At a particularly low point, desperate for work, I resorted to an outfit known as Labor Ready. Compared to my previous, white-collar profession, the work I got through Labor Ready was hard, dirty, and sometimes unpleasant, and paid minimum wage; but it was honest work, and once I proved myself, I was able to consistently get work through them.
For a while, whenever I encountered a panhandler, begging for handouts, I told him about Labor Ready. I worked very hard for what meager earnings I was making, and I figured that anyone else who was willing to work as hard as I was, and to observe some very basic ethical standards, could make just as much money as I was; and anyone who wasn't willing to do that much certainly wasn't going to get any handouts from me out of my earnings.
I don't think any panhandler that I thus advised ever showed up at Labor Ready, and it didn't take me very long to realize that I wasn't doing the organization any good by trying to refer those types to it anyway.
I was much, much, much more sympathetic to panhandlers before this experience, than I have been since then.
Anyway, based on my experience, I have little faith that
Ben Thomson's idea would work out anywhere near as well as what he imagines.