Why are the Pashtuns allowed to dominate Afghanistan?

[rupol2000]

As you know, the Taliban, which have already gathered to recognize as the Afghan official power, is a Pashtun movement.
But in fact, the Pashtuns are not the majority in Afghanistan, and besides, the number of Tajiks there is about the same. Shouldn't these claims be of concern to the United Nations Security Council? Shouldn't peacekeeping troops be brought in due to Pashtun chauvinism and violence associated with it?

 

[rupol2000]

And the best way out of this situation is to use the right to self-determination of peoples, enshrined in international law. That is, to allow the Hazaras, Tajiks and national minorities to form their own union and secede from Afghanistan, which is the de facto occupation regime of the Pashtuns.​

 

[rupol2000]

And if United Nations Security Council do not want decision this problem it means that it plays along with the violent occupation regime and discredits itself as an institution for the protection of peoples from arbitrariness.

 

[surada]

As you know, the Taliban, which have already gathered to recognize as the Afghan official power, is a Pashtun movement.
But in fact, the Pashtuns are not the majority in Afghanistan, and besides, the number of Tajiks there is about the same. Shouldn't these claims be of concern to the United Nations Security Council? Shouldn't peacekeeping troops be brought in due to Pashtun chauvinism and violence associated with it?

The Pashtuns are the majority.. The Pashtun areas are more densely populated. They claim to be descended from the tribe of Benjamin. Israel supports that claim.

 

[harmonica]

.....it's ruled by POWER--not PEACEFUL democratic elections
one Afhgan president said:
''"the Afghans recognize only crude force''''
they had 3 heads of state changes in less than 2 years-all were MURDERS
....these Mid East and African countries are nothing like the West

History of Afghanistan - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[rupol2000]

The Pashtuns are the majority.. The Pashtun areas are more densely populated. They claim to be descended from the tribe of Benjamin. Israel supports that claim.

Are there more of them than Hazaras, Tajiks and Uzbeks taken together?

 

[Unkotare]

All people are essentially the same when it comes right down to it.

 

[surada]

Are there more of them than Hazaras, Tajiks and Uzbeks taken together?

The Hazaras, Tajiks and Uzbeks are not united.

 

[rupol2000]

The Hazaras, Tajiks and Uzbeks are not united.

They can unite, they have a common Margiana-Bactrian history, and they actually represent close ethnic groups. For example, about 40% of Tajiks live in Uzbekistan.

 

[surada]

They can unite, they have a common Margiana-Bactrian history, and they actually represent close ethnic groups. For example, about 40% of Tajiks live in Uzbekistan.

They would more likely align with the Taliban. The Hazara are descended from the Khan.. They are also Shia Muslims and traditionally they have been considered 2nd class citizens.

 

[rupol2000]

In fact, all these peoples of the northern part of Afghanistan can unite under the common name of southwestern Turkestan. This is the southwestern wing of Turkestan, and Turkestan collapsed not so long ago.

 

[surada]

.....it's ruled by POWER--not PEACEFUL democratic elections
one Afhgan president said:
''"the Afghans recognize only crude force''''
they had 3 heads of state changes in less than 2 years-all were MURDERS
....these Mid East and African countries are nothing like the West

History of Afghanistan - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Before the Afghan communists overthrew the Monarchy they were literate. They had movie theaters, cafes, international schools, rock and roll and mini skirts.

 

[rupol2000]

They would more likely align with the Taliban. The Hazara are descended from the Khan.. They are also Shia Muslims and traditionally they have been considered 2nd class citizens.

All these peoples except the Pashtuns are united. Khan himself came from that very place, from Kabul. His grandfather is Kabul Khan. The Arabs then called Mongols not the Tungus as they are now, but the great Mughals from India to the Moghulistan(Modern Uyghuristan). They were the descendants of the Indo-Aryans

 

[White 6]

As you know, the Taliban, which have already gathered to recognize as the Afghan official power, is a Pashtun movement.
But in fact, the Pashtuns are not the majority in Afghanistan, and besides, the number of Tajiks there is about the same. Shouldn't these claims be of concern to the United Nations Security Council? Shouldn't peacekeeping troops be brought in due to Pashtun chauvinism and violence associated with it?

"Why are the Pashtuns allowed to dominate Afghanistan?" Because they have been around that region, dating back to the 11th or maybe 7th century? Who gives a rats ass about the UN Security Council or the UN itself? We are the major funder of the United Nations, but it has been years since they supported our interests. We are pulling out of Afghanistan. It has been in the papers and on TV. Surely, you heard about it. Why would we wish to fund that force and those lives, if we don't want to fight to force our vision of democracy, peace and tranquility on that country? Can't you find another line of work or production to fund your lifestyle.​

 

[harmonica]

Before the Afghan communists overthrew the Monarchy they were literate. They had movie theaters, cafes, international schools, rock and roll and mini skirts.

hey pal----3 heads of state murders = shithhole
look at it NOW!!!!!!!!!!
..it's like certain groups in the US = their culture is crap --this is not racism/hate-- but a fact
..they've had wars/conflicts for 40 years--and that's just the recent problems
...rock and roll and mini skirts doesn't mean their culture is the same ---
..my god, they treat women like shit

Over 54 Percent of Afghans Live Under Poverty Line: CSO

(Last Updated On: May 6, 2018)According to Afghanistan’s Central Statistics Organization (CSO), more than 54 percent of the population is living under the poverty line while the number has risen to 67 percent during winter seasons in the country. More than 155 thousand people from 34 provinces...

ariananews.af

 

[rupol2000]

If these peoples will be reunited with the Central Asian states, with with Turkmenistan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan, which are now independent, then if they annex the Chinese Uighurs, they will revive Turkestan.
In fact, they are fragments of these peoples, they are simply separated from them by the regime.

 

[rupol2000]

Because they have been around that region, dating back to the 11th or maybe 7th century?

Really? and where did the southwestern Turkestanis live then?

 

[surada]

hey pal----3 heads of state murders = shithhole
look at it NOW!!!!!!!!!!
..it's like certain groups in the US = their culture is crap --this is not racism/hate-- but a fact
..they've had wars/conflicts for 40 years--and that's just the recent problems
...rock and roll and mini skirts doesn't mean their culture is the same ---
..my god, they treat women like shit

Over 54 Percent of Afghans Live Under Poverty Line: CSO

(Last Updated On: May 6, 2018)According to Afghanistan’s Central Statistics Organization (CSO), more than 54 percent of the population is living under the poverty line while the number has risen to 67 percent during winter seasons in the country. More than 155 thousand people from 34 provinces...

ariananews.af

They didn't treat women like shit until the Americans left and the country collapsed into total lawlessness. The US initially believed the Taliban would restore law and order.. stopping the rapes and carjackings, kidnapping and smuggling. They were war orphans barely out of the teens and they absolutely went too far.

 

[harmonica]

surada OBVIOUSLY their culture is shit--UNDENIABLE except to a cultist/insane person .....

 

[White 6]

Really? and where did the southwestern Turkestanis live then?

Beats me. It wasn't Tennessee, I'll tell you that much.