Good for Philadelphia!

Astrostar

Diamond Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2017
Messages
3,395
Reaction score
5,215
Points
1,940
Well, good luck with that, comrade.

Federal offices carrying out their duties cannot be charged by states or their political subdivisions.

Supremacy Clause immunity (originating from In re Neagle, 1890), which shields federal agents from state criminal prosecution.
 
Well, good luck with that, comrade.

Federal offices carrying out their duties cannot be charged by states or their political subdivisions.
Nope, you are wrong. If a federal agent is a drunk driver, or rapes someone or any number of crimes he can be arrested. Do you actually think a federal agent that's beating up a child in the street is immune to arrest?

If you do you are a monster, because nobody should condone such a system.

No one is above the law, that's what laws are, that's why we have them.
Supremacy Clause immunity (originating from In re Neagle, 1890), which shields federal agents from state criminal prosecution.
 
Well, good luck with that, comrade.

Federal offices carrying out their duties cannot be charged by states or their political subdivisions.

Supremacy Clause immunity (originating from In re Neagle, 1890), which shields federal agents from state criminal prosecution.

Isn't it awesome when the lunatic leftoids lose it and show the rest of the world exactly how ignorant, stupid, and moronic they really are?
 
Nope, you are wrong. If a federal agent is a drunk driver, or rapes someone or any number of crimes he can be arrested. Do you actually think a federal agent that's beating up a child in the street is immune to arrest?

If you do you are a monster, because nobody should condone such a system.

No one is above the law, that's what laws are, that's why we have them.


Maybe you need to learn how to read English?

I posted this:

Federal officers carrying out their duties cannot be charged by states or their political subdivisions.

Supremacy Clause immunity (originating from In re Neagle, 1890), which shields federal agents from state criminal prosecution.
 

Don't you wish that every American city that Trump sends his ICE goons to has a strong backbone like Philadelphia. Great to see cities resist the Trump fascist Gestapo tactics.

Bigly!!!
<~~~~~~~~~~>​
Message to the ignorant...
This principle is established by the Supremacy Clause in Article VI, Clause 2 of the U.S. Constitution, which declares that the Constitution, federal laws, and treaties are the "supreme Law of the Land".
The Doctrine of Federal Preemption
When a state or local law conflicts with a federal law, the federal law prevails, and the lower-level law is deemed "preempted" or void.
Express Preemption: Congress explicitly states in a statute that it intends to override state or local laws.
Implied Preemption: Courts determine that Congress intended to take over a specific field (field preemption) or that the state law makes it impossible to comply with federal law (conflict preemption).
A similar dynamic exists at the state level: state law generally overcomes municipal (city or county) ordinances because local governments are "creatures of the state" and derive their authority from state constitutions or legislatures.
Federal officer carrying out lawful Federal laws/orders are exempt from State and Municipal statutes/laws.
So if the District Attorney for Philadelphia is making that statement. He'd better check with the Federal gov't.
He's blowing smoke and you're ignorant enough to believe him...
 

Don't you wish that every American city that Trump sends his ICE goons to has a strong backbone like Philadelphia. Great to see cities resist the Trump fascist Gestapo tactics.

Bigly!!!
Larry Krasner is a Communist.
He's bought and paid for by George Soros.
He refuses to prosecute criminals while making idiotic ******* statements like this one.
He is a loathsome creature who doesn't give a shit about protecting Philadelphians. He wants chaos and crime and violence because it furthers the causes that his god, George Soros, adores in pursuit of the destruction of the United States.
 

Don't you wish that every American city that Trump sends his ICE goons to has a strong backbone like Philadelphia. Great to see cities resist the Trump fascist Gestapo tactics.

Bigly!!!
I mean, when the Federal government rightfully ignores this, what're you gonna do? Perform a citizen's arrest?
 
Right so it all depends on the interpterion don't it dumbo.

"I'm arresting you for intoxication and running over to people".

"No you ain't officer, I was just carrying out my duty".

You jackass.
Hey, low-IQ Moonbat, intoxication and running over to people are not duties of a federal agent.
 
<~~~~~~~~~~>​
Message to the ignorant...
This principle is established by the Supremacy Clause in Article VI, Clause 2 of the U.S. Constitution, which declares that the Constitution, federal laws, and treaties are the "supreme Law of the Land".
The Doctrine of Federal Preemption
When a state or local law conflicts with a federal law, the federal law prevails, and the lower-level law is deemed "preempted" or void.
Express Preemption: Congress explicitly states in a statute that it intends to override state or local laws.
Implied Preemption: Courts determine that Congress intended to take over a specific field (field preemption) or that the state law makes it impossible to comply with federal law (conflict preemption).
A similar dynamic exists at the state level: state law generally overcomes municipal (city or county) ordinances because local governments are "creatures of the state" and derive their authority from state constitutions or legislatures.
Federal officer carrying out lawful Federal laws/orders are exempt from State and Municipal statutes/laws.
So if the District Attorney for Philadelphia is making that statement. He'd better check with the Federal gov't.
He's blowing smoke and you're ignorant enough to believe him...
What happens when a federal agent breaks a state law?

Then they're guilty of breaking the state law.

One thing is them carrying out duties under their federal duties. Another is them doing things that are not part of their federal duties, like shooting people for no good reason.
 
What happens when a federal agent breaks a state law?

Then they're guilty of breaking the state law.

One thing is them carrying out duties under their federal duties. Another is them doing things that are not part of their federal duties, like shooting people for no good reason.
Get real. Both sides play this game.

Illegal alien truck driver killed citizen. Newsom blames federal government for immigration law. Feds move in, Newsom said it’s a state jurisdiction to prosecute.
 
Get real. Both sides play this game.

Illegal alien truck driver killed citizen. Newsom blames federal government for immigration law. Feds move in, Newsom said it’s a state jurisdiction to prosecute.

Yeah, they do. US politics is absurd. Time for Proportional Representation or this insanity is just going to continue.
 

Don't you wish that every American city that Trump sends his ICE goons to has a strong backbone like Philadelphia. Great to see cities resist the Trump fascist Gestapo tactics.

Bigly!!!

If any of them are committing crimes, I agree, having said that, their dockets are going to be pretty thin I think
 
Nope, you are wrong. If a federal agent is a drunk driver, or rapes someone or any number of crimes he can be arrested. Do you actually think a federal agent that's beating up a child in the street is immune to arrest?

If you do you are a monster, because nobody should condone such a system.

No one is above the law, that's what laws are, that's why we have them.

..”official duties…”
 
15th post
Yeah, they do. US politics is absurd. Time for Proportional Representation or this insanity is just going to continue.

The only way you’re getting that is with a constitutional amendment.
 
Back
Top Bottom