Review of a purchase of a lawnmower from Tractor Supply

airplanemechanic

Diamond Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2014
Messages
22,646
Reaction score
19,106
Points
2,415
I had such a unique, and ultimately bad experience doing this, I wanted to share it with others.

I've been doing research for a long time about lawnmowers. I bought one when I bought this house in 2011 and still have that mower, but it's been giving me more and more issues. I finally decided to splurge and get a new one. Now, which one to get?

Well I was walking in Lowes with my dad buying some crap for something, and we wound up walking by a big ZTR inside the store (not out in the parking lot). I was shocked at the price, a 54" Toro Timecutter Max with 23hp Kawasaki engine, welded deck and 5 gallon fuel tank for $4099.00 I thought that was quite reasonable for such a large machine with the Kawasaki engine. So I began to research this machine, and compare it to others in the same size range. I quickly realized that this was the cheapest one, with others being MORE expensive and having a Kohler engine, not even the MUCH more desirable Kawasaki. The reviews were generally pretty good. Some things were really odd, like some people reporting that their machine ate the $130 deck belt on the first time using it. I figured that was simply an assembly defect and I could avoid that by simply checking the routing of the belt before I mow the first time. After a couple of months I go to the Lowes website and it was still there, same price. But when I googled it, I found it CHEAPER at Tractor Supply, and it was the "Havoc" edition. Got a little more bling-bling on it but the same machine. It was cheaper when you added the machine to the "cart" and checked off "pick up in store" it took $500 dollars off the price. I was like wow. Now this machine is $3699.

So I go back and forth on whether I should drop this much on a lawnmower and I finally bite the bullet and purchase it. I called the store immediately the next morning so they would know that I couldn't go pick it up. I am a truck driver, I'll be gone for weeks, just put it inside in the back and I'll grab it when I get in. He was very nice and accommodating and held it for me for almost 3 weeks. Nice guy when it came to that aspect.

However, I noticed that when I made the purchase, that the tax offset the "savings" of 500 dollars. I thought that sounded like way too much tax. I know the tax rate in my dads parish is 9%. But if you take 3699 x 1.09 you get a number quite a few dollars less than the 4095 I was charged at check out. I call TS customer service and they tell me tax is automatically calculated and it is what it is. I told them that they got it wrong, I paid tax on the FULL purchase price of the mower, not the reduced price. The manager told me to bring it to his attention when I picked it up. I did, showed him the math, he checked it over and refunded me over 70 dollars in cash that I overpaid in tax. He admitted I was absolutely right and he had no idea how they arrived at the massive amount of tax they were charging me on this purchase.

Fast forward to the actual pick up date. I give him a heads up that I'm coming, thinking that he'll use that time to make sure that the mower is 100% ready to go. Well, I arrive in my car before my father who brought his truck and trailer so we could get it to my house. When my dad arrives, the guy goes to start it, and it's dead. Battery is shot. Well he jumps it with a jumper box, and it starts but stops almost immediately. It's out of fuel. He puts JUST ENOUGH to get it out of the warehouse and onto my dads trailer. We finally get it home, and of course it's dead. I have to charge the battery of this BRAND NEW MACHINE for 10-15 minutes to start it to get it off of the trailer so my dad can leave. But of course I have to add gas too, as it ran out as we were maneuvering it for tiedown.

I decide to start checking things before the first mow. This guy had the battery hooked up wrong. It wasn't backwards, but how he had the connector ON the battery with the cable was the most whackadoodle thing I'd ever seen. You couldn't tighten the wingnut, you could wiggle the negative terminal. So I had to totally redo it, and I fixed it and put it right. Ok, that problem is solved.

I read the owners manual and they tell you how to level the deck properly. It should be 2 5/8" in front and 2 7/8" in the rear of the deck when the deck is set to the 3" setting on the deck height adjustment. I measure it, it's WAY off. It's 2.25 front and 2" rear. So I have to do this crazy method of leveling the deck and I finally get it right. Ok, next problem solved. All of this on a BRAND NEW machine.

While it was sitting at TS I asked the manager if it had a hitch. He said that model comes with one, and they put it on as a courtesy and even took a pic of it on there for me. Nice guy. Or so I thought. My machine now has a grand total of 1.4 hours and at 1.0 the hitch fell off, or almost completely fell off. Now the hardware that mounted it is gone and I'll have to find new hardware. I don't need the hitch but I would like to have the original hardware that held it on. Well that's now long gone.

I had read horror stories about buying machines from big box stores but I figured it couldn't be that bad. But even doing my due diligence I've still had more issues than I could have ever imagined with this purchase. But the mower mows really well, and is so much more powerful than my old riding lawnmower, even with only 1 more hp. That Kawasaki has twice the torque and YOU CAN FEEL IT. Since my yard this time of year is more dirt and dust than grass, I mow at a very low engine speed to try to keep the dust down.

Overall, I got the machine at a really good price and spent some of the savings on an upgrade for the intake over the stock paper filter, using a canister filter kit that fits the "fancier" engines but fits this one as well. If someone wants to buy a machine from a big box store, that's ok, you'll save a TON over a mom-and-pop lawnmower sales place, just be very careful and check it over VERY well before you begin mowing with your new machine.

You can see the upgraded canister air filter on top of the engine. It did not come with that.
 

Attachments

  • 20251205_120250.webp
    20251205_120250.webp
    397.2 KB · Views: 19
  • 1000015773.webp
    1000015773.webp
    258 KB · Views: 13
Last edited:
I had such a unique, and ultimately bad experience doing this, I wanted to share it with others.

I've been doing research for a long time about lawnmowers. I bought one when I bought this house in 2011 and still have that mower, but it's been giving me more and more issues. I finally decided to splurge and get a new one. Now, which one to get?

Well I was walking in Lowes with my dad buying some crap for something, and we wound up walking by a big ZTR inside the store (not out in the parking lot). I was shocked at the price, a 54" Toro Timecutter Max with 23hp Kawasaki engine, welded deck and 5 gallon fuel tank for $4099.00 I thought that was quite reasonable for such a large machine with the Kawasaki engine. So I began to research this machine, and compare it to others in the same size range. I quickly realized that this was the cheapest one, with others being MORE expensive and having a Kohler engine, not even the MUCH more desirable Kawasaki. The reviews were generally pretty good. Some things were really odd, like some people reporting that their machine ate the $130 deck belt on the first time using it. I figured that was simply an assembly defect and I could avoid that by simply checking the routing of the belt before I mow the first time. After a couple of months I go to the Lowes website and it was still there, same price. But when I googled it, I found it CHEAPER at Tractor Supply, and it was the "Havoc" edition. Got a little more bling-bling on it but the same machine. It was cheaper when you added the machine to the "cart" and checked off "pick up in store" it took $500 dollars off the price. I was like wow. Now this machine is $3699.

So I go back and forth on whether I should drop this much on a lawnmower and I finally bite the bullet and purchase it. I called the store immediately the next morning so they would know that I couldn't go pick it up. I am a truck driver, I'll be gone for weeks, just put it inside in the back and I'll grab it when I get in. He was very nice and accommodating and held it for me for almost 3 weeks. Nice guy when it came to that aspect.

However, I noticed that when I made the purchase, that the tax offset the "savings" of 500 dollars. I thought that sounded like way too much tax. I know the tax rate in my dads parish is 9%. But if you take 3699 x 1.09 you get a number quite a few dollars less than the 4095 I was charged at check out. I call TS customer service and they tell me tax is automatically calculated and it is what it is. I told them that they got it wrong, I paid tax on the FULL purchase price of the mower, not the reduced price. The manager told me to bring it to his attention when I picked it up. I did, showed him the math, he checked it over and refunded me over 70 dollars in cash that I overpaid in tax. He admitted I was absolutely right and he had no idea how they arrived at the massive amount of tax they were charging me on this purchase.

Fast forward to the actual pick up date. I give him a heads up that I'm coming, thinking that he'll use that time to make sure that the mower is 100% ready to go. Well, I arrive in my car before my father who brought his truck and trailer so we could get it to my house. When my dad arrives, the guy goes to start it, and it's dead. Battery is shot. Well he jumps it with a jumper box, and it starts but stops almost immediately. It's out of fuel. He puts JUST ENOUGH to get it out of the warehouse and onto my dads trailer. We finally get it home, and of course it's dead. I have to charge the battery of this BRAND NEW MACHINE for 10-15 minutes to start it to get it off of the trailer so my dad can leave. But of course I have to add gas too, as it ran out as we were maneuvering it for tiedown.

I decide to start checking things before the first mow. This guy had the battery hooked up wrong. It wasn't backwards, but how he had the connector ON the battery with the cable was the most whackadoodle thing I'd ever seen. You couldn't tighten the wingnut, you could wiggle the negative terminal. So I had to totally redo it, and I fixed it and put it right. Ok, that problem is solved.

I read the owners manual and they tell you how to level the deck properly. It should be 2 5/8" in front and 2 7/8" in the rear of the deck when the deck is set to the 3" setting on the deck height adjustment. I measure it, it's WAY off. It's 2.25 front and 2" rear. So I have to do this crazy method of leveling the deck and I finally get it right. Ok, next problem solved. All of this on a BRAND NEW machine.

While it was sitting at TS I asked the manager if it had a hitch. He said that model comes with one, and they put it on as a courtesy and even took a pic of it on there for me. Nice guy. Or so I thought. My machine now has a grand total of 1.4 hours and at 1.0 the hitch fell off, or almost completely fell off. Now the hardware that mounted it is gone and I'll have to find new hardware. I don't need the hitch but I would like to have the original hardware that held it on. Well that's now long gone.

I had read horror stories about buying machines from big box stores but I figured it couldn't be that bad. But even doing my due diligence I've still had more issues than I could have ever imagined with this purchase. But the mower mows really well, and is so much more powerful than my old riding lawnmower, even with only 1 more hp. That Kawasaki has twice the torque and YOU CAN FEEL IT. Since my yard this time of year is more dirt and dust than grass, I mow at a very low engine speed to try to keep the dust down.

Overall, I got the machine at a really good price and spent some of the savings on an upgrade for the intake, using a canister filter kit that fits the "fancier" engines but fits this one as well. If someone wants to buy a machine from a big box store, that's ok, you'll save a TON over a mom-and-pop lawnmower sales place, just be very careful and check it over VERY well before you begin mowing with your new machine.
I've dealt with the horror stories as well. LOL, I bought a JD lawn tractor with a 23? hp Kawasaki from Lowes and experienced some of the leveling probs you cite---and a JD mechanic was said to have set it up. I was replacing my 26hp Craftsman (Husqvarna) lawn tractor w/54" deck. Long story short. I sold my mower to my son in law and as luck would have it, he moved to a smaller lot and offered me first shot. I traded him straight across for the JD--he sold it for a profit and I have my original that I am more than happy with. As an aside, I experienced the same delivery nightmares from Sears as you did from Tractor Supply.
 
Lawn mower from Tractor Supply lasted one summer and it died . Pretty sure its the valves I haven't had a chance to take it a part.
 
I've dealt with the horror stories as well. LOL, I bought a JD lawn tractor with a 23? hp Kawasaki from Lowes and experienced some of the leveling probs you cite---and a JD mechanic was said to have set it up. I was replacing my 26hp Craftsman (Husqvarna) lawn tractor w/54" deck. Long story short. I sold my mower to my son in law and as luck would have it, he moved to a smaller lot and offered me first shot. I traded him straight across for the JD--he sold it for a profit and I have my original that I am more than happy with. As an aside, I experienced the same delivery nightmares from Sears as you did from Tractor Supply.

That's exactly what I am replacing, a 22hp Kohler Craftsman (Husqvarna) lawn tractor as well. Mine was 46".
 
That's exactly what I am replacing, a 22hp Kohler Craftsman (Husqvarna) lawn tractor as well. Mine was 46".
I bought mine twelve years ago and I mow about a half acre--also got the snow blower for it. After I got it set up from what the moron at Sears did to it and with the minor exception of how they set up the oil drain on the Kohler motor, I haven't got any complaints. I am completely satisfied.
 
I bought mine twelve years ago and I mow about a half acre--also got the snow blower for it. After I got it set up from what the moron at Sears did to it and with the minor exception of how they set up the oil drain on the Kohler motor, I haven't got any complaints. I am completely satisfied.

Yea, I've had nothing but issues with the Kohler engine. They've ALL been carb related. The original Walbro suddenly had the needle inside the float bowl BENT sideways, leak fuel into the engine while I was gone and hydro locked the engine. I had to pull the plug and turn it over and blow a bunch of fuel out the spark plug hole to get it started. I ran it like that for a while then replaced it with a Chinese carb. I ran that one for a while until suddenly the shut off solenoid caught on fire under the carb and almost burned the machine had the gas ignited. I replaced the carb AGAIN and now its so cold natured and will suddenly stop without warning. I used it today, it still runs. I just can't stand that Kohler engine.
 
Yeah....
You put it exactly right.

Zero turn Lawnmowers are complicated. A small shop is more likely to do the setup correctly EVERY time versus a big box store.
Sure, you saved a couple of hundred dollars....
BUT
If you calculate the hours you spent on the setup of your machine....@$100/hr....you barely broke even.
And if you didn't know how to do all that you did do to set it up.....you would have paid that rate to that same service shop to fix it all. (Some guys are not mechanically inclined. Not that it's a bad thing, they have different talents)

Zero turn mowers are awesome and can do a lawn 30-50% faster than a tractor mower.

The motor is never the thing that goes out. (So long as it has clean oil) it's always everything else: Spindles, pulleys, battery, alternators, starters, limit switches, tires, seat, armrests, cables, and transmissions.

I got a Hustler. Simple, stripped down Zero turn. Usually gives a loud, rough ride while mowing. But it's quick. I wish the frame had more give to it as I often find myself on three wheels and spinning the drive wheels in back too much. This causes me to chew up lawn or not turn like I wish to.
Oh well....
They really don't like for us to test drive/mower with these things before you buy them. Even if they are a large investment.
 
