Originally posted by gop_jeff
WW,
My comments are about the same as Darin's. It is up to God to judge who goes to heaven or hell. It is clear that both John and Bob are sinners. If Bob is really repentant, I would think that his behavior would change over time, even slightly. But even if not, if he is truly repantant, God is faithful to forgive.
Darin said it already, but God's grace is not dependent on our actions. We can look at someone like John and say "Man, what a great guy." But God does not determine our salvation based on our actions; otherwise, who could measure up?