Why are the Pashtuns allowed to dominate Afghanistan?

[surada]

surada OBVIOUSLY their culture is shit--UNDENIABLE except to a cultist/insane person .....

surada OBVIOUSLY their culture is shit--UNDENIABLE except to a cultist/insane person .....

Those who are insane rejected the offer to have OBL turned over... and spent 20 years trying to reinvent a country that was never a country. Insanity is fighting mountain people on their own turf or trying to make them over to be like America.

 

[rupol2000]

Beats me. It wasn't Tennessee, I'll tell you that much.

it was the northern half of the so-called "Afghanistan"

 

[harmonica]

surada hahahhahaha...their country has been in turmoil for decades = they can't get their shit together

 

[White 6]

it was the northern half of the so-called "Afghanistan"

So? I am supposed to care, why? Where are you from, that you should have any sway on the direction of that ancient country?

 

[surada]

surada hahahhahaha...their country has been in turmoil for decades = they can't get their shit together

Yes, since 1974. I told you they overthrew the Monarchy. Afghanistan was never actually a nation.. It was made up of tribes and clans.

 

[rupol2000]

So?

This is the best solution for solving the Afghan issue, overcoming extremism. They will draw a clear line between Pashtuns and Turkestanis and the issue is settled. Further attempts at terrorism in the north will be seen as an attack on the country.

 

[harmonica]

surada 3 head of state murders in less than 2 years--this has to do with loooong BEFORE 1974

 

[harmonica]

surada the culture is there long before 1974

 

[surada]

surada the culture is there long before 1974

Well yeah.. They defeated the Russians twice, the British and even Alexander the Great.. .. so who is stupid?

 

[rupol2000]

From the point of view of morality, this is also the best solution, because in fact it is a totalitarian occupation regime that infringes upon the rights of national minorities and engages in crimes against them, including genocide.

 

[harmonica]

surada yes, tribes and clans fighting/etc

 

[harmonica]

Well yeah.. They defeated the Russians twice, the British and even Alexander the Great.. .. so who is stupid?

hahhahahahahhaah----not really defeated----unwinnable like Vietnam ...and we gave them high tech weapons

 

[harmonica]

Well yeah.. They defeated the Russians twice, the British and even Alexander the Great.. .. so who is stupid?

....you are a shallow thinker .....they have all these countries go into their country and ran all over the place.....bombing/killing/destroying---and you say THEY are smarter????!!!
HAHAHAHHAHAHAHA
...smart is going into ANOTHER country --not letting YOUR country be fkd up = shithole

 

[surada]

hahhahahahahhaah----not really defeated----unwinnable like Vietnam ...and we gave them high tech weapons

You can beat mountain people. Same with Yemen.

 

[rupol2000]

Well yeah.. They defeated the Russians twice, the British and even Alexander the Great.. .. so who is stupid?

hahhahahahahhaah----not really defeated----unwinnable like Vietnam ...and we gave them high tech weapons

How do I understand the speech about Turkestan, and the Hazaras? Here, first of all, we must remember how Genghis Khan destroyed the Arab Caliphate. The Parthians were from about where they destroyed the Roman Empire. Prior to that, the Macedonian empire of the Seleucids was raked from there. There is no doubt that the greatest warriors of all time lived there.

 

[harmonica]

surada yes unwinnable--like Vietnam --I've got a thread on it ......
..but we did go in and kill a bunch of the bad guys and their leader

 

[harmonica]

rupol2000 ; lived where?? the US defeated Japan and Germany--at the same time ......there are great warriors in a lot of militaries.....but, Afghanistan can't get their shit together

 

[rupol2000]

lived where??

In this case, we mean the region of South Turkestan, modern Uyguristan and northern Afghanistan.
In general, one can take wider, Indo-Aryans and Huns from Altai to India and from Don to Baikal

the US defeated Japan and Germany--at the same time ......there are great warriors in a lot of militaries.....but, Afghanistan can't get their shit together

But this is not quite the same, these are massive modern wars, where the role of the warrior's skill is not the same as that of the ancient chariots and horsemen of the east.
They crushed huge imperial infantry by military skill, they were real heroes.

 

[harmonica]

rupol2000 if they were great warriors they would not have let those armies into their country in the first place

 

[rupol2000]

rupol2000 if they were great warriors they would not have let those armies into their country in the first place

It's not just skill and spirit that decides, but money, politics and numbers.
All the great cavalry armies were defeated all over the world, when there was a massive conquest of muskets, commoners were armed with them, and even children, and they won everyone.