What Question Would T.J. Ask The Hollywood 10?

Flanders

ARCHCONSERVATIVE
Sep 23, 2010
7,628
748
205
A better question is: How would T.J. put this in the form of a question:

To compel a man to furnish funds for the propagation of ideas he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical. Thomas Jefferson

Trumbo is scheduled for release in early November.


I doubt if anybody born after 1980 will be interested in the plot. Younger Americans who might be interested in the plot consist of idiot liberals who think they sound politically astute when they talk about the Hollywood Blacklist ā€”ā€” without knowing what it was all about.

Bryan Cranston Goes From Drug Lord to Communist in Blacklist Saga 'Trumbo': "A Socialist, But He Loved Being Rich"
By Gary Baum

Bryan Cranston Plays Communist in 'Trumbo': "A Socialist, But He Loved Being Rich"

Us old folks remember the early days of television when HUAC hearings was big news; possibly the first big media story ever televised because so many movie stars testified:



I will checkout Trumbo after it shows up on TV, but I cannot promise to watch the entire movie. Iā€™m outta there as soon as I smell the same old Hollywood liberal rant.

Iā€™m betting that Trumbo will not go to the heart the matter:

Did Communists have the right to dictate the use of private property they did not own?

That question was never asked because media Communists helped Hollywood Lefties turn it into a Fifth Amendment issue.


During the investigative hearings, members of HUAC grilled the witnesses about their past and present associations with the Communist Party. Aware that their answers could ruin their reputations and careers, most individuals either sought leniency by cooperating with investigators or cited their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. However, a group of 10 Hollywood screenwriters and directors took a different approach and openly challenged the legitimacy of the committeeā€™s investigations.

XXXXX

The Hollywood Ten were controversial figures at the time they launched their protest, and their actions continue to inspire debate decades later. Some tend to view their punishment as justified, since the individuals were admitted communists, while others generally view them as heroic figures who spoke out against the abuses of the Red Scareā€“and in defense of the U.S. Constitutionā€“when many of their colleagues remained silent.


To this day you will be hard-pressed finding Americans who know that the Hollywood Ten were defending Communism. Most Americans believe the lie Hollywood Lefties have been telling for more than 60 years: The Hollywood Ten were defending the Constitution for all of us.

The so-called Hollywood Blacklist was nothing more than property owners defending their Right to refuse to hire employees who decided the work they would do. (Imagine a plumber you hire to fix a leak telling you: I am going to paint your front door and you still have to pay me.)

Every employer in the world ā€”ā€” except movie studios ā€”ā€” had that Right to hire and fire. The crap Hollywood produces with tax breaks, subsidies, propaganda inserted in movies paid for by the United Nations, and so on since the death of the studio system opened the door to every employer losing their most important Right. Thankfully, crap has been reducing the movie industry to a shrinking subculture in the years since HUAC.

Put aside liberals milking a lie for decades, and you will see that nothing stopped Hollywood Lefties from saying everything they wanted to say on their own dime. They did not have the Right to force someone else to pay them for saying it.
 
UPDATE

I hope Pat Buchananā€™s informative piece will attract a few young Americans to the truth, or at least prepare them for what they will get from Hollywood:

Why is Hollywood making a movie about Trumbo?

To whitewash the traitor and his comrades who were blacklisted for refusing to testify to the House Un-American Activities Committee about their Communist Party membership and affiliations.

In promoting ā€œTrumbo,ā€ Hollywoodā€™s flacks write of the late 1940s as the ā€œdarkest daysā€ in American history.

They were dark all right. But probably less dark for Tinseltown Bolsheviks than the hundreds of millions who fell under the rule of the revolutions and regimes they supported in those years.

Dalton Trumbo Had It Coming
Patrick J. Buchanan | Friday Nov 6, 2015 12:01 AM

Dalton Trumbo Had It Coming | Human Events
 
Did Communists have the right to dictate the use of private property they did not own?

That question was never asked because media Communists helped Hollywood Lefties turn it into a Fifth Amendment issue.
Put aside liberals milking a lie for decades,
I just noticed that Trumbo did not win best picture award. I guess the lie was dispelled so often Hollywood Lefties were afraid to give one of their skeletons a major award.
 
A better question is: How would T.J. put this in the form of a question:

To compel a man to furnish funds for the propagation of ideas he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical. Thomas Jefferson

Trumbo is scheduled for release in early November.


I doubt if anybody born after 1980 will be interested in the plot. Younger Americans who might be interested in the plot consist of idiot liberals who think they sound politically astute when they talk about the Hollywood Blacklist ā€”ā€” without knowing what it was all about.

Bryan Cranston Goes From Drug Lord to Communist in Blacklist Saga 'Trumbo': "A Socialist, But He Loved Being Rich"
By Gary Baum

Bryan Cranston Plays Communist in 'Trumbo': "A Socialist, But He Loved Being Rich"

Us old folks remember the early days of television when HUAC hearings was big news; possibly the first big media story ever televised because so many movie stars testified:



I will checkout Trumbo after it shows up on TV, but I cannot promise to watch the entire movie. Iā€™m outta there as soon as I smell the same old Hollywood liberal rant.

Iā€™m betting that Trumbo will not go to the heart the matter:

Did Communists have the right to dictate the use of private property they did not own?

That question was never asked because media Communists helped Hollywood Lefties turn it into a Fifth Amendment issue.


During the investigative hearings, members of HUAC grilled the witnesses about their past and present associations with the Communist Party. Aware that their answers could ruin their reputations and careers, most individuals either sought leniency by cooperating with investigators or cited their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. However, a group of 10 Hollywood screenwriters and directors took a different approach and openly challenged the legitimacy of the committeeā€™s investigations.

XXXXX

The Hollywood Ten were controversial figures at the time they launched their protest, and their actions continue to inspire debate decades later. Some tend to view their punishment as justified, since the individuals were admitted communists, while others generally view them as heroic figures who spoke out against the abuses of the Red Scareā€“and in defense of the U.S. Constitutionā€“when many of their colleagues remained silent.


To this day you will be hard-pressed finding Americans who know that the Hollywood Ten were defending Communism. Most Americans believe the lie Hollywood Lefties have been telling for more than 60 years: The Hollywood Ten were defending the Constitution for all of us.

The so-called Hollywood Blacklist was nothing more than property owners defending their Right to refuse to hire employees who decided the work they would do. (Imagine a plumber you hire to fix a leak telling you: I am going to paint your front door and you still have to pay me.)

Every employer in the world ā€”ā€” except movie studios ā€”ā€” had that Right to hire and fire. The crap Hollywood produces with tax breaks, subsidies, propaganda inserted in movies paid for by the United Nations, and so on since the death of the studio system opened the door to every employer losing their most important Right. Thankfully, crap has been reducing the movie industry to a shrinking subculture in the years since HUAC.

Put aside liberals milking a lie for decades, and you will see that nothing stopped Hollywood Lefties from saying everything they wanted to say on their own dime. They did not have the Right to force someone else to pay them for saying it.



They were defending stalin's communism.......over 25 million murdered men, women and children...and they were actively conspiring to bring about the end of the country....

The hollywood 10 were vile morons.........too bad hollywood won't make an accurate movie about who they were and what they did....
 

Forum List

Back
Top