Why Won’t People Sing the National Anthem Correctly?!?!?!

Anathema

Crotchety Olde Man
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
23,174
Reaction score
8,885
Points
910
Location
The Olden Days
One of my biggest pet peeves when I attend events or watch them on television…

Why the Hell do these singers feel it is appropriate for them to take liberties with the tempo and vocalization of the Star Sosngled Banner?

I understand it’s not an easy song to sing, lyrically and due to the range it requires; but why does everyone seem to feel it necessary to just openly slaughter the song when they’re asked to sing it at an event?
 
The "Star Spangled Banner" is a war anthem. Many think "America the Beautiful" should be the national anthem.

"America the Beautiful" embodies in its rather lengthy lyrics the highest ideals of a Christian nation. Most versions omit most of the verses of the song.
 
Last edited:
One of my biggest pet peeves when I attend events or watch them on television…

Why the Hell do these singers feel it is appropriate for them to take liberties with the tempo and vocalization of the Star Sosngled Banner?

I understand it’s not an easy song to sing, lyrically and due to the range it requires; but why does everyone seem to feel it necessary to just openly slaughter the song when they’re asked to sing it at an event?
It is a drinking song

It should be sung appropriately
 
The "Star Spangled Banner" is a war anthem. Many think "America the Beautiful" should be the national anthem.

"America the Beautiful" embodies in its rather lengthy lyrics the highest ideals of a Christian nation. Most versions omit most of the verses of the song.
Irrelevant. Until its officially changed the current anthem needs to be sung respectfully and properly.
 
Irrelevant. Until its officially changed the current anthem needs to be sung respectfully and properly.
I have heard of gatherings that play America the Beautiful in place of the Star Spangled Banner.
 
My big question concerning this song is when will we finally get to hear Alison Krauss sing it? Has she ever once been approached to sing it anywhere like before a sporting event for example? To me, the fact that she has never been the one to sing it before the Super Bowl is mind boggling! :( :( :(

God bless you and the angel always!!!

Holly (a fan of her since 1994)
 
One of my biggest pet peeves when I attend events or watch them on television…

Why the Hell do these singers feel it is appropriate for them to take liberties with the tempo and vocalization of the Star Sosngled Banner?

I understand it’s not an easy song to sing, lyrically and due to the range it requires; but why does everyone seem to feel it necessary to just openly slaughter the song when they’re asked to sing it at an event?
Total agreement. I won't listen to some fool turning the anthem into a "pop hit" or some other abomination. It should be sung with reverence and conviction. But these attention junkies want the world to hear their singing abilities (as if they had any) instead of the message.
 
Right here is my newest favorite performance of the song. :) :) :)



God bless you and Mason Ramsey always!!!

Holly (a girl who only loves him more every day)
 
It is a drinking song

It should be sung appropriately

a british drinking song.

Was the “Star-Spangled Banner” an old drinking song?​

Washington Library Center for Digital History Colonial Music Institute Essays Star-Spangled Banner

The words to our national anthem have nothing to do with consumption of alcohol, but the melody that Francis Scott Key had in mind when he wrote those words did originate decades earlier as the melody for a song in praise of wine.

That Francis Scott Key borrowed a popular melody for his famous song is very much in keeping with common practice of his time period. Many lyrics for songs written in the 18th and early 19th centuries were based upon popular melodies. Before there was copyright protection, melodies were recycled over and over again. These melodies, known by name by almost everyone, were used for whatever purpose presented itself—a political song, a hymn, a march tune, a drinking song, or a country dance. Melodies to theater songs were used for dancing, and dance tunes, even fast Irish jigs, were sometimes given sets of words.

Many sets of lyrics have been written to the melody that Key chose for his verses that eventually became our national anthem. In fact, by 1820, eighty-four were written in the United States alone. Unlike most common melodies, we know who wrote the original words, music, and why!

The song dates from the mid-1770s and it was composed for a group of London gentlemen who had recently formed a social club. The club met every other week in the winter. The meetings included a formal concert, a dinner, and a social time afterwards during which the members entertained each other by singing catches, glees, and amusing songs. In 1780, the diverse membership included “peers, commoners, aldermen, gentlemen, proctors, actors, and polite tradesmen.”
Was the “Star-Spangled Banner” an old drinking song?

:cheers2:

 
Why the Hell do these singers feel it is appropriate for them to take liberties with the tempo and vocalization of the Star Sosngled Banner?

Some do, some don't. I see many who give a very traditional rendition, but the answer obviously in the cases who do is that the singer is merely trying to express themselves individually through their singing. Why should that bother or surprise you?

I'm less concerned with whether it is copybook and more concerned that the singing is /good./

If I want to hear a record, I'll get a phonograph.
 
15th post
Some do, some don't. I see many who give a very traditional rendition, but the answer obviously in the cases who do is that the singer is merely trying to express themselves individually through their singing. Why should that bother or surprise you?

I'm less concerned with whether it is copybook and more concerned that the singing is /good./

If I want to hear a record, I'll get a phonograph.
If they’re singing it at a concert, that’s one thing. I wouldn’t pay money to hear someone else’s take on it, but I can understand the concrpt.

If it’s being sung before an event, as a respect for the nation, it needs to be sung in the traditional Manner
 
One of my biggest pet peeves when I attend events or watch them on television…

Why the Hell do these singers feel it is appropriate for them to take liberties with the tempo and vocalization of the Star Sosngled Banner?

I understand it’s not an easy song to sing, lyrically and due to the range it requires; but why does everyone seem to feel it necessary to just openly slaughter the song when they’re asked to sing it at an event?

I wonder why countries have a national song, it seems rather weird. And then people get all angry about people singing it in a way they don't like. It's like you're creating something just so people can get angry.
 
To me, these are the best group performances of the song. :) :) :)





God bless you and both groups always!!!

Holly
 
If they’re singing it at a concert, that’s one thing.
Whoever sings the SSB at a concert?

If it’s being sung before an event, as a respect for the nation, it needs to be sung in the traditional Manner
That is your opinion. It is usually sung before an event, and while I've heard some variants I didn't like, it was mainly for lack of singing skills not because of the variation. Variation is part of creativity and individuality, and I rather like there being the possibility of some unexpected but brilliant variation with the song, such as that time Whitney Houston sung her beautiful rendition of the song at the Super Bowl.

After all, America herself is /about/ individuality.
 
Back
Top Bottom