UNHRC's longtimer biased Navi Pillay' and her "independent commission": a classic oxymoron

Sayaras

Platinum Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2023
Messages
5,970
Reaction score
3,667
Points
938
The so-called "independent" Pillay Commission *genocide" completely debunked is a complete oxymoron, especially given the long-standing anti-Israel bias of its chair, Navi Pillay. Her previous track record, including her actions as head of the 2021 Commission, shows a consistent pattern of skewed narratives that serve political agendas rather than objective fact-finding. It's no surprise that she would align herself with figures like Francesca Albanese, notorious for spreading baseless "genocide" accusations against Israel since 2014—well before she was unjustly given a UN position. This entire Commission's supposed neutrality is nothing more than a facade, built on a foundation of pre-existing anti-Israel rhetoric.

See Navi Pillay record Navi Pillay Archives - UN Watch
 
The so-called "independent" Pillay Commission *genocide" completely debunked is a complete oxymoron, especially given the long-standing anti-Israel bias of its chair, Navi Pillay. Her previous track record, including her actions as head of the 2021 Commission, shows a consistent pattern of skewed narratives that serve political agendas rather than objective fact-finding. It's no surprise that she would align herself with figures like Francesca Albanese, notorious for spreading baseless "genocide" accusations against Israel since 2014—well before she was unjustly given a UN position. This entire Commission's supposed neutrality is nothing more than a facade, built on a foundation of pre-existing anti-Israel rhetoric.

See Navi Pillay record Navi Pillay Archives - UN Watch
There is definitely a lot of hate in the UN for Israel.

The issue is that Israel has basically only one reliable partner in America. There is now pressure within countries in the M.E to walk away from the Abraham Accord so they remain isolated.

The sooner this war ends the better, regardless of any of the usual U.N decisions. Even when Israel left Gaza two decades ago the U.N was still blaming them for Palestinian government failures. Then it turns out they were spending billions to build massive elaborate tunnels.
 
How to prove it is not a war, but a "genocide":

Create a report which entirely erases the military force and actions of the belligerent. In a conflict between two opposing forces, make one invisible.
 
A reminder: "davebb" is one of 60 accounts by Hondo_50.
 
How to prove it is not a war, but a "genocide":

Create a report which entirely erases the military force and actions of the belligerent. In a conflict between two opposing forces, make one invisible.
Pretty much so.
 
You can tell it to the judge.
An independent one or an israelophobic one?

___


1. ’Canada rejects genocide allegation made against Israel,’ 'Toronto Star', January 12, 2024. [Justin Trudeau breaks silence over Canada’s position on Israel genocide allegations]

2. ’Germany Rejects UN ’Genocide’ Charge Against Israel,’ 'AFP via Barron’s', January 12, 2024. [Germany Rejects UN 'Genocide' Charge Against Israel]

3. ’France Rejects Genocide Accusations Against Israel in Gaza,’ 'New York Times', January 17, 2024. [https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/17/world/middleeast/france-israel-genocide-gaza.html]

4. ’UK Government Rejects Determination of Israeli ’Genocide’ in Gaza,’ 'Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD)', September 11, 2025. [https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/0...ts-determination-of-israeli-genocide-in-gaza/]

5. ’Austin: No proof Israel is committing genocide,’ 'Jewish News Syndicate (JNS)', April 9, 2024. [https://www.jns.org/austin-no-proof-israel-committing-genocide/]

6. Salo Aizenberg, ’A strong consensus has formed: there is no genocide in Gaza,’ 'X (formerly Twitter)', May 20, 2025. []

7. Nitsana Darshan-Leitner, ’International law scholar: There is no genocide in Gaza,’ 'Jerusalem Post', July 28, 2025. [International law scholar: There is no genocide in Gaza | The Jerusalem Post]

8. ’5 Reasons Why the Events in Gaza Are Not ’Genocide’,’ 'American Jewish Committee (AJC)', July 22, 2025. [5 Reasons Why the Events in Gaza Are Not “Genocide”]

9. Rachel O’Donoghue, ’I’m a Genocide Scholar... And I’ve Been Prepping My NYT Genocide Case Against Israel for Years,’ 'Honest Reporting', July 17, 2025. [“I’m a Genocide Scholar”… And I’ve Been Prepping My NYT Genocide Case Against Israel for Years | HonestReporting]

10. Jeremy Sharon, Jacob Magid, and ToI Staff, ’Predetermined conclusions: Amnesty Israel workers slam parent group’s ’genocide’ charge,’ 'Times of Israel', December 5, 2024. [‘Predetermined conclusions’: Amnesty Israel workers slam parent group’s ‘genocide’ charge]

11. ’Yad Vashem rejects genocide allegation against Israel,’ 'JNS via Columbus Jewish News', July 28, 2025. [Yad Vashem rejects genocide allegation against Israel]

12. Bernard-Henri Lévy, ’There Is No ’Genocide’ in Gaza,’ 'New York Sun', November 21, 2024. [There Is No ‘Genocide’ in Gaza]

13. ’There is no starvation in Gaza caused by Israel, Hamas at fault: Consul general,’ 'NewsNation', July 29, 2025. []

14. Charlie Kirk, ’No, Israel is NOT Starving Gazans: Debunking the Latest Propaganda Attacks Against Israel,’ 'Facebook Video', July 28, 2025. []

