Indeependent
Diamond Member
- Nov 19, 2013
- 73,633
- 28,506
- 2,250
Arab sites have no contradictions, they have lies.The territory in question (Area A) is disputed. By definition it has no sovereignty and therefore no nationality. By definition, then, there ARE no citizens. Try again.A foreign national is some one not a citizen of the area in question.
Either BOTH Israelis and Arab Palestinians are citizens of the territory. Or neither are. To say that one group is and one group is not is biased.
These to paragraphs contradict each other. On the one hand, you say that, due to the rules of your game, only Israelis can be settlers. On the other hand, you claim that neither are settlers. Please resolve your own contradiction.An Arab settlement would be a new town or outpost built in the occupied/disputed territories, between the start of the Israeli settlement program and now. To keep it clear, let’s define settlers as Israeli nationals.
As to who are the settlers in the Jewish Quarter? I would say neither. War and subsequent policies caused considerable population shifts.
And this is yet another entirely different objective definition. Please resolve your own contradiction.A foreigner is some one who was not a resident there (or the progeny of) at the time it was occupied.
Well, I have no idea what refugee camps have to do with anything. But I agree in principle that Arab Palestinians have just as much right to build in Area C as Israelis. They just don't have the infrastructure and government and economy to do it. Largely because they can't focus on the right things. And since they created a security problem for Israel, well, Israel has to address it.If you choose to define it broadly than Palestinians in refugee camps would have equal right to enter and settle those areas as well as Israel.
You keep asking me for a different definition. It is not my contradiction, it is your unwillingness to accept the definitions.
No. It is because your definitions contain internal contradictions. You need to resolve those internal contradictions first.