21st amendment illegal

[rupol2000]

The 21st amendment was under pressure from the totalitarian criminal regime FDR. Laws written by criminals have no legal force. Prohibition has not been repealed.

 

[Thunk]

The constitution is the HIGHEST law of the land. An amendment cannot be "illegal".

A law can be unconstitutional...but not the other way around.

 

[White 6]

The 21st amendment was under pressure from the totalitarian criminal regime FDR. Laws written by criminals have no legal force. Prohibition has not been repealed.

I'll drink to that!

 

[Thunk]

I'll drink to that!

 

[ReinyDays]

All states tax booze ... that's what makes the 21st Amendment lawful ...

 

[WinterBorn]

The 21st amendment was under pressure from the totalitarian criminal regime FDR. Laws written by criminals have no legal force. Prohibition has not been repealed.

Your dislike of FDR does not make him a criminal. And regardless of who was in the White House, the constitutional amendment was properly ratified. So the 21st amendment, like the 18th amendment, was law.

 

[WinterBorn]

The 21st amendment was under pressure from the totalitarian criminal regime FDR. Laws written by criminals have no legal force. Prohibition has not been repealed.

So you claim FDR was a criminal, and therefore had no authority or legal force. So you want to reject all laws passed between March 1933 and April 1945?


Also, if you intend to remove all the laws written by FDR's administration, you have to present a law he broke.

 

[rupol2000]

The constitution is the HIGHEST law of the land. An amendment cannot be "illegal".

A law can be unconstitutional...but not the other way around.

This is de facto abolition by rewriting the constitution, and this is an unprecedented case. If you don't want to cut out the illegal 21st amendment, then cancel it with an amendment from above, as the criminals did.

 

[rupol2000]

All states tax booze ... that's what makes the 21st Amendment lawful ...

Alcohol is the drink of the slaves. This is what the Left needs to bring European slaves to America and push out Free Americans.

 

[rupol2000]

Your dislike of FDR does not make him a criminal. And regardless of who was in the White House, the constitutional amendment was properly ratified. So the 21st amendment, like the 18th amendment, was law.

He is a criminal, he committed crimes against the American people, he tried to make slaves out of Americans, to impose the slave regime of Stalinism. Served hostile communism and British imperialism. This is an enemy agent.

 

[WinterBorn]

He is a criminal, he committed crimes against the American people, he tried to make slaves out of Americans, to impose the slave regime of Stalinism. Served hostile communism and British imperialism. This is an enemy agent.

That is a lot of generalized nonsense. You'll have to list specific crimes.

Oh, and the president is not the final deciding factor in a constitutional amendment.

 

[rupol2000]

That is a lot of generalized nonsense. You'll have to list specific crimes.

Illegal confiscations of property, enslavement, forced resettlement, cooperation with Stalin's terrorists, and so on.

 

[WinterBorn]

Illegal confiscations of property, enslavement, forced resettlement, cooperation with Stalin's terrorists, and so on.

And you think, despite getting the required votes from the states to amend the US Constitution, the 21st amendment should be thrown out and Prohibition brought back?

It was obviously a losing proposition to ban alcohol. The people voted, as the constitution clearly outlines, for the 21st amendment.

It will stand, despite your lunatic desires to the contrary.

 

[Concerned American]

This is de facto abolition by rewriting the constitution,

The founders were very clear in establishing a method to amend the constitution. It is very difficult to do. The fact that it was done attests to the will of the people being followed in their quest for self government--regardless of how you believe things should be given your short 23 years of experience.

 

[rupol2000]

And you think, despite getting the required votes from the states to amend the US Constitution, the 21st amendment should be thrown out and Prohibition brought back?

It was obviously a losing proposition to ban alcohol. The people voted, as the constitution clearly outlines, for the 21st amendment.

It will stand, despite your lunatic desires to the contrary.

It's a scam, just like the market crash of '29. After that, America plunged into shit

 

[WinterBorn]

It's a scam, just like the market crash of '29. After that, America plunged into shit

It is not a scam. The scam would be people believing you that the 21st amendment was never ratified.

 

[rupol2000]

The founders were very clear in establishing a method to amend the constitution. It is very difficult to do. The fact that it was done attests to the will of the people being followed in their quest for self government--regardless of how you believe things should be given your short 23 years of experience.

lies. The criminals just made a scam. There was only the German-British lobby, but they are the same criminals.

 

[WinterBorn]

lies. The criminals just made a scam. There was only the German-British lobby, but they are the same criminals.

36 states voted to ratify the 21st amendment. That is 75% of the 48 states. There was no scam. There was the will of the people.

 

[rupol2000]

36 states voted to ratify the 21st amendment. That is 75% of the 48 states. There was no scam. There was the will of the people.

This is a scam. Americans had no reason to vote against their prosperity of the roaring twenties

 

[WinterBorn]

This is a scam. Americans had no reason to vote against their prosperity of the roaring twenties

They voted to bring back alcohol sales in the US.

Rather than allow the criminals to run it all.