15. ’They’re in a war there’: Trump rejects claims of genocide in Gaza,’ 'The Jewish Chronicle', August 4, 2025. [‘They’re in a war there’: Trump rejects claims of genocide in Gaza - The Jewish Chronicle]

16. Dennis Prager, ’The word ’genocide’ is losing its meaning,’ 'Facebook', May 31, 2025. []

17. Alan Dershowitz, ’Why ’Gaza genocide’ claims equal Holocaust denial,’ 'New York Post', July 15, 2025. [There is no ‘genocide’ in Gaza — why the claim equals Holocaust denial]

18. Maïa de La Baume, ’There is no clear intent to commit genocide in Gaza, top international law expert says,’ 'Euro News', August 1, 2025. [There is no clear intent to commit genocide in Gaza, law expert says]

19. ’New study debunks Gaza genocide claims, finds flaws in UN, int'l reporting on war,’ 'Jerusalem Post', August 3, 2025. [Israel-Gaza genocide claims debunked, study finds | The Jerusalem Post]

20. Joe Brown, ’Want to be a renowned genocide scholar? Pay $30,’ 'i24NEWS', September 3, 2025. [https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/israel/diplomacy/artc-want-to-be-a-renowned-genocide-scholar-pay-30]

* [https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveb...lars-group-retract-accusation-against-israel/ The Times of Israel] – "More than 500 experts sign demand that genocide scholars group retract accusation against Israel" (September 9, 2025)
*
[https://www.camera.org/article/abcs-selective-and-one-sided-coverage-of-the-iags-genocide-libel/ CAMERA] – "ABC’s Selective and One-Sided Coverage of the IAGS Genocide Libel" (September 5, 2025)

* [https://www.timesofisrael.com/genoc...d-through-israel-condemnation-without-debate/ The Times of Israel] – "Genocide scholar says group pushed through Israel condemnation without debate" (September 2, 2025)

* [https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/charade-academic-garb The Washington Institute] – "The Charade of Academic Garb" (September 2, 2025)

* [https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/israel/diplomacy/artc-want-to-be-a-renowned-genocide-scholar-pay-30 i24 News] – "Want to be a renowned genocide scholar? Pay $30" (September 3, 2025)

* [https://themedialine.org/top-storie...resolution-but-global-media-missed-the-story/ The Media Line] – "Only 28% of Scholars Association’s Members Voted on Gaza Genocide Resolution, but Global Media Missed the Story" (September 4, 2025)
'
* [https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/the-pr-jihad/ The Times of Israel Blogs] – "The PR Jihad" (September 7, 2025).
'The International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS) membership criteria was exposed on X by Salo Aizenberg of Honest Reporting. Soon after, people began joining under fake names, real names, their pets joined, and even “Adolf Hitler” joined. Actual genocide scholar, Professor Mia Bloom, Ph.D., one of the founding members of IAGS, and others, exposed the voting process as a sham vote without transparency, without the standard debate, and any dissent was blocked.'

21. Imogen Garfinkel, ’Dismissing October 7 Gang Rape and Comparing Israel to the Third Reich: Who is UN ‘Special Rapporteur’ Francesca Albanese?,’ 'The JC', November 28, 2024. [https://web.archive.org/web/2024112...pecial-rapporteur-francesca-albanese-mc3h514n]

22. Human Rights Expert: 'Francesca Albanese uses Nazi textbook to produce Oct. 7 denial'. 'Human Rights Voices', July 9, 2025.
[https://hrvoices.org/?post_type=article&p=393985]

23. [https://unwatch.org/tag/navi-pillay/ Navi Pillay Archives - UN Watch]

24. 'UN Watch Rebuttal: Legal Analysis of Pillay Commission’s September 2025 Report to Human Rights Council.'
'QUN Watch', September 16, 2025. [https://unwatch.org/un-watch-rebutt...eptember-2025-report-to-human-rights-council/]

25. 'The only thing being genocided in Gaza is truth itself.'
"We are living through the largest propaganda assault in modern history."
Andrew Fox, 'Israel National News', Sep 16, 2025. [https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/415019]

26. 'UN panel that determined genocide in Gaza made up of ‘Hamas proxies,’ Israel says.'
"A new U.N. report relies “entirely on Hamas falsehoods, laundered and repeated by others,” without identifying Hamas as the problem, critics say."
Mike Wagenheim, 'JNS', September 17, 2025.
[https://www.jns.org/un-panel-that-determined-genocide-in-gaza-made-up-of-hamas-proxies-israel-says/]

27. 'The U.N. Genocide Report Against Israel Is an Assault on Critical Thinking.'
John Spencer, 'Washington Free Beacon'.
September 17, 2025
[https://freebeacon.com/israel/the-u...st-israel-is-an-assault-on-critical-thinking/]

28. 'Pretending that Hamas does not exist
To the UN, Hamas’s attempts at genocide are completely justified, while Israelis commit genocide just by living.'
Gary Willig. 'Israel National News'. September 18, 2025.
[https://www.israelnationalnews.com/tags/50035]

29. 'German Chancellor: Israel’s actions in Gaza do not amount to genocide.'
Elad Benari. 'Israel National News', Sep 19, 2025.
[https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/415177]
 
Last edited:
"John_U" - "Hondo_50" SP account number 63.
chrome_screenshot_Sep 19, 2025 6_58_01 PM EDT.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom