No one is checking to see if the Shahak claims (or Chumpsky's reference to them) are real. Still no bio info on the mysterious Yinon, eh?
In fact they are checking, Squeal.
Ever heard of Amazon?
Zionist Plan for the Middle East (Special Document, No 1) Paperback – June, 1982
by
Oded Yinon (Author),
Israel Shahak (Translator)"
Zionist Plan for the Middle East Special Document No 1 Oded Yinon Israel Shahak 9780937694565 Amazon.com Books
Still no info on the mysterious Oled Yinon, I see.
Doesn't that strike you as a bit odd considering his alleged career as a high ranking Israeli official and Jerusalem Post journalist?
you really need to stay clear of the CT sites. They erode brain cells.
You slurp up lies and twist them around and pretend they are facts.
US has done everything to get Iraq to stay together. It might be divided into units for each major ethnic or religious
group but it is still one country. US is 50 states within one. It helps to give each a sense of power to represent the people/group and help them be both individuals and citizens of a country without the inherent abuse and persecution of just a single hateful authority.
The theory you keep believing exists as a conspiracy against Iraq makes no logical sense. The country is made up of three major groups and none of them want to oppressed by the others. Three units to share a distribution of power and to still stay together makes sense.
The region is a beautiful mosaic not separate pictures trying to over power each other.
Your 'theory' began as a scholarly exercise comparing what was being built against a possible alternative. It was just presenting another scenario. You look at all the possibilities and go with the one that will be best for the situation.
Bindenburg is a place for people from all areas of study to get together and share ideas, not to make policy. It allows those invited to get different perspective to help them make the best choices for the future for each of their countries, businesses or group.
It is important to get ideas from outside your own closed groups. You don't have to accept them, but even a bad idea can make you thing about things in a different way.
Lewis present a theory and it did not fly. Now CT nuts make it seem this is some global plan to bring on a catastrophe. Just think about what has been going on in Iraq since it's independence, It has had problems even longer and no been a cohesive unit. It has been pulling itself apart long before these papers were written. You need to look forward under all scenarios to anticipate all the what ifs and which path is the better one to take.
Thought exercises are not meant to be the only policy a country(ies) or group should take, just a possibility of what might happen in this or that circumstance.
To split Iraq would leave too many resources in the hands of one or two group and leave the third to suffer or be killed off. The world has been trying to keep Iraq as a single state, not divided, for the last few decades. If you don't present what might happen if they were divided then you can't figure out if it will work or not.
Prove that this divided theory has been a global plan implement and not just so much wasted paper. It is just a thought exercise by a scholar. There is no global conspiracy. What is weighted is what is best for the people and the survival of a state(s) in the region.
Iran, Russia, ISIS, Kurds, Sunni, Shiite, etc., have all had their own reason to divide and conquer but Iraq is better served to bring all groups together and work for the country not their own smaller units. They need to look at the big picture not just three feet in front of themselves.
Find a new place to graze. A change in diet will be to your benefit. Trying to kick over every bucket you come near just leads to waste and does far more harm than good. Hate will lead to your early death. It will just eat away at you from the inside. Why do you want to hurt yourself and others with your venom? How will that solve anything? Hate will more likely bring about a disintegration of countries and collapse of governments, this idea of a divided Iraq, than anything else. Peace brings cooperation and benefit to the most people.
We need a wide range of ideas, a variety of studies, so that we can make informed decisions. It is better to think in many directions and dimensions, not be stuck with one. God (for those who believe) is supposed to have created man to think and make his own decision. We are not robots goosestepping in one direction. We need to imagine other possibilities and explore all the what ifs we can.
