US Message Board šŸ¦…

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

China is the world's largest creditor... so why doesn't the USA go after the $1 trillion China owes the USA?

healthmyths

Platinum Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Messages
28,549
Reaction score
10,095
Points
900
The worldā€™s largest creditors should take coordinated and decisive action to address the ā€œgenerational challengeā€ of poorer nations struggling with unmanageable debt burdens, a top US Treasury official said, aiming specific criticism at China, the biggest lender to emerging markets.

In 1938, during its conflict with Japan, the ROC defaulted on its sovereign debt. After the military victory of the communists, the ROC government fled to Taiwan. The Peopleā€™s Republic of China was eventually recognized internationally as the successor government of China. Under well-established international law, the ā€œsuccessor governmentā€ doctrine holds that the current government of China, led by the Chinese Communist Party, is responsible for repayment of the defaulted bonds.
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

Great Britain had China pay back... BUT did the USA???
Then-U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcherā€™s tough negotiation stance on the return of Hong Kong to China led to a British settlement agreement on these same Chinese bonds in 1987. Thatcher said that for China to have access to U.K. capital markets, it had to honor the defaulted Chinese sovereign debt held by British subjects. Faced with that stark choice, China agreed.

BUT WHAT ABOUT USA ???
Unfortunately, the U.S. failed to take such a common-sense stance.
To this day, China has had access to U.S. capital markets while openly rejecting its sovereign debt obligations(Plus $1 Trillion!) to American bondholders.
Lest anyone wonder about the age of these bonds, it is irrelevant. What matters is that this is a sovereign obligation. As recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.

The Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have a unique opportunity to enforce the well-established international rule that governments must honor their debts. Like the U.K. did in 1987, the U.S. must view the repayment of Chinaā€™s sovereign debt as essential to its national security interests.
In doing so, the U.S. government should undertake one or both of two actions currently being discussed by members of Congress.
 

scruffy

Diamond Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2022
Messages
18,596
Reaction score
15,114
Points
2,288
There's an old saying, if the bank lends you a few thousand bucks the bank owns you, because you have to pay it back.

But if the bank loans you a billion bucks, you own the bank. Because they depend on you to pay it back.
 

healthmyths

Platinum Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Messages
28,549
Reaction score
10,095
Points
900
There's an old saying, if the bank lends you a few thousand bucks the bank owns you, because you have to pay it back.

But if the bank loans you a billion bucks, you own the bank. Because they depend on you to pay it back.
As you said... that's an OLD saying! Reality is as "recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.
So why hasn't the USA held China responsible for it?
 

JGalt

Diamond Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2011
Messages
70,453
Reaction score
84,414
Points
3,635
The worldā€™s largest creditors should take coordinated and decisive action to address the ā€œgenerational challengeā€ of poorer nations struggling with unmanageable debt burdens, a top US Treasury official said, aiming specific criticism at China, the biggest lender to emerging markets.

In 1938, during its conflict with Japan, the ROC defaulted on its sovereign debt. After the military victory of the communists, the ROC government fled to Taiwan. The Peopleā€™s Republic of China was eventually recognized internationally as the successor government of China. Under well-established international law, the ā€œsuccessor governmentā€ doctrine holds that the current government of China, led by the Chinese Communist Party, is responsible for repayment of the defaulted bonds.
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

Great Britain had China pay back... BUT did the USA???
Then-U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcherā€™s tough negotiation stance on the return of Hong Kong to China led to a British settlement agreement on these same Chinese bonds in 1987. Thatcher said that for China to have access to U.K. capital markets, it had to honor the defaulted Chinese sovereign debt held by British subjects. Faced with that stark choice, China agreed.

BUT WHAT ABOUT USA ???
Unfortunately, the U.S. failed to take such a common-sense stance.
To this day, China has had access to U.S. capital markets while openly rejecting its sovereign debt obligations(Plus $1 Trillion!) to American bondholders.
Lest anyone wonder about the age of these bonds, it is irrelevant. What matters is that this is a sovereign obligation. As recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.

The Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have a unique opportunity to enforce the well-established international rule that governments must honor their debts. Like the U.K. did in 1987, the U.S. must view the repayment of Chinaā€™s sovereign debt as essential to its national security interests.
In doing so, the U.S. government should undertake one or both of two actions currently being discussed by members of Congress.

Well we owe China $859 billion so we might as well default on it, call it even, and tell them to go fuck themselves.

We'd still be ahead a billion and a half dollars. :banana:
 

JoeB131

Diamond Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2011
Messages
168,955
Reaction score
31,652
Points
2,220
Location
Chicago, Chicago, that Toddling Town
The worldā€™s largest creditors should take coordinated and decisive action to address the ā€œgenerational challengeā€ of poorer nations struggling with unmanageable debt burdens, a top US Treasury official said, aiming specific criticism at China, the biggest lender to emerging markets.

In 1938, during its conflict with Japan, the ROC defaulted on its sovereign debt. After the military victory of the communists, the ROC government fled to Taiwan. The Peopleā€™s Republic of China was eventually recognized internationally as the successor government of China. Under well-established international law, the ā€œsuccessor governmentā€ doctrine holds that the current government of China, led by the Chinese Communist Party, is responsible for repayment of the defaulted bonds.
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

Great Britain had China pay back... BUT did the USA???
Then-U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcherā€™s tough negotiation stance on the return of Hong Kong to China led to a British settlement agreement on these same Chinese bonds in 1987. Thatcher said that for China to have access to U.K. capital markets, it had to honor the defaulted Chinese sovereign debt held by British subjects. Faced with that stark choice, China agreed.

BUT WHAT ABOUT USA ???
Unfortunately, the U.S. failed to take such a common-sense stance.
To this day, China has had access to U.S. capital markets while openly rejecting its sovereign debt obligations(Plus $1 Trillion!) to American bondholders.
Lest anyone wonder about the age of these bonds, it is irrelevant. What matters is that this is a sovereign obligation. As recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.

The Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have a unique opportunity to enforce the well-established international rule that governments must honor their debts. Like the U.K. did in 1987, the U.S. must view the repayment of Chinaā€™s sovereign debt as essential to its national security interests.
In doing so, the U.S. government should undertake one or both of two actions currently being discussed by members of Congress.
The UK had leverage, in that China wanted Hong Kong back.

We don't really have leverage to get Beijing to honor Chiang Kai-shek's old debts.
 

Invisibleflash

Diamond Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2019
Messages
2,051
Reaction score
1,685
Points
1,940
Location
Born L.A.-NYC is 2nd home-Rustbelt is home base
The worldā€™s largest creditors should take coordinated and decisive action to address the ā€œgenerational challengeā€ of poorer nations struggling with unmanageable debt burdens, a top US Treasury official said, aiming specific criticism at China, the biggest lender to emerging markets.

In 1938, during its conflict with Japan, the ROC defaulted on its sovereign debt. After the military victory of the communists, the ROC government fled to Taiwan. The Peopleā€™s Republic of China was eventually recognized internationally as the successor government of China. Under well-established international law, the ā€œsuccessor governmentā€ doctrine holds that the current government of China, led by the Chinese Communist Party, is responsible for repayment of the defaulted bonds.
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

Great Britain had China pay back... BUT did the USA???
Then-U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcherā€™s tough negotiation stance on the return of Hong Kong to China led to a British settlement agreement on these same Chinese bonds in 1987. Thatcher said that for China to have access to U.K. capital markets, it had to honor the defaulted Chinese sovereign debt held by British subjects. Faced with that stark choice, China agreed.

BUT WHAT ABOUT USA ???
Unfortunately, the U.S. failed to take such a common-sense stance.
To this day, China has had access to U.S. capital markets while openly rejecting its sovereign debt obligations(Plus $1 Trillion!) to American bondholders.
Lest anyone wonder about the age of these bonds, it is irrelevant. What matters is that this is a sovereign obligation. As recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.

The Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have a unique opportunity to enforce the well-established international rule that governments must honor their debts. Like the U.K. did in 1987, the U.S. must view the repayment of Chinaā€™s sovereign debt as essential to its national security interests.
In doing so, the U.S. government should undertake one or both of two actions currently being discussed by members of Congress.

xi won.png
 

Dragonlady

Designing Woman
Joined
Dec 1, 2012
Messages
51,897
Reaction score
30,077
Points
2,615
Location
Niagara Escarpment
The worldā€™s largest creditors should take coordinated and decisive action to address the ā€œgenerational challengeā€ of poorer nations struggling with unmanageable debt burdens, a top US Treasury official said, aiming specific criticism at China, the biggest lender to emerging markets.

In 1938, during its conflict with Japan, the ROC defaulted on its sovereign debt. After the military victory of the communists, the ROC government fled to Taiwan. The Peopleā€™s Republic of China was eventually recognized internationally as the successor government of China. Under well-established international law, the ā€œsuccessor governmentā€ doctrine holds that the current government of China, led by the Chinese Communist Party, is responsible for repayment of the defaulted bonds.
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

Great Britain had China pay back... BUT did the USA???
Then-U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcherā€™s tough negotiation stance on the return of Hong Kong to China led to a British settlement agreement on these same Chinese bonds in 1987. Thatcher said that for China to have access to U.K. capital markets, it had to honor the defaulted Chinese sovereign debt held by British subjects. Faced with that stark choice, China agreed.

BUT WHAT ABOUT USA ???
Unfortunately, the U.S. failed to take such a common-sense stance.
To this day, China has had access to U.S. capital markets while openly rejecting its sovereign debt obligations(Plus $1 Trillion!) to American bondholders.
Lest anyone wonder about the age of these bonds, it is irrelevant. What matters is that this is a sovereign obligation. As recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.

The Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have a unique opportunity to enforce the well-established international rule that governments must honor their debts. Like the U.K. did in 1987, the U.S. must view the repayment of Chinaā€™s sovereign debt as essential to its national security interests.
In doing so, the U.S. government should undertake one or both of two actions currently being discussed by members of Congress.

Why doesn't the USA go after the government of Taiwan for the debt?????? They're the ones who borrowed the money. Not the communists.

The difference between Great Britain and the USA, is that the British aren't living on the national credit card and borrowing money to cover their budgets. They're TAXING British corporations and people to pay for their programs.

As long as the USA keeps running massive deficits, it's not to their benefit to piss off their bankers.
 

Toddsterpatriot

Diamond Member
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
100,376
Reaction score
34,788
Points
2,250
Location
Chicago
The worldā€™s largest creditors should take coordinated and decisive action to address the ā€œgenerational challengeā€ of poorer nations struggling with unmanageable debt burdens, a top US Treasury official said, aiming specific criticism at China, the biggest lender to emerging markets.

In 1938, during its conflict with Japan, the ROC defaulted on its sovereign debt. After the military victory of the communists, the ROC government fled to Taiwan. The Peopleā€™s Republic of China was eventually recognized internationally as the successor government of China. Under well-established international law, the ā€œsuccessor governmentā€ doctrine holds that the current government of China, led by the Chinese Communist Party, is responsible for repayment of the defaulted bonds.
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

Great Britain had China pay back... BUT did the USA???
Then-U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcherā€™s tough negotiation stance on the return of Hong Kong to China led to a British settlement agreement on these same Chinese bonds in 1987. Thatcher said that for China to have access to U.K. capital markets, it had to honor the defaulted Chinese sovereign debt held by British subjects. Faced with that stark choice, China agreed.

BUT WHAT ABOUT USA ???
Unfortunately, the U.S. failed to take such a common-sense stance.
To this day, China has had access to U.S. capital markets while openly rejecting its sovereign debt obligations(Plus $1 Trillion!) to American bondholders.
Lest anyone wonder about the age of these bonds, it is irrelevant. What matters is that this is a sovereign obligation. As recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.

The Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have a unique opportunity to enforce the well-established international rule that governments must honor their debts. Like the U.K. did in 1987, the U.S. must view the repayment of Chinaā€™s sovereign debt as essential to its national security interests.
In doing so, the U.S. government should undertake one or both of two actions currently being discussed by members of Congress.

A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

I've seen this silly claim before.
Their math might actually be worse than yours.
I know, that hardly seems possible.
 

tyroneweaver

Platinum Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2012
Messages
25,863
Reaction score
11,149
Points
940
Location
Burley, Idaho
The worldā€™s largest creditors should take coordinated and decisive action to address the ā€œgenerational challengeā€ of poorer nations struggling with unmanageable debt burdens, a top US Treasury official said, aiming specific criticism at China, the biggest lender to emerging markets.

In 1938, during its conflict with Japan, the ROC defaulted on its sovereign debt. After the military victory of the communists, the ROC government fled to Taiwan. The Peopleā€™s Republic of China was eventually recognized internationally as the successor government of China. Under well-established international law, the ā€œsuccessor governmentā€ doctrine holds that the current government of China, led by the Chinese Communist Party, is responsible for repayment of the defaulted bonds.
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

Great Britain had China pay back... BUT did the USA???
Then-U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcherā€™s tough negotiation stance on the return of Hong Kong to China led to a British settlement agreement on these same Chinese bonds in 1987. Thatcher said that for China to have access to U.K. capital markets, it had to honor the defaulted Chinese sovereign debt held by British subjects. Faced with that stark choice, China agreed.

BUT WHAT ABOUT USA ???
Unfortunately, the U.S. failed to take such a common-sense stance.
To this day, China has had access to U.S. capital markets while openly rejecting its sovereign debt obligations(Plus $1 Trillion!) to American bondholders.
Lest anyone wonder about the age of these bonds, it is irrelevant. What matters is that this is a sovereign obligation. As recently as 2010, the German government made its last payment for reparations from World War I. In 2015 Great Britain made payments on bonds issuances that dated from the 18th century.

The Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have a unique opportunity to enforce the well-established international rule that governments must honor their debts. Like the U.K. did in 1987, the U.S. must view the repayment of Chinaā€™s sovereign debt as essential to its national security interests.
In doing so, the U.S. government should undertake one or both of two actions currently being discussed by members of Congress.
There's an old Vulcan proverb. " Only Nixon can go to China."
 

lennypartiv

Diamond Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
25,973
Reaction score
19,923
Points
2,320
China is not in great financial shape.

---China's Hidden-Debt Problem Laid Bare in Zunyi City's Half-Finished Roads, Empty Flats--


---China's Great Wall of Debt---


---Unforgettable Photos Of Chinaā€™s Uninhabited Ghost Cities---

 

healthmyths

Platinum Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Messages
28,549
Reaction score
10,095
Points
900
A private group of American citizens holds a large quantity of these gold-denominated bonds. This citizen-led group, the American Bondholders Foundation (ABF), serves as trustee with power of attorney for some 20,000 bondholders, whose bonds are valued at well more than $1 trillion.

I've seen this silly claim before.
Their math might actually be worse than yours.
I know, that hardly seems possible.
So where is your proof the math is wrong? Besides wheather the number is $999,999,999 or $1,000,000,000,001 is not the point which obviously goes way above your IQ!
 

22lcidw

Diamond Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2018
Messages
43,631
Reaction score
20,338
Points
2,285
The UK had leverage, in that China wanted Hong Kong back.

We don't really have leverage to get Beijing to honor Chiang Kai-shek's old debts.
When it comes to those debts, they really do not go away and they cause massive misery. From five hundred years ago, there are debts. Paying off loans is massive. A reason for the wars and deaths of many people.
 

Toddsterpatriot

Diamond Member
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
100,376
Reaction score
34,788
Points
2,250
Location
Chicago
So where is your proof the math is wrong? Besides wheather the number is $999,999,999 or $1,000,000,000,001 is not the point which obviously goes way above your IQ!

Post their calculation. I'll be glad to disprove it.
 

Forum List

Top