Okay, this is worrisome:
Here’s a breakdown to clarify what’s happening and its potential implications:
What is RFK Jr. doing now?
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., an outspoken critic of vaccines, is associated with efforts to challenge vaccine approvals in the U.S. His lawyer, Aaron Siri, filed a petition to the FDA on behalf of the Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN) to request the revocation of FDA approval for the polio vaccine.
This petition is part of a broader campaign by vaccine-skeptical groups that often call for more stringent testing of vaccines, claiming safety concerns. RFK Jr.'s public advocacy often focuses on challenging vaccine policies and mandates, emphasizing perceived risks despite overwhelming scientific evidence of vaccines' safety and effectiveness.
What authority does RFK Jr. (or others) have to petition the FDA?
Anyone—whether an individual, organization, or group—can file a "Citizen Petition" with the FDA. This process allows the public to formally request the agency to issue, change, or revoke a regulation or take a specific administrative action.
The FDA is required to respond, but filing a petition does not mean the FDA will act on it. The agency typically evaluates such petitions based on scientific evidence, public health needs, and legal considerations.
In this case, RFK Jr.'s lawyer is exercising this legal right to challenge the polio vaccine's approval. The petition argues for safety reassessment, often framing it as a need for more rigorous studies.
What does "get rid of the polio vaccine" mean?
"Getting rid of" the vaccine, in this context, refers to the petition's request for the FDA to revoke its approval. If the FDA were to revoke the polio vaccine's approval:
- It would no longer be available for administration in the U.S.
- Doctors would be prohibited from prescribing or administering the vaccine.
- The vaccine's removal would effectively eliminate it as a tool for preventing polio.
This doesn’t mean destroying existing supplies—it means removing the vaccine from the approved list, effectively halting its use.
What would be the real-life implications for Americans if the polio vaccine were revoked?
- Increased Risk of Polio Resurgence:
- Polio is a highly contagious viral disease that can cause paralysis and death. Widespread vaccination has virtually eradicated polio in the U.S., but the virus still circulates in parts of the world.
- Without the vaccine, there’s a significant risk that polio could reemerge, especially through international travel or contact with asymptomatic carriers in under-vaccinated communities.
- Public Health Crisis:
- Loss of herd immunity would expose millions of unvaccinated or under-vaccinated individuals, particularly children, to potential outbreaks.
- Historical data shows that before the polio vaccine, the U.S. experienced tens of thousands of polio cases annually, leading to widespread paralysis and death.
- Global Ramifications:
- The U.S. has been a leader in global vaccination campaigns. Revoking approval for the polio vaccine could undermine international confidence in vaccines and fuel anti-vaccine movements worldwide.
- Erosion of Public Trust in Vaccines:
- Revocation of such a critical vaccine could lead to increased skepticism about other vaccines, potentially leading to outbreaks of other preventable diseases (e.g., measles, mumps, rubella).
Will this petition succeed?
It’s highly unlikely. The polio vaccine is one of the most rigorously studied and successful medical interventions in history. Scientific consensus overwhelmingly supports its safety and effectiveness.
The FDA would need compelling, credible evidence of significant safety concerns to consider revoking approval. Currently, there’s no such evidence.
In Summary:
RFK Jr., through his lawyer, has filed a petition challenging the FDA’s approval of the polio vaccine. While this is a legal right, it doesn’t mean the vaccine will be “gotten rid of.” If such an action were taken (which is extremely unlikely), the consequences could be catastrophic for public health, with the risk of polio outbreaks and erosion of confidence in life-saving vaccines.