Zone1 I kid you not Left wing and far Right

[Captain Caveman]

When I absorb information, I kinda get niggly feelings inside. I like psychology and get quite in-depth from the normal path when I'm bugged.

One such thing was the orientation of the left. So I did a little researching -

Study: Left-wing authoritarians share key psychological traits with far right

People with extreme political views that favor authoritarianism—whether they are on the far left or the far right—have surprisingly similar behaviors and psychological characteristics, a new study finds.

phys.org

Now, I always thought Republicans were not Far Right, but Democrats kinda ring alarm bells.

Your thoughts on the link?

 

[TNHarley]

Far right people dont favor authoritarianism. Far left is totalitarianism. Far right is anarchy.
Im one of the farthest right people on this board and you never see me supporting authoritarianism or govt intervention.

 

[d0gbreath]

Far right people dont favor authoritarianism. Far left is totalitarianism. Far right is anarchy.
Im one of the farthest right people on this board and you never see me supporting authoritarianism or govt intervention.

I'm an anarchist, and farther left than the communists. I can see it being far right, it simply means no leaders, on any level. Ever.

 

[MisterBeale]

When I absorb information, I kinda get niggly feelings inside. I like psychology and get quite in-depth from the normal path when I'm bugged.

One such thing was the orientation of the left. So I did a little researching -

Study: Left-wing authoritarians share key psychological traits with far right

People with extreme political views that favor authoritarianism—whether they are on the far left or the far right—have surprisingly similar behaviors and psychological characteristics, a new study finds.

phys.org

Now, I always thought Republicans were not Far Right, but Democrats kinda ring alarm bells.

Your thoughts on the link?

As you can see from the few comments in the thread so far. . . we need to be able to read the study, and see how the authors defined their terms.

The members in this thread seem to take exception to the authors definitions and points of view, of the political spectrum, but we can't really know for sure, the exact definitions they are using, because they want us to pay. . .

APA PsycNet

psycnet.apa.org

Fruitless discussion IMO.

Right-wing authoritarianism - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

(I find it telling, the wiki has no stub for "left-wing authoritarianism" )

The Authoritarian Personality - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[Dont Taz Me Bro]

Far right people dont favor authoritarianism.

They absolutely do

 

[BackAgain]

Far right people dont favor authoritarianism. Far left is totalitarianism. Far right is anarchy.
Im one of the farthest right people on this board and you never see me supporting authoritarianism or govt intervention.

I’m not convinced that far right truly correlates with anarchy.

I have very little doubt that far left does come down on the spade of totalitarianism.

 

[MisterBeale]

I’m not convinced that far right truly correlates with anarchy.

Really, he is not too far off the mark.

Lysander Spooner is generally regarded as far right, and he published in what is regarded as America's first Anarchist periodical. . . started by Benjamin Tucker.

He was friends, I believe, with Josiah Warren. Both were at the first Internationale. I have no proof they traveled there together, but I suspect that they did.

Benjamin Tucker's Liberty

I was the first American—I may say the first Anglo-Saxon—to start an avowedly Anarchistic newspaper printed in the English language....

reason.com

"I was the first American—I may say the first Anglo-Saxon—to start an avowedly Anarchistic newspaper printed in the English language. I am still the editor, publisher and proprietor of that paper. It is everywhere regarded as the pioneer and principal organ of modem individualist Anarchism. I either am, or have been, the publisher of the chief Anarchistic works in the English language. I am the author of the most widely-accepted English text-book of Anarchism. I have enjoyed the friendship, had the benefit of instruction, and have carefully studied the works, of those Americans from whom the Anarchists have largely derived their beliefs—Josiah Warren, Stephen Pearl Andrews, Lysander Spooner, and Colonel William B. Greene. I am the translator into English of some of the principal works of P.J. Proudhon, who was the first writer in any language to declare himself an Anarchist. I am acquainted, perhaps better than any other man, with the English-speaking Anarchists of the United States. . . "

Lysander Spooner - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Josiah Warren - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[MisterBeale]

They absolutely do

It really, as I posted previously, depends on one's definition of "far right."

 

[Harpy Eagle]

Far right people dont favor authoritarianism. Far left is totalitarianism. Far right is anarchy.
Im one of the farthest right people on this board and you never see me supporting authoritarianism or govt intervention.

 

[BackAgain]

Really, he is not too far off the mark.

Lysander Spooner is generally regarded as far right, and he published in what is regarded as America's first Anarchist periodical. . . started by Benjamin Tucker.

He was friends, I believe, with Josiah Warren. Both were at the first Internationale. I have no proof they traveled there together, but I suspect that they did.

Benjamin Tucker's Liberty

I was the first American—I may say the first Anglo-Saxon—to start an avowedly Anarchistic newspaper printed in the English language....

reason.com

"I was the first American—I may say the first Anglo-Saxon—to start an avowedly Anarchistic newspaper printed in the English language. I am still the editor, publisher and proprietor of that paper. It is everywhere regarded as the pioneer and principal organ of modem individualist Anarchism. I either am, or have been, the publisher of the chief Anarchistic works in the English language. I am the author of the most widely-accepted English text-book of Anarchism. I have enjoyed the friendship, had the benefit of instruction, and have carefully studied the works, of those Americans from whom the Anarchists have largely derived their beliefs—Josiah Warren, Stephen Pearl Andrews, Lysander Spooner, and Colonel William B. Greene. I am the translator into English of some of the principal works of P.J. Proudhon, who was the first writer in any language to declare himself an Anarchist. I am acquainted, perhaps better than any other man, with the English-speaking Anarchists of the United States. . . "

Lysander Spooner - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Josiah Warren - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Understand. I also see that there is a strain or variety of light libertarianism which is aligned with anarch-concepulaizations.

Nonetheless, my view remains. Dealing with our Framers, they don’t seek an anarchical society. In fact, despite their justified reservations about all governments, when they crafted our Constitutional republic on a firm foundation of checks and balances, they were not seeking government incapable of doing the very things for which we even have governments.

Accordingly, I maintain that there is a delicate balance between agreeing to create a government capable of doing the very things we call on governments to perform while at the same time seeking to limiting and prevent it from assuming too much power or power to do things we haven’t agreed it should do.

 

[MisterBeale]

View attachment 936305

Horseshoe theory - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[MisterBeale]

Dealing with our Framers, they don’t seek an anarchical society.

Of course they didn't seek that, but they recognized the truth of what Aristotle wrote about.

Corruption in either direction, leads to extremes.

You can be sure, they were all familiar with their ancient Greek.

Aristotle’s Political Theory (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

 

[Dadoalex]

When I absorb information, I kinda get niggly feelings inside. I like psychology and get quite in-depth from the normal path when I'm bugged.

One such thing was the orientation of the left. So I did a little researching -

Study: Left-wing authoritarians share key psychological traits with far right

People with extreme political views that favor authoritarianism—whether they are on the far left or the far right—have surprisingly similar behaviors and psychological characteristics, a new study finds.

phys.org

Now, I always thought Republicans were not Far Right, but Democrats kinda ring alarm bells.

Your thoughts on the link?

People consider ideologies as

In reality Ideologies are more like

 

[MisterBeale]

People consider ideologies as

View attachment 936339

In reality Ideologies are more like

View attachment 936341

From my PoV?

It is more like this . . .

 

[Harpy Eagle]

Horseshoe theory - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

great quote from your link, thanks...


"The [horseshoe] theory is typically used to explain why 20th century communists and fascists seemed to have so much in common, though it likely predates the last century. But in the United States in 2021, a softer version of this iron law is at play, with the center-left and the center-right mushily converging toward expensive authoritarian policies that look astonishingly similar despite their supposedly opposite goals. Still a horseshoe, but more like one of the marshmallow ones you can find in bowls of Lucky Charms."

 

[yidnar]

They absolutely do

the majority of the maga party are nothing more than the latest version of the Tea party ... we don't want overreaching government ... for instance current our candidate is a victim of said overreaching gov ..

 

[BackAgain]

Of course they didn't seek that, but they recognized the truth of what Aristotle wrote about.

Corruption in either direction, leads to extremes.

You can be sure, they were all familiar with their ancient Greek.

Aristotle’s Political Theory (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

View attachment 936334

I agree that they were every well read learned men.

 

[MarcATL]

Far right people dont favor authoritarianism. Far left is totalitarianism. Far right is anarchy.
Im one of the farthest right people on this board and you never see me supporting authoritarianism or govt intervention.

 

[MisterBeale]

great quote from your link, thanks...


"The [horseshoe] theory is typically used to explain why 20th century communists and fascists seemed to have so much in common, though it likely predates the last century. But in the United States in 2021, a softer version of this iron law is at play, with the center-left and the center-right mushily converging toward expensive authoritarian policies that look astonishingly similar despite their supposedly opposite goals. Still a horseshoe, but more like one of the marshmallow ones you can find in bowls of Lucky Charms."

That isn't that part I linked. . . Real political scientists? Regard it as major WOO.

"The horseshoe theory does not enjoy wide support within academic circles; peer-reviewed research by political scientists on the subject is scarce, and existing studies and comprehensive reviews have often contradicted its central premises, or found only limited support for the theory under certain conditions.[6][8]"

 

[Dadoalex]

From my PoV?

It is more like this . . .

Lots of gibberish words but you have "liberty" and and "hive mind" in the same quadrant so...