Lawn mower from Tractor Supply lasted one summer and it died . Pretty sure its the valves I haven't had a chance to take it a part.

Some of the junk they sell is just that. This mower is sold at commercial mowing places as a "heavy duty residential/light duty commercial" machine. Some mowing places have reviewed it and at the end they always plug their lawnmower business. If you go above this machine, you get into the true commercial stuff. And prices go way up really fast.
 
Some of the junk they sell is just that. This mower is sold at commercial mowing places as a "heavy duty residential/light duty commercial" machine. Some mowing places have reviewed it and at the end they always plug their lawnmower business. If you go above this machine, you get into the true commercial stuff. And prices go way up really fast.
I've heard that ZTR is the way to go and going by the number of commercial outfits that you see using both the sit down and stand up models, that is true. My lawn tractor fits my needs better though.
 
I've heard that ZTR is the way to go and going by the number of commercial outfits that you see using both the sit down and stand up models, that is true. My lawn tractor fits my needs better though.

Both have benefits and drawbacks. I have both. The trailer hitch on the ZTR (that fell off today) is too high to use to pull my lawn sweeper that I use to pick up lawn debris this time of year. So I have to continue to use my lawn tractor for that. Also, the lawn tractor would be better on slopes. It has "cruise control" as you know, where we can push our foot to a desired speed, pull up on the cruise lever, and maintain that without having to hold our foot down. ZTR's don't have that.

However, ZTR's will smoke a lawn tractor in mowing time. The maneuverability is unmatched. Once you mow with a ZTR you will wonder why you still have the lawn tractor. (except for me that needs both). It's also faster than a lawn tractor, so even just going straight you do better, much less in the turns. You can also see better when you mow as you don't have that big hood in your way. For me, I like the ZTR because the engine is sitting on the drive tires. I've stuck my lawn tractor many times, especially pulling a full lawn cart of wet leaves on wet ground trying to pick up my yard. The ZTR is a monster. If you stick that, it will take a small truck or tractor to get you out. It's like the old VW's, with the engine in the back. They could go anywhere.

My 46" at about 1/4 throttle and as fast as it will mow mowed my 1 acre lot in 1.5 hours. That's a lot of maneuvering around the numerous oak, pine and damn chicken trees I have. Not to mention flower beds, storage sheds and other crap. With my ZTR just a tick above idle (for dust reduction) I mowed the same area in .9 hours. My ZTR is 54".

For just mowing, ZTR's win hands down. But if you need more than that, lawn tractors could very well still hold a very important place in your yard repertoire.
 
Last edited:
I also usually have to change out blades once a year. (Too much sand and sticks I run over)
That's a PITA. They aren't expensive....and now easier that I got a chain fall to hoist up.the front.
I thought about getting a hitch so I can put a spreader behind me for pesticide and fertilizers. But dang they want too much money for them things. So I'll just use my broadcast spreader and walk it out. (Lots of walking but meh)

Leaves? Lawn sweeper is NOT going to cur it with my place (over an acre of large trees) backpack leaf blower and fire or bagging them up.

I hit a low stump with my mower....bent one of the rods for my deck level. That was a pain to fix. But...like I said before, I got a stripped, bare bones model so it wasn't much to figure out and fix.

My Father-in-law got a tank sprayer to run behind his for his farm. (Weed killer and etc). It works pretty well but I wasn't around to watch it....just seen where he got stuck in a ditch pulling the sprayer.
 
Who says America can avoid its asssumed plug hole destiny?

Always buy from China -- get some credits on your ID card

My salesmen told me my JD was made in America.

I did some work on it and read Made in China on the axle.

Paid $200 extra for a 23 HP KZ engine.
 
My salesmen told me my JD was made in America.

I did some work on it and read Made in China on the axle.

Paid $200 extra for a 23 HP KZ engine.

Great .
You have at least got some credit , come the day they effectively take over , using our lovely Moslem brothers as front line deflection .

P.S. , Watch out for Canadian Moslems .
Carney seems to be making the big switch and those dim witted forest dwellers could stab you where it hurts .
 
I thought about getting a hitch so I can put a spreader behind me for pesticide and fertilizers. But dang they want too much money for them things. So I'll just use my broadcast spreader and walk it out. (Lots of walking but meh)
I've got a tow behind broadcast spreader that I picked up for $100 new. Works pretty good. I also have a spray rig that I use --- they are worth every penny IMO.
 
Oh I forgot to say, the tires were supposed to have 13 rear, 30 front. They had 7 rear, and 2 or 3psi in the front. So the tires were flat, too.
 
15th post

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom