The SC saved trump from his worst impulses.

berg80

Diamond Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2017
Messages
25,045
Reaction score
21,016
Points
2,320

Supreme Court, for Now, Blocks Deportations of Venezuelan Migrants​

The Supreme Court temporarily blocked the Trump administration early Saturday from deporting another group of Venezuelan migrants accused of being gang members under the expansive powers of a rarely invoked wartime law.

“The government is directed not to remove any member of the putative class of detainees from the United States until further order of this court,” the court said in a brief, unsigned order that gave no reasoning, as is typical in emergency cases.

Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr. dissented. The White House did not issue any immediate response.

More than 50 Venezuelans were scheduled to be flown out of the country — presumably to El Salvador — from an immigration detention center in Anson, Texas, according to two people with knowledge of the situation. The A.C.L.U. in recent days had already secured court orders barring similar deportations under the law, the Alien Enemies Act, in other places including New York, Denver and Brownsville, Texas.


Don essentially forced the Court in to a corner. How could it allow for the deportation of more human beings when it already ruled Garcia's return must be facilitated?

The fact that the regime was on a path to doing it before it was stopped displays just how willing trump is to openly defy existing court orders.

It's making me wonder if the immunity ruling has resulted in him feeling completely unaccountable for any action he takes. As for members of the regime, they know they will be protected from prosecution by the pardon power. All of which makes for the kind of lawlessness we have seen thus far.

The judiciary's enforcement power of its rulings is essentially non-existent. It depends on the regime's respect for the constitutional order that has governed the nation since we declared our independence. Respect it has shown it does not have. Which is why this thing could really go sideways.
 

Supreme Court, for Now, Blocks Deportations of Venezuelan Migrants​

The Supreme Court temporarily blocked the Trump administration early Saturday from deporting another group of Venezuelan migrants accused of being gang members under the expansive powers of a rarely invoked wartime law.
.
Let e guess...LIBs are all for those laws now.

Surely you remember just last week OMB used one to deport / wanna deport a Palli.
 
At least its the USSC and not some piss ant district judge.
As Boasberg points out in his most recent opinion, lower court rulings must be obeyed until such time as they are overruled. Your dismissive rhetoric doesn't change the constitutional order that's been followed for two centuries.
 
.
Let e guess...LIBs are all for those laws now.

Surely you remember just last week OMB used one to deport / wanna deport a Palli.
Surely there's a better use of your time than shitting all over yourself as you do each time you write a post.
 
At least its the USSC and not some piss ant district judge.
So what does ICE do with the gang members? Put them in US prisons until they get a hearing?
If they’re actually gang members… prove it in a court of law and THEN deport them.

Half of the people sent to that El Salvador jail were not gang members
 
If they’re actually gang members… prove it in a court of law and THEN deport them.

Half of the people sent to that El Salvador jail were not gang members
I wonder if it has occurred to trumples that the point of invoking the AEA is trump knew he could not legally deport a significant number of those men if he gave them a hearing. So because he wanted them gone he tried to create a legal pretense for deporting them. It failed.
 
MS13 is a very important Democrat Party constituency group
In fact, criminals in general are a Democrat voting bloc.
The Democrats want MS13 to help them to turn our country into third world banana republic.
 
As Boasberg points out in his most recent opinion, lower court rulings must be obeyed until such time as they are overruled. Your dismissive rhetoric doesn't change the constitutional order that's been followed for two centuries.
District courts have no Constitutional authority, only the USSC does. They are now blatantly political.
Congress and the USSC need to put district courts back in their districts to limit their authority.
Trump needs to ignore them until the USSC rules on the district courts.
Lets make a Constitutional Crisis to settle this once and for all.
 
District courts have no Constitutional authority
Ridiculous. Only the SC can make decisions as to the constitutionality of laws or actions. But lower courts have the authority to enforce constitutional law. Their authority must be respected unless their rulings are reversed on appeal.
 
Ridiculous. Only the SC can make decisions as to the constitutionality of laws or actions. But lower courts have the authority to enforce constitutional law. Their authority must be respected unless their rulings are reversed on appeal.
Article 2 of the Constitution gives the President authority.
The Constitutional co-equal branch is the US Supreme Court, not district courts.
Lower courts can enforce Laws only in their districts.
Trump needs to create a Constitutional crisis by ignoring district judges and force the USSC to make a decision on district courts.
 
As Boasberg points out in his most recent opinion, lower court rulings must be obeyed until such time as they are overruled. Your dismissive rhetoric doesn't change the constitutional order that's been followed for two centuries.
The one thing Progs did do is cheapen life while making it more expensive.
 
Article 2 of the Constitution gives the President authority.
The Constitutional co-equal branch is the US Supreme Court, not district courts.
Lower courts can enforce Laws only in their districts.
Trump needs to create a Constitutional crisis by ignoring district judges and force the USSC to make a decision on district courts.
That’s not true. Conservative have always use lower court rules to enforce anti-abortion rulings nationally.
 

Supreme Court, for Now, Blocks Deportations of Venezuelan Migrants​

The Supreme Court temporarily blocked the Trump administration early Saturday from deporting another group of Venezuelan migrants accused of being gang members under the expansive powers of a rarely invoked wartime law.

“The government is directed not to remove any member of the putative class of detainees from the United States until further order of this court,” the court said in a brief, unsigned order that gave no reasoning, as is typical in emergency cases.

Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr. dissented. The White House did not issue any immediate response.

More than 50 Venezuelans were scheduled to be flown out of the country — presumably to El Salvador — from an immigration detention center in Anson, Texas, according to two people with knowledge of the situation. The A.C.L.U. in recent days had already secured court orders barring similar deportations under the law, the Alien Enemies Act, in other places including New York, Denver and Brownsville, Texas.


Don essentially forced the Court in to a corner. How could it allow for the deportation of more human beings when it already ruled Garcia's return must be facilitated?

The fact that the regime was on a path to doing it before it was stopped displays just how willing trump is to openly defy existing court orders.

It's making me wonder if the immunity ruling has resulted in him feeling completely unaccountable for any action he takes. As for members of the regime, they know they will be protected from prosecution by the pardon power. All of which makes for the kind of lawlessness we have seen thus far.

The judiciary's enforcement power of its rulings is essentially non-existent. It depends on the regime's respect for the constitutional order that has governed the nation since we declared our independence. Respect it has shown it does not have. Which is why this thing could really go sideways.
Stop being so dramatic.

Trump will go the Biden route of having a policy "shut down" by the USSC, but them immediately finding another way to do the same thing, while claiming to be following the letter of the ruling.

That's how determined Biden was that welders, Uber drivers, waitresses, and airport baggage handlers be forced to pay for his constituents' degrees in Gender Studies, and Russian Literature.

That's how determined Donald Trump is to rid the country of the violent thugs Biden imported while arranging for student loan deadbeats to vote Democrat forever.
 

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom