John Edgar Slow Horses
Diamond Member
- Apr 11, 2023
- 53,995
- 25,132
- 2,488
- Banned
- #1
Though not a Christian or Jew or Moslem of any 'suasion, I think the line is eternally correct and always have followed it.
Simple example. LeoXIV has another calling that supersedes American citizen.
I had a Brigade commander ask me in a closed-door disciplinary meeting why I would not do what the JAG of 1st Cavalry Division wanted. I told the Colonel that the Battalion Commander wanted to do matters differently than counseled by the JAG advisory lawyer seconded to the Battalion. The Colonel then asked, "Why?
I told him, "I cannot serve two masters. My orders assign me to his Battalion. I support the Battalion Commander."
The issue itself was not a matter of right or wrong, but the conflict of who to obey was ethical.
The Colonel refused to continue my case and discharged it, thank heavens. If he had relieved the Battalion commander of the case and ordered me to prepare charges under the Brigade command, I would have done so.
I was lucky. The JAG later became the Judge Advocate General of the U. S. Army, and I gather he served with distinction, including with terrorists and their Gitmo charges.
Simple example. LeoXIV has another calling that supersedes American citizen.
I had a Brigade commander ask me in a closed-door disciplinary meeting why I would not do what the JAG of 1st Cavalry Division wanted. I told the Colonel that the Battalion Commander wanted to do matters differently than counseled by the JAG advisory lawyer seconded to the Battalion. The Colonel then asked, "Why?
I told him, "I cannot serve two masters. My orders assign me to his Battalion. I support the Battalion Commander."
The issue itself was not a matter of right or wrong, but the conflict of who to obey was ethical.
The Colonel refused to continue my case and discharged it, thank heavens. If he had relieved the Battalion commander of the case and ordered me to prepare charges under the Brigade command, I would have done so.
I was lucky. The JAG later became the Judge Advocate General of the U. S. Army, and I gather he served with distinction, including with terrorists and their Gitmo charges.
Military Ethic and the Judge Advocate General’s Corps: Legal Guardians of the Profession of Arms www.ausa.org/publications/military-ethic-and-judge-advocate-generals-corps-legal-guardians-profession-arms#:~:text=The%20JAG%20Corps%20has%20a%20particular%20interest%20and,of%20subordinates%2C%20adultery%20and%20a%20plethora%20of%20others.
Last edited: