000. The others — some 1.5 million — were killed in what historians consider a genocide.

As David Fromkin put it in his widely praised history of World War I and its aftermath, “A Peace to End All Peace”: “Rape and beating were commonplace. Those who were not killed at once were driven through mountains and deserts without food, drink or shelter. Hundreds of thousands of Armenians eventually succumbed or were killed .”

 

[eagle1462010]

 

[eagle1462010]

 

[harmonica]

the Palestinians should thank their lucky stars Israel has not shoved them into the sea for all the murderous/etc crap the Pals have done

 

[eagle1462010]

Some groups of people on this earth CHOOSE TO BE ON THE WRONG SIDE OF HISTORY...................

BLAME OTHERS FOR THE SAME SHIT THEY DO.................

Others NOT SO MUCH................These others don't give a damn about those on the wrong side of History complaints............Only that if you TRY YOUR BS AGAIN............we WILL BE ON YOUR DOOR STEP AND DO THE SAME THING THE WORLD DID TO THE OTTOMANS.....

Have a Nice Day.