- Aug 27, 2008
- 18,450
- 1,823
- 205
Over the last 40 years, the U.S. government has relied on extreme fear-mongering to demonize transparency. In sum, every time an unwanted whistleblower steps forward, we are treated to the same messaging: Youre all going to die because of these leakers and the journalists who publish their disclosures! Lest you think thats hyperbole, consider this headline from last week based on an interview with outgoing NSA chief Keith Alexander:
The NSA engages in this fear-mongering not only publicly but also privately. As part of its efforts to persuade news organizations not to publish newsworthy stories from Snowden materials, its representatives constantly say the same thing: If you publish what were doing, it will endanger lives, including NSA personnel, by making people angry about what were doing in their countries and want to attack us.
But whenever it suits the agency to do someaning when it wants to propagandize on its own behalfthe NSA casually discloses even its most top secret activities in the very countries where such retaliation is most likely. Anonymous ex-officials boasted to the Washington Post last July in detail about the role the agency plays in helping kill people by drones. The Post dutifully headlined its story: NSA Growth Fueled by Need to Target Terrorists.
NSA Blows Its Own Top Secret Program in Order to Propagandize
This just goes to show that there is no principled position against leaking from the administration, only opposition to those leaks which serve to make them look bad.
Greenwald concludes:
But because the purpose was to serve the NSAs interests and to propagandize the public, none of the people who pretend to object to leakswhen they shine light on the bad acts of the most powerful officialswill utter a peep of protest. Thats because, as always, secrecy designations and condemnations of leaks are about shielding those officials from scrutiny and embarrassment, not any legitimate considerations of national security or any of the other ostensible purposes.